Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Smt. Sugni Devi & Others.

Rajasthan High Court
Aug 24, 2012
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act against the judgment and award dated 12.04.2012 of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (I), Jodhpur, which granted compensation of Rs. 24,44,798/-. The accident occurred on 11.08.2010: Shri Babu Lal Choudhary (deceased) was riding motorcycle No. RJ 19-19M-0323 towards his residence at Bera Poliyawas when another motorcycle (No. RJ19-SH-3846), driven by Shri Suresh Nath, allegedly collided with him. Babu Lal sustained severe injuries and died subsequently. The claimants (family of the deceased) filed a claim petition before the MACT and an FIR was registered; a police investigation resulted in a charge-sheet against Suresh Nath. The Tribunal awarded compensation after considering the deceased’s salary, applying statutory deductions and a multiplier.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the accident occurred solely due to the negligence of Shri Suresh Nath or whether there was contributory negligence by the deceased (i.e., whether contributory negligence should reduce or defeat liability).
  2. Whether the insurer of the offending vehicle (No. RJ 19-SH-3846) was properly impleaded in the proceedings.
  3. Whether the Tribunal correctly assessed the deceased’s income for computation of compensation (including the correctness of the monthly income taken, the deductions applied, the multiplier used), and whether family pension or similar receipts should have been deducted from the compensation.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The accident involved contributory negligence by the deceased — the site plan (Exhibit-4) prepared by the police and the FIR indicate the accident took place at the centre of the road; the Tribunal failed to consider these materials and certain witness statements (e.g., Shri Mangi Lal and Shri Chena Ram were not produced despite being named in the FIR).
  • The Tribunal wrongly decided issue No.1 solely because a charge-sheet was filed against the respondent-driver; the Tribunal did not properly frame or decide the contributory negligence point based on the site plan and relevant witnesses.
  • The insurance company of the offending vehicle was not impleaded as a party to the litigation.
  • The deceased’s income (assessed at Rs. 29,160/- per month) was incorrectly assessed; pensionary benefits (family pension) available to the claimants were not deducted from the compensation calculation.

Respondents' / Caveator's Arguments

  • The site plan was prepared many days after the occurrence and the witnesses who signed it (Suresh and Ashok) stated their signatures were taken on blank paper; therefore the site plan is unreliable and cannot be relied upon to establish contributory negligence.
  • AW 1 (Shri Sumer Singh) appeared as an eyewitness and gave oral evidence that supports the claimants' case; no successful rebuttal evidence was produced by the appellant/insurer to establish contributory negligence.
  • Reliance was placed upon judicial authority to submit that, in the absence of material, no deduction for family pension should be made when computing compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act; the respondents also relied on precedent to argue that life insurance/family pension are distinct from compensation under the Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation v. Kumudavalli, 2005 ACJ 1598 Principle cited by respondents' counsel that, in the absence of material on record, no deduction with respect to receipt of family pension can be made. The case was relied upon by respondents' counsel in argument summarising that family pension should not be deducted where no material shows receipt; the Court recorded that this principle was invoked by respondents in their submissions.
Helen C. Rebello (Mrs.) v. Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation, (1999) 1 SCC 90 Held that family pension and other receipts like provident fund or life insurance are not correlative to compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act and thus are not to be treated as "pecuniary advantage" for the purpose of deduction from statutory compensation. The Court expressly relied on and quoted this Apex Court decision to reject the appellant’s submission that family pension should be deducted; the judgment was applied to hold that family pension has no necessary nexus with compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act and therefore cannot be deducted absent specific evidence.
Gurdeep Kaur v. Tarsem Singh, 2009 ACJ 314 (Single Bench, Punjab & Haryana High Court) Illustration that tribunals may not place significance on site plans and photographs prepared after accidents because they may not reflect positions at the time of accident; reliance used to show a tribunal's finding based principally on a site plan can be set aside. The Court noted this authority as a judicial recognition of the limited value of post-accident site plans/photographs; the opinion used the same reasoning to treat the site plan in the present case as unreliable where signatures were said to have been taken on blank paper and the plan was prepared later.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the evidence and submissions in a sequential manner focused on three main strands: the reliability of the site plan and contributory negligence, the evidentiary picture (witness testimony and charge-sheet), and the computation of compensation (income, deductions, multiplier and family pension).

On the question of contributory negligence, the Court examined the site plan (Ex.4) and the statements of witnesses who were said to have signed it. Two witnesses (Chandra Prakash and Ashok) stated that the signatures on Ex.4 were taken by police on blank papers and that the site plan was not prepared in their presence. This factual assertion rendered the site plan doubtful. The Court emphasized that the site plan was prepared much later and that a post-accident site plan which is not contemporaneous cannot be relied upon to establish contributory negligence. The Court also noted that strict rules of Civil Procedure Code and the Evidence Act are not applied rigidly in MACT proceedings; the Tribunal must adopt procedures consonant with natural justice and the pragmatic needs of claims adjudication.

The Court further considered the investigative record: a police investigation was conducted and a charge-sheet was filed against Suresh Nath. While recognizing that a charge-sheet is not conclusive proof of guilt, the Court treated it as a contextual factor. More importantly, the Court assessed the oral evidence: AW 1 (Shri Sumer Singh) testified that the offending motorcycle overtook and hit the motorcycle ridden by the deceased; there was no cogent rebuttal evidence produced by the appellant/insurer to establish contributory negligence. Taken together — the doubtful site plan, eyewitness testimony in favour of the claimants, the lack of rebuttal evidence, and the charge-sheet — the Court concluded the accident resulted from rash and negligent driving by Suresh Nath.

On the compensation computation, the Court accepted the Tribunal's use of the salary record (Ex.10) which showed Rs. 29,160/- per month for the deceased in July 2010. The Court set out the arithmetic adopted by the Tribunal: annualizing the salary, adjusting for taxation (as explained in the award), deducting one-third for personal expenses of the deceased, determining the family dependency figure, applying a multiplier of 11 (appropriate for a 51-year-old deceased), and adding Rs. 18,000/- under other heads — arriving at the total award of Rs. 24,44,798/-. The Court found no fault with these calculations and held the multiplier and deductions to be "just and fair" in the facts of the case.

Regarding family pension, the Court observed there was no evidence that the family was in receipt of pension. Even on the legal point, the Court relied on the Apex Court’s authority in Helen C. Rebello to hold that family pension (and similar receipts) do not bear necessary correlation with compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act and therefore cannot be deducted from compensation unless there is evidence and a legal basis to do so. The Court thus rejected the appellant’s submission that family pension should be taken into account.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED. The appeal is dismissed and the impugned award of Rs. 24,44,798/- passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal on 12.04.2012 is upheld.

Implications:

  • The Tribunal's factual findings — that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of Shri Suresh Nath and not because of contributory negligence by the deceased — are affirmed based on the testimonial record and the unreliability of the site plan.
  • The Tribunal's computation of compensation (salary evidence, deduction of one-third for personal expenses, multiplier of 11, and additional heads) is sustained; the total award of Rs. 24,44,798/- remains payable as ordered.
  • With respect to family pension and similar receipts, the Court followed the Apex Court's pronouncement in Helen C. Rebello and declined to deduct family pension in the absence of evidence showing receipt; the decision does not articulate any novel legal principle beyond applying existing authority in the factual matrix before it.

Note: This summary is strictly confined to the facts, arguments, citations and reasoning contained in the provided opinion and does not introduce any material not present in the source text.

Show all summary ...

BY THE COURT:

This is an appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act against the judgment and award dated 12.04.2012 passed by the Judge, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (I), Jodhpur vide which, an award of Rs. 24,44,798/- was granted.

The facts, in short, are that on 11.08.2010, one Shri Babu Lal Choudhary was travelling from his Motorcycle No. RJ 19-19M-0323 towards his resident at Bera Poliyawas. At that time, he met with an accident with another Motorcycle bearing No. RJ19-SH-3846 which was driven by one Shri Suresh Nath. On account of the said accident, the driver who was driving the Motorcycle No. RJ 19-19M-0323 i.e Shri Babu Lal sustained severe injuries and finally succumbed to the injuries received in the accident.

The claimants of the deceased Babulal Choudhary filed a claim petition before the MACT (First), Jodhpur and also got registered FIR. The matter was investigated and the charge-sheet was filed against the driver Suresh Nath. The deceased was a Senior Teacher in Khariya Mithapur Government School. Accordingly, the claimants raised claim of Rs. 50,50,000/-. After taking into consideration the salary of the deceased and by applying the deduction of 1/3rd, the total compensation, after applying multiplier of 11, was granted to tune of Rs. 24,44,798/-.

While challenging the impugned award, learned counsel for the appellant raised two-fold arguments. The first argument raised was that it was not the sole negligence of the driver Shri Suresh Nath but was a case of contributory negligence. It was submitted that the Tribunal did not consider the site plan (Exhibit-4) prepared by the police in which it is clearly shown that the accident took place on the centre of the road and neither the learned Tribunal has properly considered the statement of eye witness Shri Sumer Singh, AW 2 Shri Chander Prakash and AW 4 Ashok. In the reply filed by the Insurance Company, the specific plea was raised by the company that the accident took place on the centre of the road and deceased was also liable for contributory negligence but on this point, the learned Tribunal has not framed any issue. The claimants have not produced eye witness Shri Mangi Lal and Shri Chena Ram in the witness-box as they were present on the spot at the time of accident as per the FIR dated 11.08.2010 lodged by AW 1 Suresh Singh. There is a clear cut case of contributory negligence as per the FIR and site plan prepared by the Police. The learned Tribunal has wrongly decided the issue No. 1 only on the ground that the challan was filed against the respondent No. 5 Shri Suresh Nath.

Secondly, the Insurance Company of the vehicle No RJ 19-SH-3846 was not impleaded as a party to the litigation.

Lastly, the income of the deceased assessed Rs. 29,160/- per month was wrongly assessed as the pensionary benefits which shall be available to the claimants in spite of the death of the deceased Babu Lal Choudhary have not been deducted.

Learned counsel for the respondents-caveator, however, pointed out that the site plan was prepared after many days of the occurrence. The witnesses who signed the document, i.e, Suresh and Ashok deposed that their signatures were taken on blank paper. As such, the said site plan cannot be relied upon. Moreover, AW 1 Shri Sumer Singh appeared as eye witness. No other eye witness was produced by the respondents. There is no rebuttal evidence. The Insurance Company, therefore, could not prove any contributory negligence. Reliance was placed on the judgment rendered by the Division Bench of the Karnataka High Court in Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation v. Kumudavalli, reported in 2005 ACJ 1598 to state that in the absence of any material on record, no deduction with respect to the receipt of the family pension, if any, can be made. Judgment rendered by the Apex Court in Helen C. Rebello (Mrs.) v. Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation, reported in (1999) 1 SCC 90, was quoted to rebut the argument of the learned counsel for the appellant that the family pension to be received by the claimants on account of death of Babu Lal Choudhary should have been considered while calculating the income.

Heard.

In order to prove their case, the claimants produced AW 1 Shri Sumer Singh. Sumer Singh specifically stated in his statement that on 11.08.2010, at 12.30 p.m, when he was going on his motorcycle from Bilara to Jaipur, near Poliyawas, he saw that one motorcycle was coming from the opposite side and when he reached the gate after crossing the road, a Motorcycle No. RJ 19-SH-3846 came from its behind and by over taking him, hit the motorcycle coming from the opposite side. The motorcycle that was coming from behind, was being driven by Suresh Nath. He hit into the motorcycle being driven by Babu Lal, who died while being rushed to the hospital. Chandra Prakash was another witness. He specifically stated that A to B are his signatures over Ex.A/4. However, the said signatures were taken by the police on blank papers. Another witness Ashok too stated that Ex.4, which is the site plan, was not prepared in his presence. The statements made by the witnesses Suresh and Ashok that signatures on the site plan were obtained by the police on blank paper, are in itself sufficient to render the site plan doubtful. No reliance can be placed on such site plan. The Tribunal, therefore, rightly ignored the same. Even otherwise, it has not been disputed that the site plan was prepared much later. A site plan which is prepared subsequent to the accident, cannot be relied upon to conclude that the accident took place on account of the contributory negligence of the deceased. Moreover, in the present case, the matter was investigated and charge-sheet was submitted against Suresh Nath the driver of Motorcycle No RJ 19-SH-3846. Although, the filing of the charge-sheet is not a conclusive proof but in the facts of the present case, the oral evidence submitted by the witnesses coupled with the fact that there is no rebuttal evidence to the contrary proves that the accident took place on account of rash and negligence driving of the driver Suresh Nath.

The learned counsel for the respondents relied upon the judgment rendered by the Single Bench of Punjab & Haryana High Court in the case of Gurdeep Kaur v. Tarsem Singh, reported in 2009 ACJ 314, in which the High Court set aside the finding of the Tribunal as the same was based on the site plan. While doing so, the learned Single Bench held that, “the Tribunal also took into consideration the photographs and the site plan, Exh.PM, while coming to the conclusion that the accident took place on account of rash and negligent driving of the driver of the tractor-trolley. It may be stated here that no significance could be attached to the photographs, as it is a matter of common knowledge that after the accident, the vehicles do not remain in the same position in which the same was at the time of accident. Exh.PM, is only a rough site plan.”

Moreover, the strict principle of Civil Procedure Code and the Evidence Act are not applicable to the inquiries required to be made in the motor accidental claim cases. The Tribunal is required to evolve its own procedure which may be in consonance with the broad principles of natural justice. Thus, no fault can be found with the order and judgment passed by the Tribunal holding Suresh Nath as negligent. In view of the above, the argument of the learned counsel for the appellant that the site plan should be referred for concluding that there was contributory negligence cannot be sustained.

The second argument of the learned counsel for the appellant that income assessed is on the higher side, too has no merit. The date of birth of the deceased was 13.07.1959 Thus, the deceased was 51 years of age. As per the salary book Ex.10, the deceased was having salary of Rs. 29,160/- in July, 2010. The Tribunal calculated the income as under:-

29,160 × 12 = Rs. 3,49,920/-. In the year 2010-11 on the income of Rs. 1,60,000/- there is no tax and after that, tax is 10%. So, Rs. 3,49,920 - 1,60,000 = Rs. 1,89,920 its 10% i.e Rs. 18,992/-, deducting Rs. 18,992 from gross income Rs. 3,49,920/- actual income with tax is calculated Rs. 3,30,928/-. Reducing 1/3 of Rs. 3,30,928/-, i.e, Rs. 1,10,310/- the family dependency emerging comes to Rs. 2,20,618/- and applying the multiplier of 11, Rs. 2,20,618 × 11 it comes to Rs. 24,26,798/-. Another Rs. 18,000/- was given under different heads. The total comensation was assessed as Rs. 24,44,798/-. Thus, the deceased being 51 years of age, the multiplier of 11 is just and fair. Even though the deceased was survived by his wife, two sons and one daughter, the deduction at the rate of 1/3 as the expenditure incurred by him on himself was added. Thus, no fault can be found with the calculation which in accordance with law.

The argument that the family pension has not been considered, is not justified, inasmuch as, there is no evidence as to whether the family is in receipt of the pension or not. Even otherwise, the Apex Court in the case of Helen C. Rebello (Mrs.) v. Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation (Supra), while holding that the life insurance amount received by them was not deductible from the compensation computed under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, held that there was no relation between family pension and the accidental death. Para 35 of the said judgment reads as under:-

“35. Broadly, we may examine the receipt of the provident fund which is a deferred payment out of the contribution made by an employee during the tenure of his service. Such employee or his heirs are entitled to receive this amount irrespective of the accidental death. This amount is secured, is certain to be received, while the amount under the Motor Vehicles Act is uncertain and is receivable only on the happening of the event, viz., accident, which may not take place at all. Similarly, family pension is also earned by an employee for the benefit of his family in the form of his contribution in the service in terms of the service conditions receivable by the heirs after his death. The heirs receive family pension even otherwise than the accidental death. No corelation between the two. Similarly, life insurance policy is received either by the insured or the heirs of the insured on account of the contract with the insurer, for which the insured contributes in the form of premium. It is receivable even by the insured if he lives till maturity after paying all the premiums. In the case of death, the insurer indemnifies to pay the sum to the heirs, again in terms of the contract for the premium paid. Again, this amount is receivable by the claimant not on account of any accidental death but otherwise on the insured's death. Death is only a step or contingency in terms of the contract, to receive the amount. Similarly any cash, bank balance, shares, fixed deposits, etc. though are all a pecuniary advantage receivable by the heirs on account of one's death but all these have no corelation with the amount receivable under a statute occasioned only on account of accidental death. How could such an amount come within the periphery of the Motor Vehicles Act to be termed as “pecuniary advantage” liable for deduction. When we seek the principle of loss and gain, it has to be on a similar and same plane having nexus, inter se, between them and not to which there is no semblance of any corelation. The insured (deceased) contributes his own money for which he receives the amount which has no corelation to the compensation computed as against the tortfeasor for his negligence on account of the accident. As aforesaid, the amount receivable as compensation under the Act is on account of the injury or death without making any contribution towards it, then how can the fruits of an amount received through contributions of the insured be deducted out of the amount receivable under the Motor Vehicles Act. The amount under this Act he receives without any contribution. As we have said, the compensation payable under the Motor Vehicles Act is statutory while the amount receivable under the life insurance policy is contractual.”

Thus, the issue that the family pension should have been taken into consideration stands settled by the Apex Court in the above mentioned judgment.

In view of the above, there is no merit in this appeal. The same is dismissed.