Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Chief District Health Officer v. Rajesh Baldevbhai Gosai

Gujarat High Court
Oct 22, 2013

ORAL ORDER

1. Challenge in this petition is made to the award of the Labour Court Vadodara dated 20.11.2012 in Reference (LCV) No. 661 of 2005, whereby the respondent workman is ordered to be reinstated in service, with continuity of service and with 50% back wages.

2. Mr. Munshaw learned Advocate for the petitioner-Employer has stated that the appointment of the respondent workman was made as a Peon on temporary, part time basis, in the year 1994, with further stipulation that in the event of availability of regular appointee, the appointment shall come to an end. It is also stated that pursuant to the order of the Government, on 07.05.2005, one person was appointed as a Peon on compassionate ground, and was posted at the place where the present respondent was working, and as the consequence thereof, the service of the present respondent came to be discontinued. Attention of this Court is also invited to the appointment order dated 07.05.2005, Annexure-C. It is therefore, contended that, the case would be governed by the provision of Section 2(oo)(bb) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, and the question of following the procedure under Section 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act, did not arise, and according to petitioner no illegality was committed which warranted any interference by the Labour Court. It is therefore contended that the impugned award of the Labour Court be quashed and set aside.

3. On the other hand learned Advocate for the respondent Mr. Iyer, has contended that even the appointment of the new workman vide order dated 07.05.2005 also stipulated one condition (condition No. 6) that the said appointment was on adhoc basis, at the monthly remuneration of Rs. 1500/- and was liable to be terminated without any notice. It is contended that the respondent workman was in service since 1994. It is stated that thus, after the continuous service of more than 11 years with the District Panchayat, to say that somebody is posted there, therefore his service are to be discontinued, is no less than illegal termination, and the Labour Court has come to the right conclusion. It is also contended that in the facts of this case, no interference be made even qua the back wages.

4. Having heard learned Advocates for the respective parties and having gone through the material on record this Court finds that, it is not in dispute that the respondent workman was in service for about 11 years. It is also to be noted that he was appointment as a Peon at the Primary Health Centre, of the petitioner District Panchyat at village-Goraj, Taluka Vaghodiya. It is difficult to accept the contention that a Primary Health Centre was attended by a Peon for 11 years, but he was a part timer, however that is not the subject matter of this petition, but this fact has some bearing therefore, the same is recorded. Further the Labour Court has recorded cogent reasons to come to the conclusion about the discontinuance of service of the respondent workman being illegal. This Court does not find any infirmity in it and the same does not call for interference. So far the contention of the learned Advocate for the petitioner Authority about the applicability of the provisions of Section 2(oo)(bb) of the Industrial Disputes Act, is concerned, this Court finds that, in the facts of this case, the workman who had worked for about 11 years, is told that since somebody is being appointed, whose service can also be terminated without any notice, as stipulated in his appointment order as well, still the service of the present respondent is liable to be terminated, cannot be accepted as legal termination, and this contention needs to be rejected and Labour Court has rightly rejected it. In view of this Court, the said reasoning does not call for any interference. This petition therefore, needs to be rejected.

5. Coming to the question of awarding back wages, this Court finds that in the facts of this case it would be too harsh to deny back wages to the respondent workman. Keeping in view, the view expressed by Hon'ble the Supreme Court of India in the case of Deepali Gundu Surwase v. Kranti Junior Adhyapak Mahavidyalaya, reported in 2013 (11) SCALE 268, this Court finds that, full back wages could have been awarded to the respondent workman, however in the petition of the employer, it would not be proper to enhance the back wages which is granted to the extent of 50% by the Labour Court, but the same need not be interfered with. Thus the impugned award does not call for any interference either in the reinstatement part or in the back wages part and the petition needs to be rejected.

6. For the reasons recorded above, this petition is rejected. Petitioner Authority is directed to give effect to the impugned award of the Labour Court within a period of two months from today. The respondent workman is entitled to wages from date of award till actual date of reinstatement. The arrears of the back wages, as well as wages from the date of award to the date of actual reinstatement in service, is directed to be paid within a period of three months from today. Notice is discharged. No order as to costs.