- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Nawab v. State Of Uttarakhand
Structured Summary of the Judgment (Oral) — Barin Ghosh, C.J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The victim, Shabana (wife of the appellant), died from a bullet injury that entered from the front and exited from the back. On 25 March 2002 at 2:35 AM, an FIR was registered on the written complaint of the appellant. The FIR stated that at about 1:30 AM on 25 March 2002 the appellant and the victim were sleeping in a room inside the appellant's house when three unknown miscreants came, brought the appellant outside, and tried to take him away. At that point the victim intervened and one of the miscreants allegedly fired upon her; the victim died.
During investigation a country-made pistol and a broken bullet were allegedly recovered from the courtyard on the disclosure of the appellant. A charge-sheet was filed under Section 302 read with Section 34, IPC against the appellant and one Israr; Israr was later exonerated by the trial court and the government did not appeal that part. A separate charge-sheet under Section 25 of the Arms Act was filed against the appellant. The trial court convicted the appellant for an offence punishable under Section 302 IPC and under Section 25 of the Arms Act. The appellant appealed against those convictions.
The record includes witness testimony: PW1 (inquest witness), PW2 (alleged witness to recovery, later declared hostile), PW3 and PW5 (strangers who said they overheard alleged conspiracy), PW4 (brother of victim) and PW6 (mother of victim) who alleged motive (insurance), PW7 (witness to inquest and to recovery of a broken wrist watch), PW9 and PW15 (investigating officers), PW12 (post-mortem surgeon who confirmed death by ante-mortem bullet injury), PW13 (site plan preparer). The trial court relied on a subset of witnesses and convicted; the appellate court reviewed those findings.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the conviction of the appellant for murder under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code is sustainable on the material on record.
- Whether the conviction of the appellant for illegal possession of a firearm under Section 25 of the Arms Act is sustainable given the circumstances of recovery and witness testimony.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The recovery of the appellant's broken wrist watch close to the place of incident indicates there was a scuffle around the time the victim was shot, supporting an alternative version of events.
- The appellant and the victim had recently taken out two life insurance policies (one in appellant's name, one in victim's name) of Rs. 50,000 each; the prosecution's claim that appellant had a motive to encash the victim's policy was not established with facts showing appellant's alleged greed or pressing need for money.
- PWs 4 and 6 (brother and mother) only made assertions about demands by the appellant and could not substantiate them; their evidence did not prove the alleged motive sufficiently.
- PWs 3 and 5 alleged prior conspiratorial discussions but were strangers to the village and their testimony (that appellant discussed how to do away with the victim in presence of others) was implausible; if PW3 had informed the Gram Pradhan, the Pradhan should have been called as a witness but was not produced.
- PW2, the lone independent witness to the recovery of the pistol and broken bullet, turned hostile and denied witnessing any recovery; since his signature appeared on the recovery memo, it was argued this undermined the prosecution's case on recovery and made conviction unjust.
- Overall, it was unjust for the trial court to convict the appellant on the available facts.
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any specific arguments advanced on behalf of the prosecution in adversarial form; instead the prosecution case is presented through the evidence led (witness statements, recoveries, site plan, post-mortem).
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court reviewed the evidence and made the following analytic findings:
- On the post-mortem and cause of death: The post-mortem surgeon (PW12) proved that death was by ante-mortem injury caused by a bullet; this fact supports that the victim died due to gunshot injury.
- On recovery of weapon and bullet: The judgment under appeal did not appear to notice the material exhibits (the recovered country-made pistol and the broken bullet). The prosecution did not attempt to link the recovered pistol to the murder by ballistic opinion, and the investigating officers admitted the pistol and bullet were not sent for ballistic examination.
- Admissibility and reliability of confession in the recovery memo: Any alleged confession recorded in the recovery memo was made before police while the appellant was in police custody and therefore not admissible in evidence; this weakens the prosecution's case regarding the recovery linking appellant to the firearm.
- On the independent witness to recovery (PW2): PW2, the only independent witness to the recovery, turned hostile and explicitly stated he had not witnessed any recovery. Because of PW2's hostility and absence of independent corroboration for the recovery, the appellate court found reason to doubt the prosecution story on the recovery of the pistol and the broken bullet, and held that the appellant was entitled to the benefit of that doubt in relation to the Arms Act charge.
- On motive and credibility of some witnesses: PW3 and PW5 (who claimed to have heard discussions about doing away with the victim) were strangers to the village and their testimony was found not convincing; it was considered unlikely that conspirators would discuss a murder in the hearing of outsiders. PW4 and PW6 claimed an insurance-related motive but failed to show the appellant was in such dire financial need that he would kill his wife for Rs. 50,000; the court considered this motive weak.
- On the appellant's own account and adverse inference: The appellant's version put him and the victim together at night with three miscreants entering the house and one assailant firing at the victim while attempting to take the appellant away. The appellate court found this narrative unbelievable and held that the appellant, as an accused who saw the incident, had fabricated his account to suit himself. Because the appellant did not speak truthfully when examined under Section 313 CrPC, the court applied the principle of drawing an adverse inference against him for his failure to give a truthful account of events he purportedly witnessed.
- Net analytical conclusion: Given the unreliability of the recovery evidence and the hostile independent witness, the court set aside the Arms Act conviction. However, despite weaknesses in motive evidence and some prosecution witnesses, the court found sufficient reason to disbelieve the appellant's account and to uphold the conviction for murder under Section 302 IPC based on the totality of evidence (including post-mortem findings and the court's adverse inference against the appellant).
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The appellate court upheld the conviction and sentence of the appellant for the offence punishable under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, and set aside the conviction and sentence imposed under Section 25 of the Arms Act.
Direct consequences and orders given by the court:
- The portion of the trial court's judgment convicting and sentencing the appellant under Section 25 of the Arms Act was set aside.
- The portion convicting and sentencing the appellant under Section 302 IPC was upheld.
- The appellant, who was on bail, had his bail cancelled and was directed to surrender forthwith to serve out the remaining part of the sentence.
- A copy of the judgment along with the lower court records was directed to be sent back for compliance.
Broader implications: The opinion does not discuss or establish any new legal precedent beyond the disposition in this case. The decision's practical effect is limited to the parties: acquittal on the Arms Act charge and maintenance of the murder conviction with the attendant cancellation of bail and direction to surrender.
JUDGMENT
BARIN GHOSH, C.J (Oral)
In the instant case, the victim, Shabana, wife of the appellant died of a bullet injury, which entered from the front side of her body and exited from the back. On the basis of a written complaint filed by the appellant, chik F.I.R was registered on 25th March, 2002 at 2.35 AM. In the written complaint, it was stated that at about 1.30 AM of 25 March, 2002, appellant and the victim were sleeping in a room inside the house of the appellant, when three unknown miscreants came, brought the appellant outside and tried to take him alongwith them. At that juncture, it was reported that the victim intervened when one of those three miscreants fired upon the victim. It was also reported that the victim died. This First Information Report was investigated. In course thereof, a country made pistol and a broken bullet were recovered from the courtyard of the house of the appellant on the disclosure made by the appellant. After completion of investigation, a charge-sheet was filed for an offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code against the appellant and one Israr. By the judgment and order under appeal, Israr has been exonerated. A separate charge-sheet was also filed against the appellant for offence punishable under Section 25 of the Arms Act. By the judgment and the order under appeal, appellant has been convicted for an offence punishable under Section 302 of I.P.C, and also, for an offence punishable under Section 25 of the Arms Act. Being aggrieved thereby, the present appeal has been preferred. No appeal has been preferred by the Government against that part of the judgment, whereby and under, Israr has been exonerated.
2. Aslam (PW4), being the brother of the victim, and Naima (PW6), being the mother of the victim, alleged that the appellant committed the crime in order to encash the life insurance policy taken out by the appellant on the life of the victim soon before the incident had taken place. They also stated that the appellant was demanding money, but the said witnesses could not provide the same. Ramjaani (PW3) and Farookh (PW5) alleged that on 24 March, 2002, when they were coming to the village to witness Moharram procession to be held on 25 March, 2002, they saw the appellant alongwith others, when the appellant was allegedly discussing with those others how to do away with the victim. PW3 stayed in the house of the Pradhan of the Gram Panchayat in the night of 24 March, 2002. Although, it was not recorded in his statements recorded under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, but in course of tendering evidence before the Court, PW3 held out that he disclosed about such discussions to the Gram Pradhan of the Gram Panchayat.
3. Tahir Hasan (PW2) is the alleged witness to the recovery of the country made pistol and the broken bullet, who was declared hostile. Nisar Ahmad (PW1) is the witness to the inquest. Fakhruddin Ali (PW7) is also a witness to the inquest report. Dr. R.C Pandey (PW12) conducted post-mortem. He proved the post-mortem report and also the fact that the death is by way of ante-mortem injury sustained by the victim by a bullet. In course of investigation, police recovered a broken wrist watch of the appellant from the courtyard of the house of the appellant. PW7 is a witness to the said recovery. D.S Panwar (PW9) and Yogendra Pal Singh (PW15) were the Investigating Officers. They accepted the fact that the recovered country made pistol was not sent for obtaining ballistic expert's opinion. Similarly, the bullet was also not sent for that purpose. Nanhe Ram (PW13), on the instructions of PW9, prepared the site plan, wherefrom, it appears that after one enters the house of the appellant, there is a courtyard. After crossing the courtyard, one gets access to two rooms. It was shown in the site plan that in one of those two rooms, appellant and the victim were sleeping. The site plan shows the marking emanating from the room, in which, appellant and the victim were sleeping, to the place where the dead body of the victim was found on the courtyard. Then the marking shows the path taken by the assailants to escape. It shows that instead of going through the main gate, assailants crossed over a wall towards the house of Shareef son of Lateef. The site plan also shows the spot, from where the broken wrist watch of the appellant was discovered.
4. When the evidence tendered against the appellant was put to him under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, appellant stated what he had stated in his First Information Report. Disbelieving the version of the appellant and, at the same time, believing the version of the prosecution and relying upon the evidence tendered by the prosecution through PW2, PW3, PW4, PW5, PW6 and PW7, the court below convicted the appellant for the charge of murder, and also, for illegally possessing a firearm.
5. In the present appeal, it is the contention of the learned counsel for the appellant that the fact of discovery of the broken wrist watch of the appellant from a place close to the place of incident, having been established, it stands established that there was a scuffle at about the time when the victim was fired upon by one of the assailants. The learned counsel submitted that it has already come on record that the appellant had taken out two life insurance policies, one in his name and the other in the name of the victim and they were of Rs. 50,000/- each. It was contended that apart from assertions made in course of tendering evidence, PW4 and PW6 could not bring on record anything, on the basis whereof a prudent person can be convinced that frequent demands were being made by the appellant or that the appellant was a greedy person. The learned counsel submitted that if PW3 heard what he deposed and, thereupon, stayed the night with the Pradhan of the Gram Panchayat and had conveyed to him what he heard, it was expected at least from the Pradhan to warn off the victim. The fact remains that the Pradhan was not brought to give evidence. Learned counsel further submitted that it is somewhat not expected that the appellant will conspire with others, to the hearing of unknown persons, to commit murder of his own wife. It was submitted that PW2, who is the lone independent witness to the recovery, turned hostile and stated in so many words that he did not witness recovery of any country made pistol or broken bullet said to have been recovered on the disclosure of the appellant. It was contended that as the signature of PW2 figured in the purported recovery memo so the signature of the appellant figured therein. It was contended that in the facts and circumstances of the case, it was unjust on the part of the court below to convict the appellant.
6. It does not appear from the judgment under appeal that the court below noticed the material exhibits being the recovered country made pistol and the broken bullet. The fact remains that no attempt was made by the prosecution to link the said country made pistol with the murder in question. The alleged confession, recorded in the recovery memo, having been made before the police while in custody of the police, is not admissible in evidence. In the absence of independent evidence, and, in particular, when PW2, the sole independent witness to the recovery, turned hostile and he having stated that he had not witnessed any recovery, a doubt is cast to the prosecution story about recovery of the country made pistol and the broken bullet, benefit whereof the appellant is entitled to.
7. The evidence tendered by PW3 and PW5 is not convincing. They came to watch Moharram to be held on 25 March, 2002. They are strangers to the village. It is doubtful, whether a conspirator will conspire in the presence or to the hearing of outsiders. PW4 and PW6 held out that the motive was to encash the life insurance policy. The amount of the life insurance policy was Rs. 50,000/-. It was not projected by PW4 and PW6 that the appellant was in such a penury that for Rs. 50,000/-, he would murder his own wife. The motive, thus ascribed, appears to be weak. However, still then, there is hardly any scope of interference with the conviction under Section 302 of I.P.C in view of the fact that according to the appellant, he and his wife were together in the house of the appellant in the intervening night of 24/25 March, 2002. According to the appellant, three miscreants came and they not only entered his house, but also the room, in which he and his wife were sleeping for the purpose of taking the appellant away. They succeeded up to the courtyard. Victim then tried to save the appellant. One of the miscreants fired, but while firing, aimed at the victim and not at the appellant and, thereafter, they left the victim and fled. This story, as made out by the appellant, is unbelievable. The narration of the events, as given by the appellant, suggests he was the witness to the incident, but has fabricated the same to suit him. Having not discharged his duty to speak truthfully as regards the incident watched by him, the Court is competent to take adverse inference against him. We, accordingly, take such adverse inference against him and, on that ground, uphold the judgment under appeal, insofar as the same convicted the appellant for an offence punishable under Section 302 of I.P.C and exonerate the appellant of the offence punishable under Section 25 of the Arms Act.
8. Accordingly, the judgment and order under appeal, insofar as the same convicted the appellant and sentenced him for an offence punishable under Section 25 of the Arms Act, is set aside and the judgment under appeal, insofar as the same convicted the appellant and sentenced him for an offence punishable under Section 302 of I.P.C is upheld. Appellant is on bail. His bail is cancelled. He is directed to surrender forthwith for serving out the remaining part of the sentence.
9. Let a copy of this judgment alongwith lower court records be sent back for compliance.
Alert