- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Company Limited v. Stephen
JUDGMENT
The 2 respondent is duly declared as served as per order dated 08.04.2010 The 1 respondent appears through counsel.
2. This appeal is at the instance of the insurer challenging the award dated 16.09.2009 in O.P(MV) No. 704 of 2003 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Neyyattinkara.
3. First respondent claimed that while riding a motor cycle belonging to the 2 respondent on 20.04.2003, a Jeep came from the opposite side. The motor cycle capsized resulting in injury to the 1 respondent. He claimed compensation under Section 163 A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short, “the Act”).
4. Appellant denied that there was any such accident as claimed by the 1 respondent. It also claimed that though a policy of insurance was issued in respect of the vehicle involved, that did not cover liability of a person like the 1 respondent.
5. The Tribunal negatived contentions of the appellant, allowed the claim petition and directed the appellant to deposit the amount. Hence this appeal.
6. Learned Senior Advocate for the appellant contended that case of the 1 respondent is not proved. My attention is drawn to Exts.B1 and B2, discharge summary of the 1 respondent and the pillion rider where the alleged history and cause of accident is stated as ‘non-medico legal case’. According to the learned counsel, that would indicate that the 1 respondent suffered injuries not in a motor accident. A further argument is that Ext.B1, policy covers only liability of owner-cum rider and that too, to the extent stated in Section 3 of Ext.B1, policy. It is argued that compensation more than the structured formula is awarded by the Tribunal.
7. So far as the accident is concerned, 1 respondent gave evidence as P.W.1 P.W.2 was examined to prove the alleged disability. In Exhibits B2 and B3, history and cause of accident is stated as ‘non-medico legal case’. What exactly is understood by that expression is not clear. It was appropriate that the 1 respondent examined the Medical Officer who prepared Exts.B2 and B3 to explain what was meant or intended by the expression ‘non-medico legal case’.
8. It also appears that the Tribunal has not considered the application of Ext.B1, policy to the 1 respondent who is the rider of the motor cycle in view of relevant clause in Ext.B1 including Section 3.
9. A further fact to be noticed is the contention raised by the appellant that compensation awarded is beyond structured formula. When a claim is preferred under Sec.163 A of the Act compensation can be awarded only as per the structured formula.
10. In the light of all the above, I am inclined to set aside the award and remit the case to the Tribunal for a fresh decision.
Resultantly the appeal is allowed by way of remand as under:
(i) Award dated 16.09.2009 in O.P(MV) No. 704 of 2003 of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Neyyattinkara is set aside.
(ii) O.P(MV) No. 704 of 2003 is remitted to the Tribunal for fresh decision of all questions involved, after giving both sides opportunity to adduce evidence in the case.
(iii) Parties shall suffer their costs in the appeal.
(iv) Parties shall appear in the Tribunal on 26.09.2013
All pending Interlocutory Applications will stand dismissed.
Alert