Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Special Deputy Collector v. Peddireddy Madhava Reddy

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Mar 1, 2013

G. Rohini, J.:— The Special Deputy Collector (Land Acquisition), Somasila Project, Unit-IV, Rajampet filed this appeal under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short ‘the Act’) aggrieved by the enhancement of compensation awarded by the Court of the District Judge, Kadapa (hereinafter referred to as the “Reference Court”) in L.A.O.P No. 43 of 2000, whereas the respondents/claimants filed the Cross-Objections contending that the enhancement awarded by the Reference Court is not adequate.

2. The brief facts of the case are as under:

A large extent of Ac.302-52 cents situated in Bukkayapalli village Siddipet Taluk, Kadapa District, was acquired for the purpose of submergence under Somasila Project vide notification dated 29.12.1977 published under section 4(1) of the Act. After due enquiry, the Land Acquisition Officer passed Award No. 4 of 1980 dated 12.12.1980 under which the acquired land was categorised into six categories and the market value was fixed at the rate of Rs. 12,000/-, Rs. 10,000/-, Rs. 5,000/-, Rs. 2,100/-, Rs. 1,050/-, and Rs. 300/- per acre for categories I to VI respectively. So far as the fruit bearing trees existing on the land are concerned, the Land Acquisition Officer had identified 14 varieties of trees and awarded compensation for each variety at different rates.

3. Not being satisfied with the quantum of compensation awarded, the claimants sought reference under Section 18 of the Act. The reference was numbered as LAOP. No. 43 of 2000 on the file of the Court of the District Judge, Kadapa and on appreciation of the evidence adduced by both the parties, the Reference Court by order dated 25.02.2002 granted enhancement of compensation by 200% for all categories of the land. So far as the trees and structures are concerned, the compensation awarded by the Land Acquisition Officer was enhanced by 100%.

4. Hence, the present appeal by the Land Acquisition Officer contending that the enhancement awarded by the Reference Court was unreasonable and excessive. On the other hand, it is contended by the respondents/Cross-objectors in the Cross-Objections that the compensation awarded by the Reference Court both for the land and the trees was not adequate in the light of the evidence available on record.

5. We have heard Sri. Giri Krishna, the learned Special Government Pleader appearing for the appellant and Sri. M. Subrahmanyam, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents/cross-objectors.

6. The learned Government Pleader appearing for the appellant contended that the Reference Court committed a grave error in granting the enhancement of 200% for the lands and 100% for the trees in the absence of any positive or cogent material or legally acceptable evidence for granting such enhancement.

7. Refuting the contention of the learned Government Pleader that no clear evidence was available, Sri. M. Subrahmanyam, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents/claimants, vehemently contended that the Reference Court ought to have awarded much higher compensation for all categories of land and also the trees.

8. In the light of the submissions made by the learned counsel on either side, the point that requires consideration is whether the enhancement of compensation awarded by the Reference Court is just and reasonable.

Compensation for the land:

9. The Referring Officer got himself examined as P.W.1 before the Reference Court and Exs.A1 and A2 documents were marked in evidence through him. So far as the claimants are concerned, R.Ws.1 to 12 were examined and Exs.B1 to B17 documents were marked on their behalf.

10. Ex.A1 is the award passed by the Land Acquisition Officer, dated 12.12.1980 in Award No. 4/1980, whereas Ex.A2 is the Notes of Inspection and Valuation submitted by the Special Deputy Collector (Land Acquisition), Somasila Project Unit-I, Badvel in respect of the lands coming under submersion for Somasila Project, Reach No. 1 of Bukkayapalli Village.

11. Coming to the evidence adduced on behalf of the claimants, two of the claimants got themselves examined as R.Ws.1 & 8 and the sale deeds, dated 9.12.1976, 1.4.1975, 23.6.1975 and 27.6.1975 were marked as Exs.B-1 to B-4 to substantiate the market value of the lands acquired as per their claim statements. They also marked the certified copies of the orders of the Court of the Senior Civil Judge, Rajampet in LAOP No. 40 of 1997 & batch, dated 23.10.1998, LAOP No. 266 of 1989 & batch, dated 16.1.1993, LAOP No. 34/1995 & batch, dated 18.5.1996 and LAOP No. 343/1989, dated 16.1.1993 as Exs.B8, B9, B12 & B14 respectively.

12. Ex.B12 related to the land situated in Eppiralla Village of Kadapa District. The said land was also acquired for the purpose of submergence under Somasila Project under Section 4(1) notification dated 17.11.1977 and the Land Acquisition Officer categorized the acquired lands into five categories and fixed the compensation. On reference under Section 18 of the Act, the Reference Court under Ex.B12, dated 18.5.1996 fixed the compensation at the rate of Rs. 20,000/- for Categories I & II, Rs. 6,000/- for Categories III & IV and Rs. 1,000/- for Category V. Though the Land Acquisition Officer preferred A.S No. 1631 of 1999, the said appeal was dismissed by this Court by judgment dated 15.09.1999 The said judgment in A.S No. 1631 of 1999 was marked as Ex.B13

13. Apart from the above mentioned evidence adduced on behalf of the claimants, the Reference Court has also taken into consideration the admitted fact that the entire village of Bukkayapalli got submerged under Somasila Project and the lands acquired were all agricultural lands which were the only source of livelihood of the claimants and accordingly awarded 200% enhancement for the lands and 100% enhancement for the trees and structures.

14. Whereas the learned Government Pleader appearing for the appellants vehemently contended that the enhancement granted by the Reference court is highly excessive, Sri. M. Subrahmanyam, the learned counsel for the respondents/cross-objectors contended that the Court below committed a grave error in awarding compensation at different rates by categorizing the lands. While submitting that the entire lands of Bukkayapalli Village are irrigable throughout the year with good water source, the learned counsel contended that the Court below was not justified in awarding very meagre compensation for the Categories II to VI.

15. As noticed above, Ex.A2 marked by the Referring Officer (PW.1) is the Notes of Inspection and Valuation submitted by the Special Deputy Collector (Land Acquisition), Somasila Project Unit-I, Badvel in respect of the lands liable for submersion under Somasila Project in Reach No. 1 of Bukkayapalli Village. The geographical location of the lands acquired under the present notification was explained in detail in Ex.A2 and a perusal of the same shows that the lands in question were located at a convenient distance from the water source and that the rains were vigorous and plenty during the North-East monsoon. Even in the South-West monsoon, there were adequate rains for raising crops for the last five years and there was no drought in the said area. While explaining that river Penna is the Southern boundary to the village and that two tanks namely Thummalavanka Madugu and Kallevagu are existing in the village itself, it was also mentioned in the Notes of Inspection (Ex.A2) that the availability of plenty of water in a close proximity was a boon to the ryots to harvest the crops without depending upon the monsoon rains and thus the lands in question were of superior category than the lands of other villages situated around Bukkayapalli village. Even with regard to the nature of the soil, it was mentioned that the moisture retention power of the soil had abundantly helped the successful growth of each crop. It was also mentioned that the lands on the Eastern side of the bank of the irrigation sources were at a higher level and they were having potential for raising three crops in a year and that they were also suitable for raising garden crops. It was explained that the percolated water in the midst of the field remains in the land sufficiently for a long period for cultivating wet crops like paddy successfully. Thus it was concluded that on the whole the land in Bukkayapalli village was having more assured supply of water than any other village with a major irrigation source to its credit.

16. In the light of Ex.A2, it is clear that the lands in question are more valuable than the lands situated in the surrounding areas. Ex.A2 also shows that Eppiralla Village is situated on the Eastern side of the lands in question of Bukkayapalli Village. The documents marked on behalf of the claimants included Ex.B12 i.e, the award of the Reference Court in LAOP No. 34/1995 relating to the lands situated in Eppiralla Village which were acquired by notification dated 17.11.1977 Ex.B-12 shows that the lands in Eppiralla Village were single crop lands and that the Land Acquisition Officer categorized the lands into five categories and fixed the compensation at Rs. 7,000/-, Rs. 5,000/-, Rs. 2,100/-, Rs. 150/- and Rs. 300/- respectively. However the Reference Court enhanced the compensation to Rs. 20,000/- per acre for categories I & II and Rs. 6,000/- for categories III & IV and Rs. 1,000/- for category-V by Award dated 18.05.1996 Though the Land Acquisition Officer carried the matter to this Court by filing A.S No. 1631 of 1999, the same was dismissed by a Division Bench of this Court under Ex.B13, dated 15.9.1999

17. Having regard to the facts and circumstances noticed above, particularly in view of Ex.A-2 which makes it clear that the lands in Bukkayapalli Village are more valuable lands yielding three crops per year, we find force in the submission of the learned counsel for the respondents/cross-objectors that the categorization of the lands in question into different categories purportedly on the basis of the availability of water for cultivation is without any basis. In fact, even according to the Land Acquisition Officer, for categories III & IV lands, water facilities were available on par with categories I & II. Coming to categories V & VI, even assuming that they are not under cultivation as on the date of acquisition, as they are irrigable and fertile lands, according to us they cannot be treated as inferior in value. It is no doubt true that the Reference Court granted 200% enhancement even for the categories III to VI, however, the very categorization of the said lands by the Land Acquisition Officer on an assumption that they are inferior in value and fixing meagre amounts as compensation for the categories III to VI being erroneous, the enhancement granted by the Reference Court, in our considered opinion, is not sufficient and it does not reflect the correct market value as provided under Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act. We are also of the opinion that the Reference Court is not justified in awarding lesser amount for Category-II lands since there is no basis for differentiating the said lands into Category-I & Category-II. It is also relevant to note that so far as the lands in Eppiralla village, which are single crop lands, the Reference Court awarded Rs. 20,000/- for Categories I & II per acre and the same was upheld by this Court in Ex.B-13 - judgment in A.S No. 1631 of 1999.

18. The learned counsel for the respondents submitted that though against the judgment of this Court in A.S No. 1631 of 1999 the Land Acquisition Officer carried the matter to the Supreme Court, the SLP was dismissed by order dated 1.3.2002 The said fact has not been disputed by the learned Government Pleader.

19. That being so, while upholding the compensation awarded by the Court below at the rate of Rs. 36,000/- per acre for Category-I lands, we hold that for Category-II lands also the claimants are entitled to compensation at Rs. 36,000/- per acre. With regard to Categories-III & IV lands, we deem it appropriate to award Rs. 20,000/- per acre on par with the lands covered by Exs.B12 & B13. So far as the categories V & VI are concerned, though they are found to be not under cultivation, having regard to the potentiality of the said lands, it would be appropriate to award at least half of the said amount being Rs. 10,000/- per acre.

Compensation for trees:

20. Coming to the compensation for trees, Ex.A-2 - Notes of Inspection and Valuation submitted by the Special Deputy Collector (LA), Somasila Project, Unit-I, shows that a large extent of the acquired land was covered by various types of fruit bearing trees. Ex.A-2 reveals that the fruit bearing trees included Mango, Acid lime, Coconut, Tamarind, Soap-nut, Guava, Jack-fruit, Pomegranate, Drumstick, Dates, Neredu, Sapota & Palmyra and it has come out in the evidence of the claimants that all the trees were fully grown up and were yielding good crops every year.

21. However, the Land Acquisition Officer had awarded meagre amounts towards compensation for each tree without taking into consideration the yield and the income that was being received by the claimants every year.

22. In their claim statement before the Reference Court the claimants claimed Rs. 15,000/- per each Mango tree, Rs. 7,000/- for each Acid Lime tree, Rs. 10,000/- for each Coconut tree, Rs. 10,000/- for each Tamarind tree, Rs. 10,000/- for each Soap-nut tree, Rs. 6,000/- for each Guava tree, Rs. 5,000/- for each Jack-fruit tree, Rs. 800/- for each Pomegranate tree, Rs. 5,000/- for each Drumstick tree, Rs. 3,000/- for each Maragosa (Neem) tree, Rs. 3,000/- for each Dirasanam tree, Rs. 3,000/- for each Nalla Thumma (Black Babul) Tree, Rs. 2,500/- for each Palmyra tree, Rs. 1,500/- for each Dates tree, Rs. 2,500/- for each Ravi (Peepul) tree, Rs. 3,000/- for each Sunkesula Marri (Banyan) tree, Rs. 4,000/- for each Neredu (Black-plum) tree and Rs. 5,000/- for each Sapota (Sapodilla) tree. However, the Reference Court without taking into consideration the evidence available on record merely granted 100% enhancement without assigning any specific reasons therefor. Having regard to the fact that all the trees were fully grown up and were yielding good crops every year, it is contended in the appeal before us that the enhancement granted by the Reference Court was absolutely inadequate and that the Reference Court committed a grave error in not taking into consideration the yield and income out of the said trees.

23. One of the important documents marked on behalf of the claimants in support of their claim for compensation for trees existing on the acquired land was Ex.B16 - a copy of Award No. 3/1997, dated 20.09.1997 relating to the lands situated in Veerlapalli Village of Kadapa District which were acquired vide Section 4(1) notification, dated 25.04.1992 Under Ex.B-16, the Land Acquisition Officer awarded compensation of Rs. 17,47,339/- for the trees existing on the acquired land. On a reference, the Reference Court by order dated 25.02.2002 in OP No. 851 of 1999 enhanced the compensation and granted Rs. 4,000/- for each Cheeni tree and Rs. 20,000/- for each Tamarind tree. Aggrieved by the same, the Land Acquisition Officer filed A.S No. 1652 of 2002. The said appeal was disposed of by this Court along with A.S No. 1288 of 2002 and by common judgment dated 24.10.2005, the appeals were allowed and the matter was remitted to the Reference Court for fresh consideration. On such remand, the Reference Court after giving an opportunity to both the parties to adduce fresh evidence passed an order dated 15.4.2010 holding that so far as the fruit bearing trees are concerned the compensation should be determined on yield basis by applying multiplier ‘16’. Accordingly, for Cheeni trees the compensation was fixed at Rs. 5,000/- each and for Tamarind trees Rs. 35,000/- was granted for each tree. So far as Margosa (Neem) trees are concerned, the value was fixed at Rs. 20,000/- per each tree.

24. It is also brought to our notice that in pursuance of the remand order in A.S No. 1288 of 2002, a fresh order dated 15.04.2010 was passed by the Reference Court in LAOP No. 438 of 2001 in respect of the land in Veerlapalli Village and adopting the capitalization method by taking into consideration the annual yield and applying the multiplier ‘16’, the market value of the acquired land was fixed at Rs. 1,92,000/- per acre. A copy of the said order in LAOP No. 438 of 2001, dated 15.04.2010 has been placed before us. We have also observed that one of the claimants in Award No. 3/1997 was examined as RW.10 before the Reference Court. To substantiate their claim for higher compensation for trees, the claimants also marked Ex.B5 which is the certified copy of the price list issued by the Marketing Committee, Kadapa with regard to the Turmeric crop for the years 1977-78 and 1978-79. They also marked Ex.B6 which is the certified copy of the price list with regard to Groundnut and Bajra for the years 1977-78 and Ex.B7-certified copy of the Commissioner's report regarding Paddy crop.

25. The claimants examined R.W.11, a retired Assistant Director of Horticulture who deposed about the valuation of the trees. Similarly the Senior Marketing Officer in the Market-yard, Kadapa was examined as RW.12 and he deposed about the valuation of Turmeric, Onions and Citrus fruits.

26. In the light of the evidence noticed above, particularly Exs.B5 to B7 coupled with the oral evidence of RWs.11 & 12, the learned counsel for the respondents/Cross-objectors submitted that the Reference Court ought to have awarded much higher compensation on yield basis by adopting the multiplier system.

27. In support of his submission, the learned counsel relied upon ASST. COMMISSIONER-CUM-LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER v. S.T POMPANNA SETTY (2005) 9 SCC 662, LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER v. KAMADANA RAMAKRISHNA RAO 2007 (4) ALT (SC) 29 and G.S RAMI REDDY v. SPL. DY. COLLECTOR, LAO, SRBC, NANDYAL 2000 (4) ALD 620.

28. Having regard to the evidence, both oral and documentary, adduced by the claimants with regard to the value of the yield from all varieties of trees existing on the land in question, we find force in the submission of the learned counsel for the respondents/Cross-objectors.

29. As held in the decisions cited by the learned counsel for the respondents, it would be appropriate to award compensation on yield basis for fruit bearing trees by adopting the multiplier system. Therefore, we are of the opinion that the Reference Court committed an error in granting the enhancement without taking into consideration the evidence available on record and without assigning any reasons for restricting the enhancement to 100%.

30. It has come out in the evidence of R.W.1 & R.W.11 read with Exs.B-14 to B-17 that the life of the Mango trees is 70 years and that each tree will yield 500 kgs. per year. The evidence also shows that value of each kilogram being Rs. 8/-, the total net income out of each tree per year would be Rs. 4,000/- and that even after deducting the expenses, the income would be Rs. 3,750/- per year. The evidence further shows that the Citrus tree gives four (4) crops per year and net income out of each tree is Rs. 1,000/- per year and that the life of Citrus tree is 30 years. So far as Coconut tree is concerned, each tree yields 200 coconuts per year and its life is 57 years. Similarly, Tamarind tree yields minimum 1000 kgs. per tree and virtually there would be no expenses. So far as Drumstick trees are concerned, the life period is 20 years and each tree yields minimum 1000 drumsticks per year.

31. With regard to Guava trees the evidence shows that the life period of the tree is 40 years and each tree would yield minimum 1000 fruits. The life time of Jack-fruit is 80 years and each tree yields minimum 100 fruits. So far as Pomegranate is concerned, the life time of the tree is 25 years and it yields three (3) crops per year at the rate of 300 to 350 fruits per each crop.

32. Having regard to such a detailed evidence available with regard to the yield from the fruit bearing trees, it appears to us that the compensation should have been determined on yield basis by applying the appropriate multiplier.

33. In identical circumstances, ASST. COMMISSIONER-CUM-LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER v. S.T POMPANNA SETTY (supra) it was held that where compensation is awarded on yield basis multiplier ‘10’ is considered to be proper and appropriate. While relying upon the principles laid down in the said decision, the learned counsel for the respondents/Cross-objectors submitted that the compensation for trees may be awarded by applying multiplier ‘10’. However, the learned Government Pleader vehemently contended that the said issue requires consideration by the Reference Court and therefore the matter may be remanded for fixing the compensation on yield basis by adopting the multiplier system.

34. As the acquisition is of the year 1977, the matter cannot be delayed any further and therefore we are not inclined to remand the matter. We have also observed that in the Cross-objections the respondents are not insisting on the exact amounts on application of multiplier, but their claim is confined to Rs. 5,000/- per each tree for Mango, Acid Lime, Coconut, Guava, Jack-fruit and Sapota (Sapodilla). So far as Tamarind and Soap-nut is concerned, their claim is at the rate of Rs. 8,000/- and Rs. 7,000/- respectively per each tree. For the trees of Pomegranate, Drumstick and Neredu (Black-plum), they claimed Rs. 4,000/- per each tree. Similarly for the trees of Dates and Palmyra, they claimed Rs. 300/- per each tree and for the remaining trees at the rate of Rs. 400/- per each tree. Accordingly, instead of remanding the matter, we deem it appropriate to give a quietus to the controversy by fixing the compensation for the fruit bearing trees as under:

For Mango, Acid Lime, Coconut, Guava, Jack-fruit and Sapota (Sapodilla), the claimants-respondents/cross-objectors shall be entitled to compensation at the rate of Rs. 3,000/- per each tree. So far as Tamarind and Soap-nut are concerned, they shall be entitled to Rs. 6,000/- and Rs. 5,000/- respectively per each tree. For the trees of Pomegranate, Drumstick and Neredu (Black-plum), they shall be entitled to Rs. 2,000/- per each tree. For the trees of Dates & Palmyra, they shall be entitled to Rs. 300/- per each tree and for the remaining trees they shall be entitled to Rs. 400/- per each tree.

35. In the light of the evidence available on record, particularly having regard to the orders passed in LAOP No. 851 of 1999 and LAOP No. 431 of 2001 on remand on 15.04.2010 determining the compensation for the fruit bearing trees, we are of the opinion that the compensation as mentioned above for each variety of trees is just and reasonable.

36. As already held above, for Category-I & II lands acquired the respondents/cross-objectors are entitled to compensation at the rate of Rs. 36,000/- per acre, for Category-III & IV lands, they are entitled to Rs. 20,000/- per acre and for Category-V & VI lands they are entitled to Rs. 10,000/- per acre.

37. Accordingly, the Appeal is dismissed and Cross-Objections are allowed in part to the extent indicated above. The respondents/Cross-objectors shall also be entitled to all the statutory benefits on the enhanced amount. No costs.