Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sam K. Mani v. T.N. Sreedhara Kaimal

Kerala High Court
Sep 2, 2013

JUDGMENT

K. Ramakrishnan, J

The claimant in O.P(M.V). No. 1012/2003 on the file of the Additional Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kottayam is the appellant herein. The appellant filed the application for compensation for the injuries and consequential disabilities sustained by him in a motor vehicle accident, caused on account of the rash and negligent driving of the vehicle by 2nd respondent, owned by the 1st respondent insured with the 3rd respondent. After considering the evidence on record, the tribunal awarded a total compensation of 3,70,000/- on various heads as follows:

Sl. Head of claim Amount No. awarded

1. Loss of earning 20000

2 Transportation charges 2000

3 Extra nourishment 1000

4 Damage to clothing 500

5 Bystander expenses 2500

6 Medical expenses 80000

7 Pain and suffering 25000

8 Loss of amenities in life 25000

9 Compensation for continuing and permanent disability 214000

Total 370000

Dissatisfied with the quantum of compensation awarded, the appellant has come before this court with the above appeal.

2. Heard counsel for the appellant and counsel for the insurance company.

3. Counsel for the appellant would submit that the appellant was working as a receptionist in Riyadh and getting a monthly income of 25,000/- at the time of the accident. But, the tribunal has taken only 4,000/- per month as his income, which is very low. Further, the Medical Board assessed 32% disability, but the tribunal has taken only 25%, for the purpose of assessing his loss of earning capacity. Further, the amount awarded under the head pain and suffering, loss of amenities in life etc., are also very low, considering the nature of injuries sustained, period of treatment undergone and the disability suffered by him. No amount was awarded under the head for future treatment as well. So according to him, the appellant is entitled to get enhancement on all heads.

4. On the other hand, the counsel for the insurance company submitted that the tribunal has considered all the aspects and the total compensation awarded is just and proper and no interference is called for at the hands of this court.

5. We have considered the rival contentions of both parties in detail.

6. The appellant was aged only 29 years at the time of the accident, sustained the following injuries:

“Comminuted fracture, medial condye (L) Tibia, lateral subluxation (L) knee, lateral popliteal nerve palsy (L), contusion lateral aspect upper thirds (L) leg, HR USG (L) knee joint, infalmatory changes with altered echotexture noted in the knee joints, minimal fluid noted in the patella femoral and tibia femoral spaces, no significant periarticular soft tissue abnormalities, bone irregularity noted involveing the upper end of tibia, no focal soft tissue collections and Cellulitis (L) leg, arthritis (L) knee.”

He was treated as inpatient from 12.02.2007 to 06.12.2007 and even thereafter, he continued his treatment for long time as seen from the medical records. So the appellant could not have worked for nearly one year and he is entitled to get loss of earning for 12 months as compensation under the head loss of earning. But, the tribunal has taken only 5 months for assessing compensation under the head loss of earning, which appears to be erroneous.

7. Though, the appellant deposed that he was working as a receptionist in King Faizal Foundation, Riyadh and getting a monthly income to 25,000/- per month at the time of the accident, no acceptable evidence was adduced to prove this aspect, except producing his passport, which will go to show to that, he had gone abroad several times, that alone is not sufficient to prove his monthly income. Further, employment in abroad is not a permanent one and it may have contingencies as well. So, the income which he was getting on account of his temporary employment in Riyadh cannot be taken as such for the purpose of assessing his monthly income, for the purpose of awarding compensation. So, during the year 2002, the monthly income of 4,000/- notionally fixed by the tribunal cannot be said to be on the lower side, in the absence of any convincing evidence adduced on the side of the petitioner to prove his income. So, we do not find any reason to interfere with the monthly income fixed by the tribunal.

8. Taking the period of treatment and inability to do his work as 12 months, the appellant will be entitled to get an amount of 48,000/- (4,000 × 12) instead of 20,000/- awarded by the tribunal. The Medical Board assessed 32% disability. The tribunal has adopted only 25%, only on the ground that, the doctors who issued the disability certificate have not been examined. The disability certificate was issued by the Medical Board. There is nothing to disbelieve the same and it was as per the reference made by the tribunal, that the Medical Board had assessed the disability. But, there is nothing to disbelieve the percentage of disability assessed by the Medical Board and the reasons stated by the tribunal for taking a lessor disability, for assessing loss of earning capacity is unsustainable in law. So, we take the entire 32% assessed by the Medical Board, for assessing his loss of earning capacity, as a person having 32% disability will have some impact on his earning capacity as well. So, the appellant will be entitled to get 2,61,120/- (4,000 × 12 × 17 × 32%) instead of 2,14,000/- awarded by the tribunal under the head loss of earning capacity and we award that amount under that head.

9. It is seen from para 11 of the judgment itself that, the petitioner has undergone inpatient treatment for longer period and he underwent 8 operations and the injuries sustained by him were also grevious in nature. Further the discussion will go to show that, the doctors told him that his left leg will have to be amputed, on account of the nature of injuries sustained by him, but the treatment given, that was avoided. So, all these things will go to show that, he would have undergone much pain and suffering during the period of his treatment. So, the amount awarded under the head pain and suffering namely, 25,000/- appears to be on the lower side and we enhance the same to 40,000/-. Similarly, a person with 32% permanent disability will have some discomfort in his personal life as well. He will have to live with these difficulties for the remaining period of his life as well. So, considering the percentage of disability sustained by him and it impact on his personal life, we feel that the amount of 25,000/- awarded by the tribunal under the head loss of amenities in life is also on the lower side and we enhance the same to 60,000/-. We are not inclined to enhance any amount under other heads, as the amount awarded appears to be just and proper. No acceptable evidence was adduced on the side of the appellant proved that he required future treatment. So, the claim laid by the counsel for the appellant for future treatment cannot be granted. In all, the appellant will be entitled to get an additional compensation of 1,15,120/-, which we rounded to 1,15,500/-, over and above what has been awarded by the tribunal, which the 3 espondent insurance company r is liable to pay with 9% interest, from the date of the claim petition, till date of payment. Three months time is granted to the insurance company to deposit this amount as well.

With the above modification of the impugned award of the tribunal, the appeal is disposed of.