- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dr. R.K Raisinghani v. The Secretary, Department Of Personnel & Others
Petitioner, in the writ petition, has prayed for relief that Rule No. 7 and 27 of the Rajasthan Medical and Health Service Rules, 1963 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Rules of 1963’) be declared ultra vires to the Constitution. Prayer has also been made for restraining the respondents from making reservation in promotions without making rules in pursuance of Article 16-4A of the Constitution and further to restrain the respondents from providing reservation in promotion without existence of compelling reasons with quantifiable data, as per decision of the Apex Court rendered in the case of M. Nagaraj v. Union of India, (2006) 8 SCC 212. It has further been prayed to direct the respondents to promote the petitioner to the post of Director and maintain his seniority qua the other employees and to strictly adhere to the roster system. Prayer has also been made to expunge communication dated 23.06.2007, communicating adverse entry for the year 2003-04 to the petitioner and to issue further direction for convening DPC meeting for quashment of result of the DPC meeting dated 26.03.2010, in which Respondent No. 5 was promoted to the post of Director.
Mr. Shobhit Tiwari, counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner has confined the prayer for promotion of the petitioner and to expunge adverse entry in the form of down grading recorded in ACR of the petitioner for the year 2003-04. He has not pressed rest of the prayers made in the petition and prayed for withdrawal of the same at this stage with liberty to file fresh petition, as and when decision is taken by the State Government pursuant to the decision dated 29.08.2012 rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Salauddin Ahmed v. Samta Andolan (Civil Appeal Nos. 2504-2505 of 2012).
Mr. Shobhit Tiwari, counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner has submitted that Reporting as well as Reviewing Officer have graded the performance of the petitioner for the year 2003-04 as outstanding i.e, excellent. However, the Accepting Authority has recorded the same to be average for the year 2003-04, on the ground that the petitioner was unable to control the spread of epidemic of Malaria in the city of Bikaner. He has submitted that down grading was communicated to the petitioner in the year 2007, but its sting stood wiped off, as the petitioner was promoted to the post of Additional Director from the post of Deputy Director on 25.09.2008, for which aforesaid record was taken into consideration. Though, again that record was required to be taken into consideration, when the matter came up for promotion for the post of Director, which is the highest post, on which promotion was required to be made on the basis of merit-cum-seniority, it could not constitute adverse material. The relevant record for consideration for the post of Director was of seven years of ACRs. It is further submitted that the petitioner was fulfilling the requisite criteria for promotion, which is of four very good ACRs. Thus, his case for promotion to the post of Director has been illegally ignored by the respondents.
Mr. Ashok Gaur, Senior Counsel appearing with Mr. Ajatshatru Mina, counsel on behalf of Respondent No. 5 and Mr. S.D Khaspuria, Additional Government Counsel appearing on behalf of other respondents have submitted that promotion to the post of Director, which is the highest post, was to be made on the basis of merit alone, as per the provisions contained in Rule 24A(7) of the Rules of 1963. Merit was the only criteria for promotion to the post in question and decision has been taken by Departmental Promotion Committee considering merits, which is unassailable. Even if the adverse entry or down grading of the petitioner for the year 2003-04 is not taken into consideration, in that case also, merit of Respondent No. 5 was far better than the petitioner.
The petitioner was communicated adverse entry/down grading in the ACR for the year 2003-04 in the year 2007. The petitioner did not question aforesaid adverse entry/down grading made by the Accepting Authority till the year 2010. Thus, writ petition filed with prayer for quashment of adverse entry made in ACR of the year 2003-04 is at belated stage and after the promotion exercise had been done by the DPC. The challenge was made by the petitioner belatedly, when the DPC had already held its meeting for promotion and the petitioner knew the consequence of the aforesaid adverse entry made in the year 2003-04. Even otherwise, we find that there is no merit in the submissions raised by counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner as post was to be filled on the basis of merits.
The post of Director, which is in question, is the highest post and it is required to be filled only on the basis of merit alone, as provided in Rule 24A(7) of the Rules of 1963. Rule 24A(7) of the Rules of 1963 is quoted below:
“[24A. Revised Criteria, Eligibility and Procedure for Promotion to Junior, Senior and other posts encadred in the Service.--………………..
[(7) Selection for promotion to the highest post/posts in the state service shall always be made on the basis of merit alone:
Provided that:
(a) in a service or groups or sections there-under where there are only two scales e.g junior scale or senior scale and there is only one-promotion then promotions shall be made on the basis of seniority-cum-merit alone.
(b) in a service or groups or sections there-under where there are three scales e.g junior scale, senior scale and selection scale and there are two promotions than promotions shall be as under:
(i) first promotion on the basis of seniority-cum-merit.
(ii) second promotion on the basis of seniority-cum-merit and merit in the proportions of 50:50.
(c) in services or groups or sections there-under, where there are more than two promotions then first promotion shall be made on the basis of seniority-cum-merit alone and promotions to subsequent higher posts shall be made on the basis of seniority-cum-merit and merit in the proportion of 50:50 except to the highest post.
[Provided further that if the Committee is satisfied that suitable persons are not available for selection by promotion to highest post/posts strictly on the basis of merit in a particular year, selection by promotion to highest post/posts on the basis of seniority-cum-merit may be made in the same manner as specified in these rules.]”
As the post of Director is the highest post of the Department, it was required to be filled up on the basis of merit alone. When we come to the comparative merits of the petitioner and Respondent No. 5, within the zone of consideration of seven years ACRs, as that was admittedly the basis for promotion to the post of Director, we find that the petitioner was having none of the ACRs as “Excellent”, whereas Respondent No. 5 was having ACRs as “Excellent” for three years, i.e 2003-04, 2007-08 and 2008-09. Apart from that, the petitioner had four ACRs as “Very Good”, whereas Respondent No. 5 was having three ACRs as “Very Good”. “Average Satisfactory” entry was of one year with the petitioner, whereas two “Average Satisfactory” entries were in the case of Respondent No. 5, i.e for years 2005-06 and 2006-07. “Average” entry was there as against the petitioner for the year 2003-04, whereas no such entry was there in the service record of Respondent No. 5.
Considering the aforesaid service records of the petitioner as well as Respondent No. 5, it is apparent that there were six entries of “Excellent” and “Very Good” in favour of Respondent No. 5, whereas only four entries of “Very Good” existed in favour of the petitioner. There was no adverse entry as against Respondent No. 5, whereas it was against the petitioner for the year 2003-04.
Considering the aforesaid aspect, it is clear that service record of Respondent No. 5 was far superior than that of the petitioner, as such, he has rightly been promoted to the post of Director. Even if, average entry against the petitioner for the year 2003-04, which is of adverse nature, is discarded, even then, on consideration of the aforesaid service records, promotion of Respondent No. 5 on merits alone cannot be faulted.
In view of the aforesaid, we find no force in the submissions raised by counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner with respect to illegality of DPC proceedings or with regard to adverse entry. Writ petition, being devoid of merits, is, hereby, dismissed.
Alert