Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Thakurdas & Ors. v. Lakhan Singh & Ors.

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Feb 21, 2013

Appellant No. 3 Gopal son of Babulal is also present in person identified by the assisting counsel of the appellants.

In view of listing of the matter, IA 265/13 respondents' application for early hearing does not require any further consideration, hence, the same is disposed of.

This second appeal is preferred on behalf of the defendants 2, 3 and 4 being aggrieved by some findings of the judgment dated 09th April, 2012 passed by Fourth Additional District Judge, Gwalior in regular Civil Appeal No. 11A/07 affirming the judgment dated 19/12/2005 passed by Civil Judge Class I, Gwalior in Original Civil Suit No. 62A/04 dismissing the suit of respondents 1 to 10 - the plaintiffs, filed for declaration and perpetual injunction with respect of the disputed land described in the plaint as well as the above mentioned judgments.

In the course of arguments on admission, in view of the definition of decree defined under section 2(2) as well as provisions of sections 96 and 100 of CPC alongwith the provisions of Order 41 Rule 1 and Order 42 Rule 2 of CPC on making certain query from the learned Senior Advocate of the appellants regarding entertainability of this second appeal under section 100 of CPC specially on the ground that the appellants or any of them is not a sufferer by any decree and they are aggrieved only by some findings of the courts below whereby they have been held to be in possession of the land as encroachers, on which instead of arguing further, such appellants' counsel seeks permission to withdraw this appeal with liberty to file appropriate proceeding before appropriate forum against the aforesaid findings of the impugned judgments with further liberty to take probable objections and defence in future in any proceeding which is so filed against the appellants on the basis of the findings of the impugned judgments.

On consideration, the appeal is hereby dismissed as withdrawn and not pressed with liberties aforesaid as prayed by the Senior Advocate of the appellants. There shall be no order as to costs.

However, it is made clear that whenever and wherever aforesaid objection is taken on behalf of the appellants in any other proceedings, then respondents-plaintiffs shall be at liberty to rebut such objection and argument in accordance with the procedure prescribed under the law.

Considering the oral prayer of the Senior Advocate of the appellants, the office is directed to return certified copy of the impugned judgment of the appellate court to the assisting counsel by retaining its photo copy on record enabling him to file appropriate proceeding before appropriate forum or to file a civil revision under section 115 of CPC.

C.C