Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Rajib Chakraborty & Anr. v. The Inspector General Of Registration & Ors.

Calcutta High Court
Apr 20, 2012

Ashoke Kumar Dasadhikari, J.:— This is second writ petition filed by the writ petitioner questioning the order passed by the Commissioner, Presidency Division in Appeal Case No. 46 of 2004-05 being the appeal under Section 47B(i) of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 against the order dated 11th October, 2004 of the Collector of D.I.G, RR-I, South 24-Parganas deciding the market value of a property P-75A, Lake Road, Kolkata-700 029.

The relevant facts of this case is that the writ petitioners have purchased 4/5 share of the property at P-75A, Lake Road, Kolkata-700029 consisting of land measuring 3 cottah 1 chittack 31 sft. (2236 sft.) and a 4-storied building thereon covering an area of 3360 sft. for an amount of Rs. 1,50,000/-.

However, the respondent authorities by and under order dated 13 December, 2005 assessed the market value of the property in respect of its 4/5 share at the aforementioned address for an amount of Rs. 30,51,200/. The property was purchased by the appellant in the year 2004.

It was contended by Mr. Bhattacharya, learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner that 1/5 share of the property was purchased by the appellant in the year 2002 at a price of Rs. 37,500/- as fixed by the Sheristader of the Court in the Civil Suit filed by the appellant for specific performance of contract. Against such fixation by the concerned respondents the petitioners earlier filed an appeal before the Commissioner, Presidency Division and the appeal was rejected. Thereafter, against the order passed by the said Commissioner, the petitioner has filed a writ petition being W.P No. 5568(W) of 2006 which was heard and disposed of by the Hon'ble High Court and in the order dated 20 July, 2009 the learned Single Judge of this Hon'ble Court set aside the order passed by the Commissioner, Presidency Division and directed the concerned respondents to hear out the matter afresh and to assess the market value of the immovable property under reference strictly in accordance with the provisions of Rule 3 of the West Bengal Stamp (Prevention of Under-valuation of Instruments) Rules of 2001 as also taking into consideration the grounds set forth in the appeal by the petitioners within a period of eight weeks from the date of communication of this order.

Pursuant to such direction the present Commissioner, Presidency Division has decided the valuation of the property upon giving opportunity to the petitioner.

Mr. Bhattacharya submits that the concerned Commissioner did not follow the aforementioned rule as well as the grounds which were to be considered by him. He submitted that in the year 2002 in a court sale 1/5 share of the property was purchased by the applicants at a consideration of Rs. 37,500/- which was determined by the Sheristader of the Court, upon reference by the concerned Judge deciding the suit for specific performance.

Mr. Bhattacharya submitted that Rule 3 is clear and specific as regards the amendment of valuation. He submits that for determination of market value the concerned authority can make a comparative assessment considering similarity in nature of area and comparable locality and also from the records of any court or any officer. In the instant case the concerned officer did not follow mandate under Rule 3 of the West Bengal Stamp (Prevention of Under-valuation of Instruments) Rules of 2001.

Mr. Bhattacharya submits that the concerned officer has taken a deed bearing No. 4398 of 1997 of a land which is very close to the said land situated in the same locality but the nature of the building, the occupancy of the building whether tenanted or not all these materials were not considered and therefore, following the valuation made for the said building in the year 1997 may not be a basis for determination of the valuation. He submitted the concerned officer ought to have followed the court's determination as regards the valuation against which a deed was prepared and executed on the basis of the decree passed by the Civil Court in the year 2002.

Mr. Bhattacharya submitted that the entire exercise is contrary to the provisions under Section 2(16B) of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 and Rule 3 of the West Bengal Stamp (Prevention of Under-valuation of Instruments) Rules of 2001. He submits that the impugned order is without any reason and the same should be set aside and the matter be referred back to the concerned officer for re-determination of valuation.

Mr. Bhattacharya cited a decision reported in A.I.R 1997 Madras 296 (S.P Padmavathi v. State of Tamil Nadu) in support of his submission that the valuation should be made following the Court's decision.

Mr. Chakraborty, learned Counsel appearing for the State submitted that the determination in this case is strictly in accordance with rules giving the method of determination of market value. He submits that Rule 3 of the said Rules is specific thereby giving guidelines in determination of the present market value by considering various factors.

In the instant case the concerned officer has taken note of the sale deed executed in the year 1997 wherein the other land situated in the same locality has been assessed at Rs. 8 lacs per katha and he has observed that the land value of the locality is appreciating. The property is situated in a posh area. He also submitted that in similar circumstance while considering Rule 3 with Section 2(16B) of the said Rule this Hon'ble Court in case of State of West Bengal v. Sati Enclave Pvt. Ltd., reported in 2010 (2) C.L.J (Cal) page 197 has come to a conclusion that the registering officer can always consider the other sale instances or any other material reflecting higher value of the property.

Mr. Chakraborty submitted that in the aforementioned Special Bench judgement is based on the Apex Court's judgement reported in 1974 (2) S.C.C 213 (Kayjay Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. Asnew Drums (P) Ltd.). He submitted that the concerned officer very carefully considered the land value of the locality and on that basis decided to value the land at the same price which was prevailing in the year 1997 whereas the present deed was executed in the year 2004.

He submitted in between this period there is much appreciation of value of land and building in the locality but the concerned officer has accepted the old valuation. He also submitted that in view of the Special Bench judgement the order passed by the concerned officer is lawful and valid. He further submitted that the power and authority of the Writ Court is to consider the decision making process but not the decision.

He cited another judgement reported in A.I.R 1989 S.C 1642 paragraph 31 (Dwarkadas Marfatia and sons v. Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay). He also submitted that this Hon'ble Court sitting in writ jurisdiction should not assess the valuation of the property in question specially when the concerned officer has taken care of all the aspects of the matter while determining the valuation on the basis of the sale deed which was executed in the year 1997.

Mr. Bhattacharya in reply submitted that the decision of the Civil Court in this regard is squarely applicable in the instant case. He reiterated that the valuation was made by this court and concerned officer ought to have given weightage and consideration of the aforementioned valuation on the basis of which the deed was executed in the year 2002. He submitted that the matter should be referred back to the concerned officer for re-determination.

Heard the learned Counsel appearing for the respective parties. The grievance of the writ petitioner in this writ petition is that determination of the market value of the property in question was not done in terms of the Rule 3 of the West Bengal Stamp (Prevention of Under-valuation of Instruments) Rules of 2001 as well as under Section 2(16B) of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899. Rule 3 of the aforementioned Rules reads as follows:-

“3. Manner of determination of market value and furnishing of particulars relating to any property. - (1) The market value within the meaning of clause (16B) of section 2 in relation to any land or any land with building shall, after taking into consideration the particulars referred with building shall, after taking into consideration the particulars referred to in sub-rule (2), be determined on the basis of the highest price for which sale of any land, or any land with building, of similar nature and area, in a comparable locality, has been negotiated and settled during the five consecutive years immediately preceding the date of execution of any instrument setting forth such market value, or on the basis of any court decision, information, report or record that may be available from any court or any officer or authority of the Central Government or the State Government or any local authority or local body, or on the basis of consideration stated in such instrument for the sale of such land or land with building, whichever is greater.”

Sub-Section (16B) of Section 2 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 reads as follows:-

“(16B) ‘Market value’ means, in relation to any property which is the subject-matter of an instrument, the price which such property would have fetched or would fetch if sold in open market on the date of execution of such instrument as determined in such manner and by such authority as may be prescribed by rules made under this Act or the consideration stated in the instrument, whichever is higher.”

The Special Bench of this Hon'ble Court while determining the method of valuation has decided on the issue and explained the aforementioned rule as well as the provision for determination of the current market value of the property. Relevant paragraph of the Sati Enclave Pvt. Ltd's case (supra) reads as follows:-

“50. The observations may certainly be relevant in order to show that the price fetched at a public auction conducted by the Court may not be the best available price. However, when the authorities are considering market value of the property, which is sold at a private sale, sale price of another property or even of the same property fetched at a Court auction without hearing the Government is not to be taken as one of the materials to be considered by the authority under Rule 3(1) of the Undervaluation Rules. Hence, even if the property at a Court sale does not fetch the highest or best available price, if there are other pieces of evidence of market value of similar properties available in the area, while exercising the powers under Section 47A(1)(2) read with Section 2(16B) of the Act and Rule 3 of the Undervaluation Rules of 2001 in relation to a private sale, the registering officer can always consider the other sale instances or any other material reflecting higher value of the property.”

I have gone through the order passed by the concerned officer. The concerned officer is very carefully considered the entire aspects of the matter and has taken the land value at the rate of Rs. 8 lacs on the basis of deed No. 4398 of 1997 in which valuation of a land of the locality of the Lake Road was taken and he has considered the claim and contention of the writ petitioner that 1/5 share of the same property which was assessed by the Sheristadar of a Civil Court Rs. 37,500/- cannot be treated as basis for determination of appropriate market value of 4/5 share of the property at P-75, Lake Road, Kolkata-700029 consisting of measuring 3 cottah 1 chittack 31 sft. and a 4-storied building therein covering an area of 3360 sft. He has come to a conclusion that determination and/or valuation done by the Sheristadar is not a determination of the Court, specially when the issue of valuation was not the subject-matter of the suit.

According to him, the valuation of the Sheristadar is not at all a proper valuation. However, he has assessed the land value as well as the value of structure and allowing 15% depreciation since property is fully tenanted and thus decided the property value at Rs. 23,63,680/-.

In my view, the valuation made by the concerned officer on the basis of a deed executed and registered in the year 1997 wherein land of the same locality was assessed is correctly made and there is no illegality in such determination. It is relevant to mention that the Special Bench has already held that the registering officer can always consider the other sale instances or any other material reflecting higher value of the property. In that case, although the property was sold in auction but a dispute arose as regards the determination of the valuation and this Hon'ble Court has settled the law. In my view, the ratio of the aforementioned judgement delivered by Special Bench of this Hon'ble Court is applicable in the instant case. It appears that the concerned officer has considered the matter and has come to a definite conclusion determining the higher value of the property. I do not find any illegality and/or irregularity in such determination.

In view of my aforesaid findings the writ petition is dismissed. There would be no order as to costs.