Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Satye Singh & Another v. State Of Uttarakhand

Uttarakhand High Court
Aug 29, 2013

Per: Servesh Kumar Gupta, J.

Appellant Satye Singh is the husband of the deceased lady Smt. Shashi, while another appellant Smt. Indra Devi is her mother-in-law. They have been convicted by the learned Sessions Judge, Tehri Garhwal for the offences under Section 302/34 and 201 IPC vide judgment and order dated 11.10.2010 rendered in Sessions Trial No. 22/2009 pertaining to Crime No. 16/2009, Revenue Police Station Bayargaon, District Tehri Garhwal. Learned Sessions Judge has appropriately sentenced the appellants for the said offences.

2. This is the gruesome murder of Smt. Shashi Devi, who was wedded with Satye Singh four years prior to the date of incident, which happened at any time between the evening of 27.6.2009 to the morning of 28.6.2009 Her considerably burnt dead body was found lying inside the Chhan, 2-3 kilometres away from the residential place of the appellants situated in village Gair, Patti Nagun, Revenue Police Station Bayargaon, Tehsil Tehri. (It may be added here that Chhan is a word in local dialect which carries the meaning of a room/animal shed having the roof of thatch and it is used mainly for keeping the cattle. It also contains some space meant for resting human being.) That Chhan was used by the father-in-law of the deceased for his rest in addition to keeping the cattle, while the appellants along with the deceased and one Ms. Sangeeta Devi (sister-in-law) used to reside in the village house. In the morning of 28.6.2009, dead body of Smt. Shashi was found lying in the state as aforementioned in the Chhan. The deceased was absenting from the house since the evening of 27.6.2009 When the father of the deceased Sharad Singh Panwar, resident of another village Vikol of the same district Tehri Garhwal, got information about the incident, he along with his relatives and other villagers rushed to the spot and found his daughter in the condition as stated above. So, they apprehended that she was murdered somewhere outside the house and then her considerably burnt body was shifted inside the Chhan in order to pose that she committed suicide. In the FIR Ex. Ka-1, which could be recorded on 28.6.2009 at 4.50 PM in the police station, Sharad Singh Panwar expressed his apprehension about the complicity of the appellants and also the sister-in-law Sangeeta Devi in this crime. Chick report is Ex. Ka-9.

3. The inquest report Ex. Ka-2 was prepared from 2.45 PM to 4 PM at the spot in the presence of several villagers, Nayab Tehsildar and some other people who were the residents of the native place of the deceased. Prima facie, the reason behind death was burning. However, to detect the clear reasons of the death, the post-mortem was recommended.

4. The autopsy of the deceased was conducted on 29.6.2009 at 1 PM in the District Hospital, Tehri Garhwal by Dr. Sanjay Kandwal. In the opinion of the doctor, the death had been caused due to haemorrhage and shock as a result of ante mortem injuries. The deceased was 22 years of age and the death had occurred 1-2 days prior to the autopsy. Thus, the estimated time, as expressed by the doctor, matches with the alleged time of incident. Following ante mortem injuries were recorded by the doctor in the post-mortem report Ex. Ka-3:

(1) Fracture in occipital bone, 3 cm × 3 cm.

(2) Fracture in left humerus lower part 1/3 (compound).

(3) Intestine out on left side of burst abdomen. Wound dimension 10 cm × 4 cm.

(4) Blackish discolouration of skin, charred, peeling, scarring, parchment like, muscle exposed.

5. Investigation culminated into submission of the chargesheet Ex. Ka-4 only against the accused appellants for the offences punishable under Section 302/201 IPC. The charges were levelled accordingly and the accused were put to trial.

6. Prosecution examined as many as 11 witnesses. Thereafter the statements of the accused persons were recorded under Section 313 CrPC. They have accepted the marriage of the deceased with Satye Singh almost four years prior to the incident, but have denied any torturous or atrocious conduct towards her on account of dowry. They have also denied the other facts as have been highlighted in the evidence. Satye Singh has said that Smt. Shashi was not available in the house since 8 PM of the date of occurrence i.e 27.6.2009 He has further disclosed that Smt. Shashi remained absent for the whole night while he along with other villagers continued to search her in that fateful night. Smt. Indra Devi has only stated that she has been roped in the crime because of being mother of Satye Singh.

7. We have heard learned Counsel for the parties and have also perused the evidence available on record as well as the impugned judgment and order.

8. PW1 Jontara Devi is the aunt of the deceased (wife of the younger brother of the informant). She has deposed that on 27th at 11 PM, while she was in home at village Vikol, a phone call of Satye Singh was received inquiring whether Shashi had reached there in village Vikol. Next day, her dead body was found. She has also deposed that whenever Shashi used to come in the village Vikol, she always used to disclose that all the appellants quarrel with her on the question of dowry.

9. PW2 Sharad Singh Panwar (father of the deceased) is the informant. He has also affirmed the atrocious conduct on the question of dowry as disclosed by his daughter from time to time at the hands of the appellants, besides sister-in-law Sangeeta Devi. He has further affirmed that the phone call was received by Jontara Devi (PW1) in the night of 27, as stated above, informing that Shashi was absenting from the house since 6 PM onwards and Satye Singh was asking whether Shashi had reached in village Vikol. They replied in negative. On the next day at about 10.11 AM, he again telephoned informing that Shashi died by setting herself on fire. On receiving this information, he along with his relatives and villagers rushed to the spot where he found the dead body of his daughter in the condition as stated hereinabove.

10. PW3 Smt. Bhagdei Devi, mother of deceased, and PW4 Bhagat Singh, another resident of village Vikol, both have corroborated the version of PW2 Sharad Singh Panwar. PW5 Bharat Singh is the brother of informant. He has also corroborated the prosecution version in the same manner as has been stated by Sharad Singh Panwar.

11. PW6 Balbeer Singh is the resident of village Gair (place of incident). He has stated that on 27.6.2009, Smt. Indra Devi (wife of the appellant) called Gambhir Singh, his nephew and asked him to accompany her. Gambhir singh went along with Smt. Indra Devi and they returned after sometime. Balbeer Singh asked Gambhir Singh as to where they had gone, to which Smt. Indra Devi pettily replied that her goat had been missing. So, she along with Gambhir Singh went in order to search the said goat. Balbeer Singh asked Smt. Indra Devi in the protesting tenor as to why she had taken along his nephew Gambhir Singh in the odd hours just to search the goat, as it was the time when one can easily fall pray to the wild animals. Then Smt. Indra Devi disclosed that, in fact, they had gone to search Smt. Shashi Devi and went up to Chhan situated in the jungle for the said purpose. However, she was not found there. Next day on 28.6.2009, the dead body of Smt. Shashi was found inside the Chhan. They (Smt. Indra Devi and Gambhir Singh) also disclosed that when they reached to Chhan in search of Smt. Shashi Devi, Atar Singh was present there. Since Smt. Shashi Devi was not found in the Chhan, so they returned to the village. This witness Balbeer Singh resides in the close vicinity of the house of Satye Singh. He has deposed that Smt. Shashi Devi sometimes used to stay in Chhan itself even in the night hours along with Atar Singh, her father-in-law. He has also stated that no other Chhan exists near the place of incident. Other Chhans are at a distance of about one kilometre. In the morning of 28 June 2009, when the appellants again took the villagers including PW6 and reached to the Chhan, then her dead body was found in the condition, as discussed above. The appellants began to weep and shout, but no clue could be noticed as to how Smt. Shashi set herself on fire. Thereafter telephonic information was sent in the parental house of Smt. Shashi.

12. PW7 is Gabar Singh, another resident of village Gair, who has deposed he had seen Atar Singh (father-in-law of the deceased) at 7.30 AM on 28.6.2009 while he coming out of his Chhan. After sometime, he noticed that smoke was emanating from the Chhan. Atar Singh was heading towards his house in the village.

13. PW8 Rai Singh is the Pradhan of the nearby village Lauldi, who, after getting the information that wife of Satye Singh remained no more, had sent the information to the Nayab Tehsildar and in the native place of the deceased. He is also the witness of Panchayatnama and has proved the same.

14. PW9 is the doctor who has conducted the autopsy and has proved the report thereof. This witness has stated that besides other ante mortem injuries, the fracture of such a dimension, as stated above, on the occipital region was clearly visible. The dead body was 100 per cent burnt. Although in the post-mortem report, burn of 100 per cent has not been mentioned, but on the basis of the nature of injury no. 4, he has stated that the body was intensely burnt. This witness has also proved that before the body was set ablaze, the woman was murdered by causing the ante mortem injuries, as stated above. More so, because her lungs were normal. This witness has further stated that since the dead body was brought for autopsy with clear name and address, so there was no need of any prior identification.

15. PW10 Gunanand Bahuguna and PW11 Virendra Raj are the successive Investigation Officers of the case, who have proved the papers on the basis of which the investigation was culminated into submission of the chargesheet.

16. After scrupulously analyzing the evidence nay pros and cons of the case, we are of the considered view that it was a gruesome murder at the hands of the appellants. The contention of the learned Counsel for the appellants that the deceased Shashi sometime went to the Chhan and set ablaze herself is wholly baseless for the reason that death has occurred not on account of setting fire on her body, rather it was because of the serious ante mortem injuries as have been indicated above and proved by the doctor concerned. Had she herself burnt to death inside the Chhan, then how the thatch ceiling of the Chhan could remain intact as the material used for laying down the ceiling of that thatch are very dried straws and wood, which are always very prone to fire. If the body was so intensely burnt, as the doctor has opined that it was 100 per cent, then how it was possible that the walls of the Chhan caught no sign of flames. It is quite impossible and difficult to believe. No kerosene or other inflammable substance or the matchbox containing the matchsticks were found near the oven inside the Chhan. It is also quite amazing that the pillow was found only partially burnt, while other articles like cot, bedding and clothes were found totally undamaged, which is not possible in case the deceased set herself on fire inside the Chhan. No explanation has been offered on behalf of the accused appellants as to how such serious injuries were found on the dead body, whereas the doctor says that such injuries cannot be caused while carrying the dead body from the said Chhan to the post-mortem table. So, certainly, these bodily injuries, though not noticed at the time of inquest, were caused while Smt. Shashi was alive and these were so fatal as the same resulted in her death.

17. On the basis of the evidence as discussed above, we are of the view that after murdering Smt. Shashi somewhere outside the Chhan and after setting the dead body on fire, the same was shifted inside the Chhan in a considerably burnt state, and it was done with intention to pretend that she actually committed suicide by setting herself ablaze inside the Chhan. Moreover, the accused persons have nowhere disclosed as to where they remained throughout the night, when they unsuccessfully posed themselves to have gone to search the whereabouts of Smt. Shashi, after their return to the house situated in village Gair. This entire play was scripted just in order to show Gambhir Singh and other villagers that uptill late evening, say about 10 to 11 PM on 27.6.2009, they searched for Smt. Shashi in the jungle and in the Chhan, but she could not be found. All these circumstances are enough to prove that Smt. Shashi was actually murdered sometime in the evening of 27.6.2009 in the jungle by causing these injuries and, after leaving her dead body there, the appellants returned to the village and collected their neighbours including Gambhir Singh just to spread the rumour that Smt. Shashi had herself left the house in the evening of that fateful day and was missing since then. However, after doing all these things, the appellants could not render any explanation as to where they remained for whole night subsequent to their return in the village at about 11 PM of the intervening night of 27/28.6.2009. It is enough to discern that they went again at the place where they had already committed the murder of Smt. Shashi and set ablaze her dead body. When the body got considerably burnt, then they shifted the same in the burnt condition to the Chhan so that they could show that Smt. Shashi committed suicide by setting herself on fire. That is why, the thatch and any other articles inside the Chhan could not catch the fire and only the cushion was exposed to little fire as the same was found partially burnt.

18. Here, it is pertinent to mention the provisions of Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, which casts duty on the accused persons to clarify as to how the dead body of Smt. Shashi reached in the Chhan when Smt. Shashi was not present there till 10-11 PM on 27.6.2009 This aspect is also important because Atar Singh (father of Satye Singh and husband of Smt. Indra Devi) was seen by PW7 at 7.30 AM on 28.6.2009 coming out of his Chhan and almost five minutes thereafter smoke emanating from the Chhan was also noticed by him. Further, the appellants have also not spoken a single word as to where they remained throughout the night after returning to their home at about 11 PM on that day.

19. So, these circumstances are enough to lead us to the conclusion that it was only the appellants, who have committed this gruesome murder and thereafter, in order to destroy the evidence, they burnt the dead body. As such, the accused appellants have rightly been convicted by the court below. Thus, we do not find any merit in the appeal, which is liable to be dismissed.

20. Consequently, we dismiss the appeal, and uphold the conviction and sentence awarded by the trial court to the accused appellants. Impugned judgment and order dated 11.10.2010, passed by the Sessions Judge, Tehri Garhwal in Sessions Trial No. 22/2009, is thus affirmed. Convict appellants are already in jail. They are to serve out their remaining sentences as awarded by the court below. Result of the appeal be communicated to the appellants in jail. Let a copy of this judgment and order, along with LCR, be sent back to the court below for its compliance.