- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shri Chatter Singh v. Shri Mohinder Singh
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff's civil suit was decreed by the Sub Judge 1st Class, Rajgarh, District Sirmaur by judgment and decree dated 27.12.2001 in Civil Suit No. 62/1 of 1999 (Hem Ram v. Mohinder Singh). That decree was affirmed by the Additional District Judge, Sirmaur at Nahan by judgment and decree dated 30.11.2002 in Civil Appeal No. 7-N/13 of 2002 (Mohinder Singh v. Hem Raj). The present is the defendants' Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, challenging the concurrent findings of fact recorded by the courts below.
Material factual matrix (as set out in the opinion): land of 8-15 Bighas in Mauza Chewala Bakanag, Tehsil Pachhad, District Sirmaur was owned in shares by Smt. Gauri (widow of Kirpa Ram) and Shri Joginder Singh in a 2/3 : 1/3 ratio. The plaintiff claimed tenancy through his father Shri Shankru, who allegedly paid rent by batai (1/4th of produce). Under the H.P. Tenancy and Land Reforms Act, 1972, the share of Shri Joginder had vested in the tenant Shri Shankru, but Smt. Gauri's share, being a widow's share, could not vest in the tenant under Section 104(8) of the Tenancy Act. In 1999 defendants No.1 and 2 (sons of Shri Joginder) obtained mutation of Smt. Gauri's share in their favour on the basis of an alleged Will; plaintiff filed suit for declaration and injunction challenging those entries and seeking to restrain interference with his possession.
Trial Court framed ten issues based on the pleadings and decreed the suit, declaring the plaintiff and proforma defendants tenants qua Gauri Devi's share, holding revenue entries in favour of defendants No.1 & 2 to be wrong, illegal and void, and granting injunction against interference. The decree was based on documentary (jamabandi) and oral evidence for the plaintiff; defendants' oral evidence regarding the Will was disbelieved. The defendants' first appeal was dismissed by the lower appellate court, which upheld the trial court's findings and held the suit maintainable in view of prior decisions of this Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, in the absence of proper pleadings and proof, it was within the jurisdiction of the courts below to declare the plaintiff to be tenant over the suit property by construing the defence in the written statement; and whether such findings were illegal, erroneous or perverse.
- Whether both the courts below erred in not rejecting the plaint under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure when the plaint was allegedly not properly valued for court fees and jurisdiction.
- Whether the plaintiff had an efficacious remedy under the Land Acquisition Act (specifically Section 30) for determination of rights and compensation in respect of part of the suit land that was acquired by the State, thereby barring the maintainability of the civil suit.
- Whether the courts below overstepped jurisdiction in adjudicating on the Will allegedly executed by Smt. Gauri Devi in favour of the appellants and whether non-joinder of necessary parties (notably the natural successor Shri Joginder Singh) was fatal to the suit.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' (Defendants No. 1 & 2) Arguments
- Denied tenancy of Shri Shankru and contended one Shri Gaurdia alias Gorkhia was the tenant who relinquished tenancy in 1957-58, after which possession remained with original owners (Smt. Gauri and Shri Joginder).
- Justified revenue mutation entries in their favour on the basis of an alleged registered Will executed by Smt. Gauri in their favour; they relied on that Will to claim proprietorship.
- Contended the courts below lacked jurisdiction: that an efficacious remedy existed under the Land Acquisition Act (Section 30) for determination of rights/compensation in respect of part of the suit land that was acquired, thus barring the civil suit.
- Argued the plaint should have been rejected under Order VII Rule 11 CPC for improper valuation (affecting jurisdiction and court fees).
- Argued the courts below should not have adjudicated the Will's validity or the title/share dispute, and that there was non-joinder of necessary parties (notably Shri Joginder Singh).
Respondent's (Plaintiff) Arguments
- Asserted tenancy of his father Shri Shankru over the suit land, paying rent by batai, and relied on revenue records (jamabandis) and mutation order (Ext. P-G) to show conferment of Shri Joginder's proprietary share to Shri Shankru under the Tenancy Act.
- Contended that defendants failed to prove the alleged Will (they did not produce the Will or the scribe/attesting witnesses), and that the Will was set up to defeat statutory rights of the tenant.
- Maintained that the civil courts had jurisdiction to decide the dispute about tenancy and title as the dispute arose independent of the proceedings under the Tenancy Act and the Land Acquisition Act argument was misconceived or inapplicable in the circumstances pleaded and evidenced at trial.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Shri Lajpat Rai (deceased) through LRs Smt. Maya Devi v. Smt. Taro Devi, 1999 (3) Shim.L.C 269 | Support for maintainability of civil suit and jurisdiction of Civil Court in certain tenancy disputes. | Lower Appellate Court relied on this decision to hold the suit maintainable; the present Court treated it as one of the authorities supporting civil court jurisdiction in the circumstances. |
| Babu Ram (deceased) through LRs Smt. Sita Devi v. Pohlo Ram (deceased) through LRs Smt. Vidya Devi | Where relationship with respect to tenancy is in dispute, the Civil Court has jurisdiction. | Cited by this Court as authority that disputes over tenancy relationship fall within civil court jurisdiction and to support dismissal of the appeal. |
| Ramesh Kumar v. Mandir Thor, 2007 (2) Shim.L.C 422 | Distinguished Chuhniya Devi; held that when landlord-tenant relationship is disputed (possession/tenancy in issue), civil courts can try the dispute despite revenue entries. | Quoted and applied to show that the Civil Court had jurisdiction where the plaintiff claimed continuous possession as tenant and the defendants denied it. |
| Chuhniya Devi v. Jindu Ram, 1991 (1) Shim.L.C 223 | Full Bench decision holding that jurisdiction of Civil Court was barred in certain circumstances under the Act. | Recognized but treated as distinguishable/inapplicable to the facts of the present case; Ramesh Kumar and Shankar v. Rukmani showed it was misapplied where facts differ. |
| Shankar v. Rukmani, 2003 (1) Shim. L.C 300 | Where the dispute of landlord and tenant arises independent of proceedings under the Tenancy Act, the Civil Court's jurisdiction is not ousted; exclusion of civil jurisdiction is not to be inferred readily. | Followed by this Court as a key precedent to hold that the Civil Court was competent to decide the present dispute and to answer substantial questions of law against the appellants. |
| Amar Chand v. Thakru Devi (Latest HLJ 2005 (HP) 1108) | Adopted the ratio in Shankar v. Rukmani: disputes between persons each claiming tenant status are not matters for the Land Reforms Officer under Chapter X; Section 112 (ouster) not attracted. | Relied upon to support the proposition that the civil courts have jurisdiction where claims of tenancy between private parties do not fall within the exclusive domain of the Land Reforms Officer. |
| Dhulabhai v. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1969 Supreme Court 78 | Exclusion of Civil Court jurisdiction should not be inferred readily; prerequisites for ouster must be strictly established. | Referred to as an established precedent underpinning the Court's approach to not readily oust civil jurisdiction in tenancy/title disputes. |
| Krishan Chand v. Jeet Ram, Latest HLJ 2009 (HP) 978 | Affirmed that Civil Court jurisdiction is not ousted when tenancy disputes arise independent of proceedings under the Tenancy Act; cited earlier decisions (Pritam Singh, Birbal, Shankar v. Rukmani). | Applied to answer questions against appellants and to confirm that the Civil Court could adjudicate the issues raised. |
| Pritam Singh v. Krishan Kumar, 1997 (1) Sim.L.C 255 | Supports the proposition that where proceedings under the Act are conducted without jurisdiction or contrary to fundamental principles, civil court jurisdiction may not be barred. | Cited (through Krishan Chand and related authorities) to support the position that civil court jurisdiction stands where statutory authorities have not acted in conformity with judicial procedure. |
| Birbal v. Udhami, 1992 (1) Sim.L.C (as cited) | Similar to Pritam Singh: supports civil court jurisdiction in appropriate cases where statutory proceedings do not exclude civil adjudication. | Referred to (in combination with other authorities) to bolster the Court's conclusion that civil jurisdiction was available. |
| Nand Ram v. Sant Ram, 2011 (3) Shim. L.C 240 | Relied upon by appellants' counsel in support of their contentions (as cited by parties). | The Court explicitly held this authority to be inapplicable on the facts of the present case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court conducted a fact-specific review of the evidence and the law and reached the following step-by-step analysis:
- Acceptance of concurrent findings: The Court found no illegality, irregularity or perversity in the concurrent findings of the trial and lower appellate courts and observed that some substantial questions of law were already settled by binding and persuasive precedents.
- Evidence and documentary primacy: The Court noted that the share of Shri Joginder vested in the tenant Shri Shankru under the Tenancy Act and that jamabandis (Exts. P-1, P-3, P-4, P-5) and mutation order (Ext. P-G) established Shri Shankru's tenancy and conferment of proprietary rights. The presence of Shri Joginder at the time of mutation was recorded, lending credence to the plaintiff's case.
- Credibility findings: The Courts below disbelieved defendants' oral evidence on the Will (DW-1, DW-2, DW-3). The present Court found no illegality or perversity in disbelieving that evidence. A lone stray entry for 1955-56 did not outweigh contemporaneous and subsequent documentary evidence demonstrating tenancy in the name of Shri Shankru.
- Failure to prove the Will: Defendants did not place the Will on record nor produced the scribe/attesting witnesses; the Court observed this failure and accepted the inference that the Will was not established and appeared to have been relied upon to defeat the tenant's statutory rights.
- On the Land Acquisition Act argument: The appellants' plea that the civil court lacked jurisdiction because part of the land was acquired and rights/compensation fell within Section 30 of the Land Acquisition Act was considered misconceived. The Court explained that Section 30 pertains to apportionment of compensation and to disputes concerning apportionment, and that rights not subject matter of acquisition could not properly be adjudicated by the Land Acquisition Collector. Moreover, the record showed that this plea was not raised or supported below (no issue framed and no evidence led under Section 30).
- Precedential support: The Court relied on a line of decisions (including Shankar v. Rukmani, Amar Chand, Ramesh Kumar, Krishan Chand, and Dhulabhai) to hold that civil courts retain jurisdiction where landlord-tenant relationship is disputed independently of the Tenancy Act proceedings, and where statutory authorities have not acted in conformity with judicial procedure. These precedents were used to reject the contention that civil jurisdiction was ousted.
- Administrative correction: The Court recorded that respondents' counsel informed the Court of an Assistant Collector's order dated 11.12.2001 correcting entries showing defendants No.1 and 2 as owners; this fact was not controverted by the appellants.
- Conclusion on substantial questions: Having considered evidence, credibility, statutory scheme and precedent, the Court answered the substantial questions of law against the appellants and concluded there was no merit in the appeal.
Holding and Implications
Holding: DISMISSED — The appeal filed by defendants No.1 and 2 is dismissed for being without merits. The substantial questions of law were answered against the appellants.
Direct implications and consequences:
- The concurrent judgments and decrees of the trial Court (dated 27.12.2001) and the lower appellate Court (dated 30.11.2002) stand affirmed: the plaintiff (and proforma defendants) are declared tenants qua the share of Gauri Devi; revenue entries showing defendants No.1 & 2 as owners qua that share were held wrong, illegal and void; and injunction was granted restraining interference with plaintiff's possession.
- The Court rejected the appellants' jurisdictional challenge based on the Land Acquisition Act and held that Section 30 did not bar the civil suit in the circumstances pleaded and evidenced; it also noted that the appellants had not pursued any evidence or issues under Section 30 before the trial Court.
- The defendants failed to establish the alleged Will; hence their claim based on that Will was not accepted.
- The Court recorded that an Assistant Collector's order dated 11.12.2001 corrected the entries showing defendants No.1 & 2 as owners; this fact was not disputed.
- No costs were awarded to any party ("No costs").
Sanjay Karol, J.
Plaintiff's Civil Suit stands decreed in terms of judgment and decree dated 27.12.2001 passed by Sub Judge 1st Class, Rajgarh, District Sirmaur in Civil Suit No. 62/1 of 1999, titled as Hem Ram v. Mohinder Singh, which stands affirmed by the Additional District Judge, Sirmaur District at Nahan, in terms of judgment and decree dated 30.11.2002 passed in Civil Appeal No. 7-N/13 of 2002, titled as Mohinder Singh v. Hem Raj.
2. This is the defendants Regular Second Appeal filed under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, assailing concurrent findings of fact recorded by the Courts below, in terms of judgment and decree referred to hereinabove. The Civil Suit was instituted before the trial Court on 5.10.1999 Appeal before the lower appellate Court was instituted on 30.11.2002 and the instant appeal was admitted on 24.2.2003
3. Land comprising 8-15 Bighas, situated in Mauza Chewala Bakanag, Tehsil Pachhad, District Sirmaur, H.P was owned by Smt. Gauri widow of Kirpa Ram and Shri Joginder Singh Son of Shri Jagtia in the ratio of 2/3rd and 1/3, respectively. As per the plaintiff Hem Raj, his father Shri Shankru was the tenant over the said land. The rent was paid as Batai i.e 1/4th of the produce to the owners. By virtue of the provisions of the H.P Tenancy and Land Reforms Act, 1972 (for short, Tenancy Act), ownership of share of Shri Joginder in the suit land, was vested and conferred upon the tenant i.e Shri Shankru. Since Smt. Gauri was a widow, by virtue of the provisions of Section 104(8) of the Tenancy Act, share of a widow could not vest with the tenant and as such, Shri Shankru continued to be tenant of Smt. Gauri. Some time in the year 1999, defendants No. 1 and 2 i.e Mohinder Singh and Chatter Singh both sons of Shri Joginder Singh on the basis of Will executed by Smt. Gauri got her share mutated in their own name. Aggrieved thereof, plaintiff filed the suit for declaration and injunction challenging the entries and also seeking relief of injunction restraining these persons (defendants) from interfering with his possession.
4. Defendants No. 1 and 2 contested the suit, inter alia, denying the tenancy of Shri Shankru and taking a specific plea that one Shri Gaurdia alias Gorkhia was the tenant in the suit land, who relinquished his tenancy way back in the year 1957-58 and thereafter possession of the suit land continued to be with the original owners (Smt. Gauri and Shri Joginder-father of defendants No. 1 and 2). Part of the suit land was acquired by the Government for the purpose of construction of the land. The entries of mutation were justified on the ground of alleged Will executed by Smt. Gauri in favour of defendants No. 1 and 2.
5. Based on the pleadings of the parties, trial Court framed the following issues:-
1. Whether the plaintiff and proforma defendants are owner in possession of the suit land, as alleged? OPP
2. If Issue No. 1 is answered in affirmative, whether the revenue entries in favour of defendants No. 1 and 2 are wrong, illegal, null and void and not binding on the plaintiff? OPP
3. Whether the defendants No. 1 and 2 are creating interference in the land in suit, as alleged? OPP
4. Whether the suit is not maintainable? OPD
5. Whether this Court has no jurisdiction, as alleged? OPD
6. Whether the land in suit was in the tenancy of Gurdia alias Gorkhia who had relinquished his tenancy in favour of the landlord, as alleged? OPD.
7. Whether Gauri Devi had bequeathed her share in the suit land to defendants No. 1 and 2, by virtue of registered Will, as alleged? OPD.
8. Whether Shamkru was not tenant in the suit land, as alleged? OPD
9. Whether the defendants are entitled for the compensation? OPD
10. Relief.
6. Trial Court decreed the plaintiff's suit in the following effect:-
“In view of my aforesaid discussion and findings, suit succeeds. Accordingly the suit is decreed with costs. A decree of declaration is passed that plaintiff and proforma defendants are tenants in the suit land qua the share of Gauri Devi and the land revenue entries showing defendants No. 1 & 2 as owner qua the share of Gauri Devi are wrong, illegal null and void and declares as such. A further decree of injunction is passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants No. 1 & 2 restraining them from causing any kind of interference in the possession of plaintiff and proforma defendants in the suit land comprised in Khata Khatauni No. 25/50 Khasra No. 11, 12, 19, 20, 21, 23, 24 and 27, plot 8, measuring 8-15 Bighas, situated in Mauza Chewala Bakanag, Tehsil Pachhad, District Sirmaur, H.P or claiming compensation qua the suit land from defendant No. 3. The decree sheet be prepared accordingly and file after needful be consigned to records.”
7. The trial Court disbelieved the oral evidence led by the defendants with regard to execution of the Will. Based on the oral and documentary evidence led by the plaintiff, the plea of tenancy of Shri Shankru was upheld.
8. Assailing the judgment dated 27.12.2001, defendants No. 1 and 2 filed an appeal, which stands dismissed in terms of impugned judgment and decree dated 30.11.2002 The lower Appellate Court not only upheld the findings of fact recorded by the trial Court but also conclusively held the suit filed by the plaintiff to be maintainable in view of the decision rendered by this Court in Shri Lajpat Rai (deceased) through his LRs Smt. Maya Devi v. Smt. Taro Devi, 1999 (3) Shim.L.C 269 and other decisions to the similar effect.
9. The instant appeal filed by defendants No. 1 and 2 was admitted on the following substantial questions of law:-
1. Whether in the absence of proper pleadings and proof, was it within the jurisdiction of the courts below to have declared the plaintiff-respondent to be the tenant over the suit property by misunderstanding the defence taken in the written statement? Are not such findings returned by both the courts below illegal, erroneous and perverse, based on misreading the relevant evidence and misapplication of correct law?
2. Whether both the Courts below have failed to exercise the jurisdiction in not rejecting the plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure when the same was not properly valued for the purpose of court fees and jurisdiction?
3. Whether both the Courts below have ignored that the plaintiff-respondent had an efficacious remedy under the provisions of Land Acquisition Act for determination of their right which barred the maintainability of the suit filed by the plaintiff-respondent for determination of the status as well as payment of the amount of compensation?
4. Whether the courts below have overstepped their jurisdiction in returning the findings over the Will executed by Smt. Gauri Devi in favour of the appellants when such question was beyond the scope of the controversy in the suit and was beyond the jurisdiction of the courts in the absence of the natural successor of Smt. Gauri Devi, namely, Shri Joginder Singh? Was not it incumbent for both the Courts below to have discussed the suit of the plaintiff-respondent for non-joinder of necessary parties?
10. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record in entirety. In my considered view the appeal only merits dismissal as there is no illegality, irregularity or perversity in the impugned judgment and decree. Some of the substantial questions of law already stand settled.
11. The fact that the suit land was owned by Smt. Gauri and Shri Joginder is not in dispute. The fact that share of Shri Joginder, by virtue of Tenancy Act vested with Shri Shankru and entries with regard to the same were duly effected in the revenue record are evidently clear from the Jamabandi (Ext.P-9). Undisputedly these entries were never assailed by Shri Joginder, father of defendants No. 1 and 2, who incidentally also appeared as a witness (DW-3) in the trial Court, during his life time.
12. Plaintiff has examined himself as PW-1) as also examined Shri Hari Dass (PW-2). Plaintiff has conclusively established, by proving documentary evidence i.e revenue record (jamabandies) Exts. P-1, P-3, P-4, P-5 pertaining to the years 1961-62, 1971-72, 1966-67 and 1981-82. These documents evidently and conclusively establish that Shri Shankru was occupying the suit land as a tenant and by virtue of the provisions of the Tenancy Act, share of Shri Joginder vested with Shri Shankru. Significantly, plaintiff has also proved the order of mutation Ext. P-G whereby proprietary rights of Shri Joginder were conferred upon Shri Shankru. At the time of this mutation, presence of Shri Joginder is clearly recorded. This only lends credence to the plaintiff's version of Shri Shankru being tenant over the suit land. These witnesses have also established that over the suit land plaintiff has set up his house where he is permanently residing since long. The rent was paid in the shape of Batai.
13. On the other hand, testimonies of defendants' witnesses, namely, Shri Dhani Ram (DW-1), defendant No. 2 Shri Chattar Singh (DW-2) and Shri Joginder Singh (DW-3), have been disbelieved by the Courts below. Having gone through the same, I find there is neither any illegality nor any perversity in appreciating the same. However, to prove the earlier tenancy, it is seen that there is a stray entry pertaining to the year 1955-56 to this effect. But then this plea, in the teeth of other contemporaneous and subsequent documentary evidence stands rebutted. Further one witness has himself admitted that subsequently tenancy was created in the name of Shri Shankru.
14. Defendants No. 1 and 2 have chosen not to place on record the Will on the basis of which entry of mutation was effected in their favour. They have also not been able to produce the scribe or the attesting witnesses to establish valid execution and attestation of a Will whereby Smt. Gauri allegedly bequeathed her share in their favour. It is not that the witnesses or the scribe were not available. By virtue of the provisions of the Tenancy Act, proprietary rights of a widow could not have been conferred upon the tenant. The alleged Will appears to have been set up by the defendants only with the object and purpose of defeating the statutory right of the original tenant and the present plaintiff, who continued to be a tenant after the death of his father.
15. Significantly Smt. Gauri died in the year 1983 and in the jamabandi (Ext.P-6) pertaining to the year 1986-87, in the ownership column, name of defendants is recorded but the possession is still shown to be that of Shri Shankru.
16. Defendants did not interfere with the plaintiff's possession and only when such attempt was made and upon inquiries, the factum of deceit committed by the defendants was discovered that the suit was filed by them on 5.10.1999
17. The conferment of proprietary rights upon tenant was not an issue. Hence, the lower appellate Court, by taking into account the decision rendered by this Court in Shri Lajpat Rai (supra), held the jurisdiction of the Civil Court not to be barred, more so, for the reason that the plaintiff had filed a suit for injunction being in possession of the suit land.
18. In Babu Ram (deceased) through LRs Smt. Sita Devi v. Pohlo Ram (deceased) through LRs Smt. Vidya Devi, this Court has taken the view that where relationship with respect to tenancy is in dispute, Civil Court would have jurisdiction.
19. A Coordinate Bench of this Court in Ramesh Kumar v. Mandir Thor (Math Thor), 2007 (2) Shim.L.C 422, has held as under:-
“6. The learned Courts below have relied on a Full Bench Judgment of this Court in Chuhniya Devi v. Jindu Ram, 1991 (1) Shim.L.C 223, holding that the jurisdiction of the Civil Court was barred. This case was subsequently considered by this Court in Shankar v. Rukmani, 2003 (1) Shim. L.C 300. While disposing of the appeal, this Court has held:-
‘3. After hearing the learned Counsel for the parties and going through the record, we find that the District Judge has wrongly applied the ratio of judgment in Chuhniya Devi v. Jindu Ram's case (supra) to the facts and circumstances of the present case. From the pleadings of the parties it is clear that the plaintiff claimed himself to be in continuous possession of the suit land as tenant for the last 20 years, whereas the defendants denied his claim and asserted that they are owners in possession. Therefore, admittedly the relationship of landlord and tenant is in dispute despite the revenue entries in favour of the plaintiff and such kind of disputes are triable by the Civil Court.
10. Coming to the case in hand, it is not averred by the either party that either the proceedings were initiated or the order was passed under Chapter × of the Act. Therefore, we have no hesitation to hold that the ratio of judgment in Chuhniya Devi v. Jindu Ram's case is not applicable to the facts and circumstances of the present case and the Civil Court has the jurisdiction to decide the suit of the plaintiff.”
7. Similarly, in Amar Chand v. Thakru Devi (Latest HLJ 2005 (HP) 1108, this Court following the ratio in Shankar v. Rukmani (supra) held:
“9. The dispute whether a given person is a tenant or not would arise when in the proceedings regarding resumption of land the person cultivating the land claims that he is tenant qua that land and the owner of the land denies that claim. Such a question would be determined by the Land Reforms Officer, appointed for the purpose of Chapter X. A question which arises between two person, each claiming to be tenant in respect of a given extent of land, as in the present case, cannot be said to be a dispute between the owner of the land and the tenant, nor has such a question any relevance to the proceedings required to be conducted under Chapter × of the Act and hence the Land Reforms Officer does not have jurisdiction in respect of such a dispute. To such matters, the provision of Section 112 of the Act barring the jurisdiction of the Civil Court is not attracted.”
8. I see no reason to differ with the ratio laid down in these judgments. Even otherwise these judgments follow the established precedent of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Dhulabhai v. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1969 Supreme Court 78, holding that exclusion of jurisdiction of a Civil Court is not to be inferred readily unless the condition precedent barring such jurisdiction are strictly established.”
20. This Court further in Krishan Chand v. Jeet Ram, Latest HLJ 2009 (HP) 978, has held:
“Question No. 5:
9. This question is answered against the appellants. The jurisdiction of the Civil Court is not ousted as pleaded. The decisions in Pritam Singh v. Krishan Kumar, 1997 (1) Sim.L.C 255, Birbal v. Udhami1992 (1) Sim.L.C and Shankar v. Rukmani, 2003 (1) Sim.L.C 300 are clear and unequivocal that where the proceedings have been conducted without jurisdiction, where the question of tenancy is disputed, independent of the proceedings under the HP Tenancy and Land Reforms Act, there is no finality to the adjudication of the revenue officials and the jurisdiction of the Civil Court is not barred.
In Rukmani's case supra this Court held:-
“After analyzing the judgment in Chuhniya Devi case (supra), we have no doubt that the jurisdiction of the Civil Court is barred under the Act if the dispute pertaining to the relationship of landlord and tenant arises during the proceedings of conferment of proprietary rights upon the tenant and resumption of land by the land owner and the order in respect thereof has been passed by the authorities under the Act except in a case where it is found that the statutory authorities envisaged by that Act had not acted in conformity with the fundamental principles of judicial procedure or where the provisions of the Act had not been complied with. But if the dispute of landlord and tenant arises independent of the proceedings under the Act, the Civil Court has the jurisdiction.”
In the present case the very basis and foundation of conferment of proprietary rights has been questioned. The case pleaded by the plaintiffs is one of suppression of facts, exercise of powers by an officer not competent to do so and the very basis of tenancy has been challenged.
This question is, therefore, answered against the appellants.”
21. Defendants themselves had pleaded and led evidence to establish their right on the basis of the alleged Will executed by Smt. Gauri. Consequently, the Courts below rightly went into and decided the question of title of the defendant on such basis.
22. It is alleged on behalf of the appellants that the Civil Court had no jurisdiction to go into the question of title or share of either the plaintiff or the defendants, for the reason the same was to be adjudicated upon under the provisions of Section 30 of the Land Acquisition Act as part of the suit land stood acquired by the State. The question of right, entitlement of the amount of compensation was to be adjudicated by the Land Acquisition Collector under the said Act.
23. This plea, in my considered view is misconceived. Section 30 of the Land Acquisition Act deals with disputes with regard to apportionment of the amount of compensation payable to the persons in the event of dispute having arisen with regard to the same.
24. By virtue of the provisions of Section 30 of the Land Acquisition Act, the Court can institute an inquiry with regard to the dispute raised inter se between certain parties. In exercise of the powers under the provisions of Section 30 of the Land Acquisition Act, the question of adjudication of right and entitlement of the parties which was not subject matter of acquisition, could not have been decided by the Land Acquisition Collector. More so, when before the trial Court this plea was never taken by the parties and neither any issue was got framed nor any evidence oral/documentary or otherwise was led to establish the findings so rendered under the provisions of Section 30 of the Land Acquisition Act.
25. The decision in Nand Ram v. Sant Ram, 2011 (3) Shim. L.C 240, relied upon by Mr. Gupta, learned Senior Advocate, is inapplicable in the facts of the case.
26. Significantly, during the course of hearing Ms. Jyotsna Rewaal Dua, learned counsel for the respondents apprised the Court of the order dated 11.12.2001 passed by the Assistant Collector, Ist Grade, whereby the entries showing defendants No. 1 and 2 to be the owners stood corrected. The factum of passing of this order was not disputed by the learned counsel for the appellants.
27. Substantial questions of law are answered accordingly.
For the aforesaid reasons, the appeal is dismissed being without any merits. No costs.
Alert