Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Prajapati Ishwarbhai Joitaram & 18 Petitioner(S) v. State Of Gujarat & 2 (S)

Gujarat High Court
Oct 10, 2012

ORAL ORDER

1. By way of this petition, the petitioners have prayed for the following reliefs:-

[A] To quash and set aside the declared results of the written examination for the post of Class-III and the final results for the post of Class-IV by the respondent no. 2 and 3 pursuant to the advertisement dated 14.10.2011 contrary to the provisions of Rule 4 of the Gujarat Civil Services (Reservation of Vacancies for Ex-Servicemen in Class-III and IV Posts and Service) Rule, 1975 and the paripatra dated 07.07.2003

[B] To direct the respondent no. 2 and 3 to prepare and declare the result of the written examination for the post of Class III and the final result for the post of the Class IV pursuant to the advertisement dated 14.11.2011 as per the provision contained in Rule 4 of the Gujarat Civil Services (Reservation of Vacancies for Ex-Servicemen in Class III and IV Posts and Service) Rules 1975 and the paripatra dated 07.07.2003

[C] Pending admission and the final hearing of this petition to stay the further proceedings pursuant to the declared result of the written examination for the post of Class III and the final result for the post of Class IV by the respondent no. 2 and 3 pursuant to the advertisement dated 14.11.2011

[D] Pending admission and final hearing of this petition, keeping ten percentage posts vacant in the each category of the Class-III and Class-IV advertised posts for the class of the ex-servicemen in terms of the Rule 4 of the said rules, to permit the respondent no. 2 and 3 to do the further proceedings pursuant to the declared result of the written examination for the post of Class III and the final result for the post of the Class IV pursuant to the advertisement dated 14.11.2011

[E] ………….”

2. The facts in brief are that on 14.11.2011 the respondent-Board published an Advertisement in a local daily inviting applications for the various Posts. In response to the said Advertisement, the petitioners submitted their applications in the prescribed form. It is the case of the petitioners that having cleared the first part of the exam, they were called for the written examination. Later on, the result of the written examination for the post of Class III and Class IV was declared by the respondents, wherein the petitioners were declared failed. The grievance of the petitioners is that the mode of preparation of the result of the written examination for the said post is contrary to the provisions of Rule 4 of the Gujarat Civil Services (Reservation of Vacancies for Ex-Servicemen in Class-III and IV Posts & Service) Rules, 1975. Hence, this petition.

3. Heard learned counsel for the respective parties and perused the documents on record. From the record it transpires that the petitioners have participated in the process of selection process without any protest at any stage and having failed in the examination, the petitioners now cannot turn back to state that the procedure adopted by the respondents is contrary to the Rules. Considering the facts of the case, it would be relevant to refer to the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Vijendra Kumar Verma v. Public Service Commission, (2011) 1 SCC 150 wherein the Court has observed that the petitioner having participated in the admiyon process knowing the selection criteria, that too without any protest at any stage, cannot turn back to state that the procedure adopted for grant of admission was wrong and without jurisdiction

4. In the aforesaid decision, the Apex Court was considering a case wherein the appellant was called for interview for the post of Civil Judge in Uttaranchal Judiciary vide letter dated 21st May 2007 wherein it was mentioned that the candidate should have the basic knowledge of the computer operation, knowledge of Microsoft Operating System and Microsoft Office operations and the appellant went for his viva voce examination and gave the said test without any protest or demur and having failed in the said interview process he challenged the same by filing a writ petition praying for a declaration that since the respondents have introduced a new selection criterion during the midstream of the selection, the selection process was vitiated and that it amounts to introduction of new benchmark. The Division Bench of the Uttarakhand High Court non-suited the petitioner. Being aggrieved by the same, the appellant filed appeal before the Supreme Court and while dismissing the appeal Apex Court in para 24 has observed as under:

“24. When the list of successful candidates in the written examination was published in such notification itself, it was also made clear that the knowledge of the candidates with regard to basic knowledge of computer operation would be tested at the time of interview for which knowledge of Microsoft Operating System and Microsoft Office Operation would be essential. In the call letter also which was sent to the appellant at the time of calling him for interview, the aforesaid criteria was reiterated and spelt out. Therefore, no minimum benchmark or a new procedure was ever introduced during the midstream of the selection process. All the candidates knew the requirements of the selection process and were also fully aware that they must possess the basic knowledge of computer operation meaning thereby Microsoft Operating System and Microsoft Office Operation. Knowing the said criteria, the appellant also appeared in the interview, faced the questions from the expert of computer application and has taken a chance and opportunity therein without any protest at any stage and now cannot turn back to state that the aforesaid procedure adopted was wrong and without jurisdiction.”

5. Consequently, the petition is dismissed summarily.