Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of Karnataka v. Vivekananda M. Hallur

Karnataka High Court
Jun 3, 2013
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants are members of the Kendra Upadhyayara Sangha (R), Bangalore South Taluk, which was formed in 1968 to provide residential sites to its members, who are teachers. The Sangha developed a layout at Nagarbhavi village, Bangalore, and allotted sites on a lease-cum-sale basis, executing lease-cum-sale agreements in 1989-90. Stamp duty and registration fees were collected based on the sale consideration in these agreements. Subsequently, the appellants presented absolute sale deeds for registration executed by the Sangha’s office bearers.

The Sub-Registrar, relying on Section 2(mm) of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957, collected stamp duty based on the market value of the property on the date of presentation of the absolute sale deed, along with registration fees. The appellants filed writ petitions challenging the legality of this collection and sought refund of the stamp duty and registration fees with interest.

The learned Single Judge allowed the writ petitions relying on Article 5(e) of the Karnataka Stamp Act, directing refund of the stamp duty and recalculation of registration fees treating the absolute sale deed as a supplementary document. Aggrieved by this order, the present appeals were filed.

Earlier, these appeals were dismissed by the High Court without condoning delay. The appellants approached the Supreme Court, which ordered the High Court to condone delay and hear the matter on merits concerning the Karnataka Stamp Act provisions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the learned Single Judge erred in granting relief without considering the effect of Section 2(mm) of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957.
  2. Whether Section 2(mm) applies to the absolute sale deed presented pursuant to an earlier executed lease-cum-sale agreement.
  3. Whether the absolute sale deed should be considered a primary document or a supplementary document for the purpose of stamp duty and registration fee calculation.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Government Advocate)

  • The learned Single Judge failed to consider Section 2(mm) of the Karnataka Stamp Act along with Article 5(e).
  • The case should be examined considering both provisions together to determine the correct stamp duty liability.
  • If both provisions were considered, the writ petitions would not have been allowed.

Respondents' Arguments (Impleading Applicants' Counsel)

  • The sale deed executed by the Sangha should not be treated as a separate document since the lease-cum-sale agreement was executed earlier with stamp duty paid based on sale consideration.
  • Once stamp duty is paid on market value under the lease-cum-sale agreement and possession delivered, Section 2(mm) does not apply to the absolute sale deed.
  • The absolute sale deed should be considered a supplementary document to the lease-cum-sale agreement.
  • Registration fees were correctly collected as per Note-7 of the registration fee table under Section 78 of the Registration Act, 1908.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the interplay between Section 2(mm) and Article 5(e) of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957. Section 2(mm) defines "market value" for stamp duty calculation as the higher of the consideration stated or the market value on the date of execution or presentation of the instrument, except in cases involving government or local authorities. Article 5(e) prescribes stamp duty rates on agreements relating to sale of immovable property, distinguishing between delivery and non-delivery of possession.

The court noted that the lease-cum-sale agreements were executed between 1987-90, before Section 2(mm) was introduced in 2003. The learned Single Judge had granted relief relying solely on Article 5(e) without considering Section 2(mm), which was now applicable to documents presented after 01.04.2003.

The court held that Section 2(mm) and Article 5(e) must be read together and not in isolation. Since the absolute sale deed was presented after the effective date of Section 2(mm), the Sub-Registrar was justified in collecting stamp duty based on market value at the date of presentation.

The court distinguished between stamp duty, a tax imposed on property conveyance, and registration fee, a fee for registration services, affirming that registration fees must be collected as per the Registration Act's schedule.

Regarding the nature of the absolute sale deed, the court held that it is a primary document conveying title and cannot be treated as a supplementary document, rejecting the respondents' argument to the contrary.

Holding and Implications

The appeals are allowed. The order of the learned Single Judge directing refund of stamp duty and registration fee is set aside.

Consequently, the appellants are not entitled to a refund of stamp duty collected on the absolute sale deed presented after 01.04.2003 under Section 2(mm) of the Karnataka Stamp Act. The absolute sale deed is treated as a primary document for stamp duty purposes.

The court also clarified that the impleading applicants may seek appropriate relief regarding penalty and interest by making necessary applications before the learned Single Judge, as those issues were not decided in the present appeals.

Where refunds have been made pursuant to the Single Judge’s order, the respondents are directed to redeposit the amounts with interest at 9% per annum from the date of receipt until deposit.

No new precedent was established beyond the direct effect on the parties involved.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

K.L Manjunath, J.:— These appeals were earlier dismissed by this Court without condoning the delay. Therefore, the matter was taken up by the appellants before the Hon'ble Supreme Court. The Hon'ble Supreme Court by its order dated 07.12.2012, allowed the Civil Appeal Nos. 8803-8805/2012 holding that the co-ordinate Division Bench of the High Court was required to condone the delay and consider the merits of the matter in relation to the provisions of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957. Therefore, the matters are listed for final hearing.

2. The facts leading to these appeals are as hereunder:—

The writ petitioners are the members of a Sangha known as Kendra Upadhyayara Sangha (R), Bangalore South Taluk. This Sangha was formed and registered in the year 1968 with the sole object of providing residential sites to its members and the teachers are the members of the Sangha. The layout was formed by the Sangha at Nagarbhavi village, Yeshwanthpura hobli, Bangalore. Sites were allotted to its members on lease-cum-sale basis. Accordingly, lease-cum-sale agreement was executed in the year 1989-90. Based on the sale consideration shown under the lease-cum-sale agreement, stamp duty and registration fees were collected by the Sub-Registrar. The members of the Sangha were also entitled to obtain absolute sale deed on fulfilling the terms and conditions of the allotment. Thereafter, the writ petitioners presented the absolute sale deed for the registration which was duly executed by the office bearers of the Sangha.

3. The concerned Sub-Registrar, relying upon Section 2(mm) of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957, collected the stamp duty from the writ petitioners considering the market value of the property conveyed to them on the date of the presentation of the document. Accordingly, registration fee was also collected. Thereafter, the writ petitions were filed to declare the collection of the stamp duty and registration charges by the Sub-Registrar on the execution of the sale deed was illegal and without authority of law and issue direction to refund the stamp duty and registration fee payable by the writ petitioners along with the interest at 24% p.a

4. The learned Single Judge relying upon Article 5(e) of the Karnataka Stamp Act allowed the writ petition directing the Registrar to refund the stamp duty collected by him on the sale deed presented by the writ petitioners and to calculate the registration fee payable on the basis of the registration table applicable to the absolute sale deed considering them as supplementary deeds and refund the same with interest within three months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of the order.

5. Aggrieved by the order of the learned single Judge, the present appeals are filed.

6. Sri. M. Keshava Reddy, learned Govt. Advocate contends that the learned Single Judge has committed serious error in not considering the effect of Section 2(mm) of the Act. According to him, he has no quarrel with regard to interpretation of Article 5(e) of the Act. According to him, the learned Single Judge was required to consider the case of the parties considering the provisions of Section 2(mm) r/w Article 5(e) of the Act. Further, he contends that if the learned single Judge has considered both the provisions, he would not have allowed the writ petitions. In the circumstances, he requests this Court to examine Section 2(mm) r/w Article 5(e) of the Act altogether and allow the writ appeals.

7. Sri. Srivatsa, learned senior Counsel appearing for the impleading applicants submit that the sale deed executed by the Sangha in favour of the writ petitioners could not be treated as a separate document, since the Sangha had executed the lease-cum-sale agreement at that point of time, the stamp duty was collected based on the sale consideration paid by the writ petitioners which was the market value. He further submits that once the stamp duty had been collected on the market value, as the possession of the property was delivered to the writ petitioners, the question of considering Section 2(mm) of the Act does not arise and such document has to be considered as a supplementary document to the lease-cum-sale agreement. Therefore, he contends that the learned single Judge is justified in granting relief to the writ petitioners.

8. Taking us through Note-7 of the table of registration fee made under Section 78 of the Registration Act, 1908 contends that the sub-registrar is required to collect registration fees in accordance with that and that the learned single Judge cannot be found fault with in granting the relief.

9. Having heard the learned Counsel for the parties, the only point to be considered in these appeals is, whether any error is committed by the learned Single Judge in granting relief to the writ petitioners without considering the effect of Section 2(mm) of the Act and whether Section 2(mm) would apply to the absolute sale deed presented pursuant to the lease-cum-sale agreement executed earlier?

10. The facts of these cases are not in dispute for the following reasons;

11. That the writ petitioners are the members of the Sangha. Sangha has formed layout. Sites were allotted to them long back. As per the terms and conditions of the agreement, lease-cum-sale deed were executed by the parties paying stamp duty as applicable on the date of presentation of the lease-cum-sale deed. But the question arises for our consideration is, whether the stamp duty has to be paid on the market value as on the date of presenting the sale deed irrespective of the stamp duty collected by the Sub-Registrar considering the sale consideration on the lease-curt)-sale agreement or not and whether the absolute sale deed presented for registration pursuant to lease-cum-sale agreement can be recorded as primary or supplementary document?

12. In order to appreciate the rival contentions, it would be appropriate for us to consider certain provisions of the Karnataka Stamp Act and so also the table of schedule concerning collection of registration fees framed pursuant to Section 78 of the Indian Registration Act.

13. Section 2(mm) reads as hereunder:

“Market Value” in relation to any property, which is the subject-matter of an instrument, means the price which such property would have fetched, in the opinion of the Deputy Commissioner or the Appellate Authority or the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority, if sold in open market on the date of execution of such instrument or the consideration stated in the instrument, whichever is higher:

Provided that notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or in the Articles, in respect of an instrument executed by or on behalf of or in favour of the State Government or the Central Government or a local authority or other authority constituted by or under any law for the time being in force or a Body incorporate wholly owned or controlled by the Central Government or the State Government the market value of the property shall be the value of consideration for such conveyance as set forth in the instrument.

14. Article 5(e) reads as hereunder:

Description of instrument Proper stamp duty Art. 5 Agreement or [its records or] Memorandum of an Agreement—
(e) If relating to sale of immovable property wherein part performance of the contract (i) possession of the property is delivered or is agreed to be delivered without executing the conveyance Same duty as a conveyance (No. 20) on the market value of the property. (ii) possession of the property is not delivered 0.25 rupee for every one hundred rupees or part thereof on the market value equal to the amount of consideration]

15. On combined reading of these two provisions of law, it is clear to us that whenever an instrument is presented for registration, it is the duty of the Sub-Registrar to collect the stamp duty considering the market value on the date of presentation of the document. Only exception in regard to the document executed by and/or on behalf of or in favour of the State Government or the Central Government or a local authority or other authority constituted by or under any law for the time being in force, or controlled by the Central Government or the State Government, the market value of the property shall be the value of consideration for such conveyance as set forth in the instrument.

16. Admittedly, lease-cum-sale agreements were executed by the parties in the present case between 1987-90. During relevant period, Section 2(mm) was not there under the Karnataka Stamp Act. It has been substituted by Act No. 8 of 2003. It has come into force with effect from 01.04.2003 If Section 2(mm) was not there on the date of presentation of the sale deed, we would have certainly appreciate the order of the learned single Judge in granting relief to the writ petitioners.

17. We have no quarrel over the interpretation of Article 5(e) of the Karnataka Stamp Act, because, if a party has already paid the stamp duty under Section 5(e), there is no question of collection of stamp duty again by the Sub-Registrar. But, unfortunately, in the instant case, the learned Single Judge without considering Section 2(mm), by considering only Article 5(e) of the Act has given relief to the petitioners. After 1.4.2093, Section 2(mm) and Article 5(e) are to be read and consider together and each of the provisions cannot be read in isolation. Therefore, we are of the opinion that an error is committed by the learned single Judge in granting relief to the writ petitioners.

18. So far as other point raised by learned Counsel for the respondents are concerned, there is a basic difference between the stamp duty payable by the party under the Karnataka Stamp Act and registration fee payable by the party when a document is presented for registration. Registration fee is altogether different from payment of stamp duty. Stamp duty is different from registration fee. Registration fee would be collected by the Sub-Registrar for the service rendered by him. It will always commensurate with the service extended to a party. So far as payment of stamp duty is concerned, it is more in the nature of tax and not fee and therefore, we have no quarrel with the points raised by the learned senior Counsel for the respondents in regard to collection of registration fee is concerned. Registration fee has to be collected as per the table pursuant to Section 78 of the Indian Registration Act.

19. The last point to be considered by us is, whether the document presented by the writ petitioners is a deed conveyance or to be considered as supplementary deed or it has to be considered as a primary document?

20. So far as this point is concerned, even if the lease-cum-sale agreement was executed earlier, a party will not get any title unless and until it is considered as conveyance under the absolute sale deed. Absolute sale deed cannot be considered as supplementary document. On the contrary, it has to be considered as primary document. Therefore, we cannot accept the arguments advanced by the learned Counsel for the respondents.

21. In the result, these appeals are allowed. The order of the teamed single Judge in directing the appellants to refund stamp duty and registration fee paid by them at the time of the writ petitioners presenting the absolute sale deed for registration is hereby set aside.

22. The additional respondents who are not parties before this Court had approached the Hon'ble Supreme Court along with the application in the civil appeals. Therefore, the applications are ordered to be considered by this Court pursuant to the order passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court while deciding the matter on merits. As a matter of fact, the case of the impleading applicants has not been considered by the learned Single Judge because their writ petitions were disposed of following the order called in question in these appeals. Though the judgment of this Court is squarely made applicable to the impleading applicants are concerned, they have also questioned the levy of penalty and interest. Since the said point is yet to be considered by the learned Single Judge, it is always open for them to make necessary applications for recalling of the order and dispose of their writ petition on merits and in accordance with law. With the above observations, the applications filed by the impleading applicants are disposed of.

23. At this stage, it is brought to our notice, pursuant to the order of the learned Single Judge, the stamp duty collected by the Sub-Registrar has been refunded to some of the writ petitioners. If it is so, it is for the respondents 1 to 3 to redeposit the amount with interest at 9% from the date of receipt of the said payment till the date of deposit before the concerned Sub-Registrar. Parties to bear their costs.