Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Virendra Mishra v. Pusauram Patel & Others.

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Jan 9, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This first appeal arises from an order dated 20.06.2015 passed by the 2nd Additional District Judge (A.D.J), Jabalpur, in Execution Case No. 87A/2004 × 14. The appellant, who is the judgment debtor, challenged the disallowance of his applications under Order 21 Rule 97 and Order 21 Rule 29 of the Code of Civil Procedure (C.P.C) by the executing court.

The underlying civil suit (No. 87A/2004) was filed by the respondent/plaintiff before the 6th A.D.J, Jabalpur, seeking specific performance of contract but was dismissed on 15.02.2005. The plaintiff/respondent then filed a first appeal (No. 519/2005), which was allowed by the Division Bench of this Court on 05.12.2013, setting aside the trial court’s decree and decreeing the plaintiff’s claim with costs.

Subsequently, the execution case (Ex. No. 87A/2004 × 14) was initiated before the 2nd A.D.J, Jabalpur. The appellant/defendant filed two applications under Order 21 Rule 97 and Order 21 Rule 29 of the C.P.C, seeking to stay execution on the ground that the decree was obtained by misrepresentation and should be treated as nullity. The executing court declined to stay the execution, holding that the judgment debtor should have preferred a second appeal instead of seeking to stall execution.

The appellant also contended that certain conditions in the sale deed, specifically a “re-purchase” clause, violated Sections 10 and 11 of the Transfer of Property Act and Article 300-A of the Constitution of India, rendering the decree passed by the Division Bench null and void. This objection was also rejected by the executing court.

Aggrieved by the executing court’s order, the appellant preferred this first appeal under Section 96 read with Order 21 Rule 103 of the C.P.C, challenging the impugned order as being without application of mind and reiterating the alleged violations of statutory provisions and constitutional rights.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the executing court erred in refusing to stay execution of the decree on the ground that the judgment debtor should have preferred a second appeal instead of filing applications under Order 21 Rule 97 and Rule 29 C.P.C.
  2. Whether the decree passed by the Division Bench of this Court is null and void due to alleged violations of Sections 10 and 11 of the Transfer of Property Act and Article 300-A of the Constitution of India, specifically relating to a “re-purchase” clause in the sale deed.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The decree obtained by the plaintiffs was based on misrepresentation of facts and should be treated as a nullity.
  • The appellant prayed for the execution proceedings to be stayed under Order 21 Rule 97 and Rule 29 of the C.P.C.
  • The conditions imposed in the sale deed, including a “re-purchase” clause, violated Sections 10 and 11 of the Transfer of Property Act and Article 300-A of the Constitution of India.
  • The judgment and decree dated 05.12.2013 passed by the Division Bench should be declared null and the impugned order set aside.

Respondent's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court observed that the appellant, being aggrieved by the judgment and decree passed by the Division Bench of this Court, had the remedy of preferring a second appeal before the competent Court but failed to do so. The executing court rightly declined to stay execution proceedings, emphasizing that execution courts must execute decrees in their letter and spirit unless set aside by appropriate appellate remedy. The Court found no impropriety, illegality, or irregularity in the impugned order and thus upheld the executing court’s decision. The objections regarding the “re-purchase” clause and alleged statutory and constitutional violations were also dismissed without sustaining the appellant’s contentions.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is that the execution of the decree passed by the Division Bench shall continue without stay. The Court reaffirmed the principle that execution proceedings cannot be stalled on grounds that should have been raised in a second appeal. No new precedent was established by this decision.

Show all summary ...

Sushil Kumar Palo, J.:— This first appeal under Section 96 read with Order 21 Rule 103 C.P.C has been preferred by the appellant/judgment debtor assailing the order dated 20.06.2015 passed by the 2nd A.D.J, Jabalpur in Ex. No. 87A/2004 × 14 wherein the application under Order 21 Rule 97 and Order 21 Rule 29 of the C.P.C were disallowed by the Executing Court.

2. Brief facts just necessary for disposal of this appeal are that Civil Suit No. 87A/2004 was filed by the respondent/plaintiff before the 6th A.D.J, Jabalpur which was decided on 15.02.2005 wherein the civil suit seeking relief of specific performance of contract was dismissed. The plaintiff/respondent (in the present case) preferred First Appeal No. 519/2005 in which the Division Bench of this Court has allowed the appeal filed by the plaintiffs and set aside the decree passed by the trial Court and the claim of the plaintiffs has been decreed with cost.

3. Subsequently, Ex. No. 87A/2004 × 14 pending before the 2 A.D.J, Jabalpur has been filed, which is in progress. In the said execution case, the appellant (in the present case)/defendant filed two applications one under Order 21 Rule 97 and the other under Order 21 Rule 29 of C.P.C and prayed for not to proceed with the execution on the ground that the decree has been obtained by the plaintiffs with misrepresenting the facts, hence, the said judgment/decree or order passed by the first appellate Court be treated as nullity.

4. The learned executing Court vide order impugned dated 20.06.2015 passed in Ex. No. 87A/2004 × 14 has expressed its inability to allow the application on the ground that judgment debtor/defendant, if aggrieved, could have preferred second appeal before the appropriate Court. But he has not done so. Therefore, the execution cannot be stayed for the executing Court has to execute the decree in its later and spirit.

5. The second objection raised by the appellant (in the present case)/defendant is that the conditions imposed in the sale deed could not have been imposed for there was clause of “re-purchase” of the property, which is violative of Sections 10, 11 of the Transfer of Property Act and Article 300-A of the Constitution of India. Hence, the decree passed by the Division Bench of this High Court on 05.12.2013 has been obtained by the plaintiffs/decree holder, is a nullity and non-est in the eyes of law.

6. The same has also been disposed, by the order impugned. The executing Court observed that the objection raised by the judgment debtor cannot be sustained, therefore, proceeding cannot be stayed.

7. Aggrieved by this common order, the appellant (in the present case)/defendant has preferred this appeal under Section 96 read with Order 21 Rule 103 of the C.P.C on the ground that the impugned order is without application of mind. The appellant claimed that there is violation of Sections 10, 11 of the Transfer of Property Act as well as read with Section 300-A of the Constitution of India and also proceeded to request this Court to treat the judgment and decree dated 05.12.2013 passed by the Division Bench of this Court as a nullity and to set aside the order impugned dated 20.06.2015

8. Considered the above. Had the appellant/defendant aggrieved by the judgment and decree passed by the Division Bench of this Court in First Appeal No. 519/2005 dated 05.12.2013, he could have preferred a second appeal before the competent Court. I do not see any impropriety, illegality or irregularity in the order impugned. Therefore, this appeal is dismissed.