- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Gangappa v. Fakkirappa
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner-plaintiff filed applications under Order 151 CPC read with Section 46 of the Karnataka Stamp Act seeking return of agreements of sale for presentation to the Deputy Commissioner, Dharwad, to enable collection of any deficit stamp duty. During hearing the court below found that sufficient stamp duty had not been paid, impounded the agreement of sale dated 16.05.2006, directed the document to be kept in safe custody, and directed the CMO to calculate proper stamp duty and penalty and collect the same from the plaintiff within 30 days; on payment, a certified copy and the challan were to be sent to the Deputy Commissioner for verification. The petitioner had filed two suits for specific performance and challenged similar orders in both, resulting in the present petitions.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the court or its office may determine and direct recovery of the deficit stamp duty and penalty from the plaintiff by ordering calculation and collection.
- Whether, in light of Sri K. Govinde Gowda v. Smt. Akkayamma (ILR 2011 KAR 4719), the court has no discretion to determine the penalty and the penalty should be limited to Rs. 5/-.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- Counsel relied on Sri K. Govinde Gowda v. Smt. Akkayamma (ILR 2011 KAR 4719) to contend that the Court has no discretion to determine the penalty and that, in the present case, the penalty should not exceed Rs. 5/-.
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any opposing party's legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sri K. Govinde Gowda v. Smt. Akkayamma (ILR 2011 KAR 4719) | To contend that the Court has no discretion to determine the penalty and that the penalty should not be more than Rs. 5/-. | The court noted the reliance but declined to consider the submission in view of Paragraph 9 of the impugned order; instead directed the court below to permit written submissions and have the concerned officer consider them when determining deficit stamp duty and penalty. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court observed the petitioner's reliance on the cited judgment but refrained from deciding the contention because the court below had already opined (in Paragraph 9 of its order) that it was appropriate to direct the office to determine the proper stamp duty and penalty. As neither the deficit stamp duty nor the penalty had been determined by the office to date, the court considered it appropriate to allow the petitioner an opportunity to place written submissions and supporting judgments on record. The court directed that, if such submissions are filed within one week, the court below must instruct the concerned officer to take them into account when determining the deficit stamp duty and penalty. All contentions regarding deficit stamp duty and penalty were kept open for determination by the court below and the officer tasked with calculation.
Holding and Implications
DISPOSED OF
Direct effects: Both petitions were disposed of with the direction that the petitioner may file written submissions and supporting judgments within one week, and the court below shall direct the concerned officer to consider these submissions when determining the deficit stamp duty and penalty on the agreements. All contentions on deficit stamp duty and penalty remain open for determination. The opinion does not purport to set any new precedent.
PO:
1. In both these petitions the orders under challenge are similar. The petitioner-plaintiff had filed applications u/S 151 of CPC r/w Sec. 46 of Karnataka Stamp Act and prayed for return of the agreements to sell for presentation to the Deputy Commissioner, Dharwad, for collection of deficit stamp duty, if any, on the said documents.
2. In the course of hearing of the applications it revealed that sufficient stamp duty was not paid and in view thereof the Court below dismissed the applications with the following directions as reflected in the operative portion of the order:
“The agreement of sale dt. 16.05.2006 is impounded and the same is to be kept in the safe custody of this court. Further, CMO is hereby directed to calculate proper stamp and penalty on the agreement of sole dt. 16.05.2006 and collect the said stamp duty and penalty from the plaintiff within the 30 days from, the date of this order. If the plaintiff paid the deficit stamp duty and penalty then the certified copy of the above said agreement of sale and the challan of payment of stamp duty and penalty be sent to Deputy Commissioner for verification of the conectnecs of stamp duty and penalty paid by the plaintiff.”
---
3. The plaintiff filed two suits for specific performance of two different agreements and in both the cases the orders impugned in the present petitions, are similar.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner, at the outset, invited my attention to the judgment of this Court in Sri K. Govinde Gowda v. Smt. Akkayamma (ILR 2011 KAR 4719), to contend that the Court has no discretion to determine the penalty and in the fact of the present case, the penalty should not be more than Rs. 5/-. I would not like to consider this submission in view of the observations made in Paragraph no. 9 of the impugned order. In this Paragraph the Court below has opined that it is just and necessary to give direction to the office to determine proper stamp duty and penalty on the agreement of sale and recover the same from the petitioner-plaintiff Admittedly, till this date neither the stamp duty not the penalty has been determined by the office. In view thereof, I am satisfied that this petition can be conveniently disposed of with the following direction, which both the learned counsel for the Parties have agreed for:
The Court below shall allow the petitioner to place his written submissions, if any, on record along with the judgments he desires to rely upon, within a period of one week from today. If the petitioner files his written submissions along with the supporting judgments, the Court below shall direct the concerned officer to take that into consideration while determining the deficit stamp duty and penalty on the agreements in question. All the contentions insofar as the deficit stamp duty and the penalty are concerned, are kept open.
With these observations, both the petitions are disposed of.
Alert