- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Binod Kumar Sinha Binod Sinha Petitioner v. The State Of Jharkhand Through C.B.I Opposite Party
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned Standing Counsel for the CBI.
The petitioner has been made accused for the offence under Sections 409, 420, 423, 424, 465, 120(B) of the Indian Penal Code and Sections 7, 10, 11 and 13 of the Prevention of Corruption Act. Charge sheet has also been filed after investigation by the CBI on 12.11.2010 under Sections 120(B) of the Indian Penal Code read with Section 9 and Section 13(2) read with 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act against the petitioner and other co-accused. So far as other allegations against the accused persons are concerned, the investigation is continuing against the petitioner and others also.
It appears from the charge sheet that a complaint dated 1.7.2009 was made by one Rajiv Sharma before the Special Judge, Vigilance, Ranchi against Madhu Koda, Ex-Chief Minister, Kamlesh Singh, Ex-Minister, Bhanu Pratap Shahi, Ex-Minister and Bandhu Tirkey, Ex-Minister of the State of Jharkhand, which was forwarded by the Special Judge to the Officer-in-Charge, Vigilance Police Station for institution and investigation of the case. Accordingly, F.I.R No. 9 of 2009 was registered by the Vigilance Department on 2.7.2009
It further appears that one W.P (PIL) No. 4700 of 2008 relating to the similar issues was filed in this Court and this Court by order dated 4.8.2010 transferred the matter for investigation to the CBI, on the basis of which, the present case was instituted against the accused persons on transfer from the Vigilance Department.
In this case, there is allegation against the petitioner to be close associate of Madhu Koda, the then Chief Minister of the State of Jharkhand and in collusion with Madhu Koda, he got large number of mines allotted to his own company and his henchmen. It is also alleged that Madhu Koda and this petitioner amassed huge property with the assistance and in connivance of this petitioner, valued at several crores of rupees.
The present charge sheet shows that it relates to specific instances of illegal gratification obtained by this petitioner and one Sanjay Choudhary on behalf of Madhu Koda by exercise of their personal influence on him to the tune of Rs. 13 crores from M/s Core Group of Industries of Mumbai for getting iron ore mines allotted in Jharkhand. There is allegation in this charge sheet that the petitioner and Sanjay Choudhary were exercising their personal influence on the then Chief Minister Madhu Koda in the matter of allotment of iron mines to Core Group of Industries and they demanded heavy illegal gratification for the same in the name of Madhu Koda and they actually received Rs. 13 crors from the said Company on different dates. It is alleged that the said amount was invested by them in an upcoming mall project at Jamshedpur. The investigation had revealed that payment of Rs. 13 crores was made by different cheques given by M/s Core Group of Industries Ltd. to Sanjay Choudhary and this petitioner. It is further alleged in the charge sheet that the petitioner started making excessive demand by way of asking for shares in the company, whereupon, the Core Group of Industries Ltd., gave up the hope of the allotment of the mines and demanded the money back, where upon Rs. 5.35 cores was returned back by co-accused Sanjay Choudhary, but rest of the money was not returned back to M/s Core Group of Company and accordingly, on the basis of these materials collected during investigation, charge sheet was filed against the petitioner under Section 120(B) of the Indian Penal Code read with Section 9 and Section 13(2) read with 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. This charge sheet is confined only to the allegation of illegal gratification obtained by the petitioner and Sanjay Choudhary from M/s Core Group of Industries and so far as the other allegations of amassing huge property, movable and immovable, inside and outside the Country, the investigation is still going on.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the petitioner has been falsely implicated in this case. The petitioner is in custody since 17.9.2010 and other co-accused persons, namely, Madhu Koda and Kamlesh Singh have already been granted bail. Learned counsel has accordingly, prayed for the release of the petitioner on bail.
Learned Standing Counsel for the CBI, on the other hand, has opposed the prayer for bail, submitting that there is direct allegation against the petitioner and other co-accused Sanjay Choudhary to have directly dealt with M/s Core Group of Industries Ltd. and to have obtained illegal gratification of Rs. 13 crores for getting iron mines allotted in their favour and the greed of the petitioner did not stop there, rather, he made further demand of shares in the company, whereupon the Company decided to withdraw and demanded the money back, but only Rs. 5.35 cores was returned to the Company and rest of the money was not returned to the Company. Learned counsel further submitted that there are other allegations also against this petitioner to have purchased landed properties for several cores of rupees and also to invest the money outside and inside the Country, for which, investigation is still going on and co-accused Sanjay Choudhary could not be apprehended till date due to the fact that he is in Dubai, for which, extradition process is being pursued by the CBI.
After having heard learned counsels for both parties and upon going through the record, I find that there are serious charges against the petitioner of being directly involved in taking illegal gratification to the tune of Rs. 13 crores from M/s Core Group of Industries Ltd. on the pretext of getting iron ore mines allotted to the said Company. I further find that charge sheet, which has been filed in this case, is confined to this allegation only, but there are other serious allegations also against the petitioner of amassing huge property inside and outside the Country, for which further investigation is still going on.
In view of the serious and direct allegations against the petitioner, I am not inclined to release the petitioner, Binod Kumar Sinha @ Binod Sinha, on bail. Accordingly, his prayer for bail is rejected.
Alert