- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dr. P. Sreekumar, Sa... v. Mohan Prasad, Atulya...
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners in Crl.M.C No. 1732/04 and 2641/07 are accused in multiple criminal cases pending before different magistrate courts in Ernakulam. The disputes arise from allegations of misappropriation of funds and forgery involving the trustees of the Vidyodaya Trust, a registered public trust. The litigation began around 1999 when internal conflicts among trustees surfaced. The first accused, who was Treasurer, allegedly misappropriated approximately 40 lakhs by forging signatures. The Executive Trustee (also a petitioner) was initially implicated but later cleared by police investigation. Subsequently, separate complaints and criminal cases were filed against the petitioners, leading to overlapping trials based on similar facts. The petitioners sought quashing of complaints and proceedings invoking the inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure to avoid multiplicity of trials and alleged abuse of process.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the complaint and subsequent proceedings pending as C.C No. 2682/2002 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court II, Ernakulam, can be quashed under Section 482 Cr.P.C. on grounds of multiplicity of trials and abuse of process.
- Whether the inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C. should be exercised to prevent trial of two cases arising from the same set of facts and involving the same parties, thereby violating fundamental rights.
- Whether the prima facie case exists against the accused in C.C No. 28/2004 to justify continuation of trial and refusal to quash the complaint.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioner in Crl.M.C 2641/07 contended that two criminal cases are pending against him alleging the same facts and offences, leading to multiple trials which violate his fundamental rights.
- He argued that the complaint and proceedings in C.C No. 2682/2002 are a mere abuse of the process of court, given that a similar case (C.C No. 28/2004) is already pending.
- The petitioner asserted that the second accused in C.C 28/2004 improperly filed another complaint against the first accused alone, which should not be allowed to proceed simultaneously.
- He prayed for quashing of the FIR, charge sheet, and all consequent proceedings in C.C No. 2682/2002 by invoking the inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C.
Respondent's Arguments
- This information was not available in the provided opinion.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| State of Haryana v. Bhajanlal (1992 SCC (Cri) 426) | Enumerated grounds for quashing criminal proceedings under Section 482 Cr.P.C., including absence of prima facie offence, abuse of process, mala fide prosecution, and multiplicity of trials. | The court applied these principles to determine whether the complaint in C.C No. 2682/2002 constituted an abuse of process and whether quashing was justified. |
| Madhu Limaye v. State Of Maharashtra ((1977) 4 SCC 551) | Supported the exercise of inherent jurisdiction to prevent abuse of process and multiplicity of proceedings. | Reinforced the court's approach in evaluating the propriety of continuing parallel criminal trials. |
| R.P Kapoor v. State of Punjab (1960 SC 860) | Affirmed the principles regarding the quashing of criminal proceedings on grounds of abuse of process and multiplicity. | Used to substantiate the court's exercise of inherent jurisdiction in the present case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the petitions under the inherent jurisdiction conferred by Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which allows quashing of proceedings to prevent abuse of process or to secure ends of justice. It examined the allegations and evidence to determine the existence of a prima facie case against the accused in C.C No. 28/2004 and found that such a case did exist, thereby making quashing inappropriate at this stage for that complaint.
Regarding the complaint and proceedings in C.C No. 2682/2002, the court noted that the second accused in C.C 28/2004 had filed a separate complaint against the first accused alone based on the same facts. The court found this to be a clear instance of multiplicity of trials and an abuse of the court's process. It relied on the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in State of Haryana v. Bhajanlal and other precedents, which allow quashing where multiple proceedings arise from the same facts and cause unnecessary harassment to the accused.
Accordingly, the court concluded that continuing the trial based on the final report in Crime No. 5/2002 would amount to abuse of process and therefore quashed the proceedings in C.C No. 2682/2002.
For the complaint in C.C No. 28/2004, the court observed that since the complaint was pending for a long time without bail being taken, the accused should surrender and apply for bail, which the trial court shall consider according to law.
Holding and Implications
The court made the following rulings:
- Crl.M.C No. 1732/2004 (complaint in C.C No. 28/2004): The petition to quash the complaint is dismissed. The accused are directed to surrender and seek bail from the trial court.
- Crl.M.C No. 2641/2007 (proceedings in C.C No. 2682/2002): The petition is allowed and all proceedings arising from the complaint and charge sheet in Crime No. 5/2002 pending before JFCM-II, Ernakulam are quashed.
The direct effect of this decision is the termination of one of the parallel trials to prevent multiplicity and abuse of process, thereby protecting the accused from facing multiple prosecutions based on the same facts. The court did not set any new precedent but applied established principles from Supreme Court decisions.
ORDER
Petitioners in Crl.M.C No. 1732/04 and 2641/07 are first and second accused in C.C 28 of 2004 on the file of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ernakulam. The petitioner in Crl.M.C 2641 of 2007 is the sole accused in Crime No. 5/2002 of Ernakulam Town North Police Station which is pending as C.C No. 2682/02 on the file of Judicial First Class Magistrate Court II, Ernakulam and the first accused in Crime No. 817/2001 of Central Police Station, Ernakulam which is pending as C.C No. 28/2004 on the file of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ernakulam.
2. The second accused in C.C 28/04 has filed this petition to quash Annexure A6 complaint pending before the Chief Judicial Magistrate's Court, Ernakulam by invoking Section 482 of Code of Criminal Procedure. The above complaint was filed by one Mohan Prasad, who is the first respondent in this petition alleging offences punishable under Sections 408, 409, 420, 467, 468, 476 and 477 A read with Section 34 of Indian Penal Code. The petitioner and first respondent are the trustees of a public Trust by name Vidyodaya Trust having its office at S.N Junction Palarivattom. The Trust came into existence on 23.4.1990 and registered as No. 300/90 of the SRO, Ernakulam.
3. According to the petitioner, four out of 12 trustees got enimical towards the Trust in the year 1999 and thus the litigation started. First accused in C.C 28/2004 (petitioner in Crl.M.C No. 2641 of 2007) was the Treasurer and one of the Trustees and from 2000 onwards he was in possession and control of the finance. He misappropriated about 40 lakhs by forging the signature of the Executive Trustee, i.e, the petitioner herein. The petitioner came to know about this illegal act only on 6.7.2001 when Mr. Arun Varma confessed the guilt before him. The Governing Council resolved to take criminal action against the Treasurer and authorised the Executive Trustee to initiate criminal proceedings. Even though the complainant was a signatory to the resolution and other proceedings, he filed a criminal complaint against the Treasurer as first accused and the Executive Trustee as the second accused. The police made investigation and referred the case against the Executive Trustee realising that the petitioner has no complicity with the crime. Subsequently the petitioner was falsely implicated in C.C 28/2004 by filing separate private complaint due to vengeance against him. The petitioner also filed a complaint which led to C.C No. 2682/2002 pending before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court - II, Ernakulam. The Chief Judicial Magistrate took cognizance of the offence against the petitioner and another person and proceeded with trial. In the said circumstance the petitioner approached this Court to quash Annexure A6 complaint against him.
4. This petition is filed under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure to quash Annexure III final report in Crime No. 5/2002 of Ernakulam Town North Police Station which is pending as CC No. 2682/2002 on the file of JFCM-II, Ernakulam. The above case was registered on the basis of a complaint filed by one Dr. Sreekumar (who is the petitioner in Crl.M.C No. 1732 of 2004.second accused in CC 28 of 2004) before the Chief Judicial Magistrate Court-II, Ernakulam, which was forwarded to Ernakulam Town North Police Station for investigation under Section 156(3) Code of Criminal Procedure. After completing the investigation, Annexure III final report was filed before the JFCM-II, Ernakulam. The petitioner contended that two cases are pending against him in two Courts alleging the same set of facts and same offence. The de-facto complainant in Crime No. 5/2002 is also an accused in C.C No. 28/2004. Hence if trial is proceeded in these two cases, he has to face two trial for the same offence which is in violation of fundamental rights. So, he prays for invoking the inherent jurisdiction to quash Annexure II FIR, Annexure III charge sheet and all its consequent proceedings pending as C.C No. 2682/2002 on the file of JFCM II, Ernakulam.
5. According to Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the inherent jurisdiction can be invoked to prevent abuse of process of Court or to give effect to any order or to secure ends of justice. While exercising such jurisdiction, this Court can inquire whether evidence in question is reliable or sufficient for a conviction or not. In this background, I have considered the averments in Crl.M.C 1732 of 2004 and Crl.M.C 2641 of 2007. Crl.M.C 1732 of 2004 was preferred against C.C 28/2004 of the CJM Court Ernakulam in which one Mohan Prasad filed the case against five persons. After perusing the records and averments in the complaint, the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate took cognizance against two persons alone. Before that the case was sent for investigation under Section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C Police filed Annexure IV final report in the form of refer report which led to file C.C No. 28/2004 on the file of CJM Court Ernakulam.
6. It is found that the second accused in C.C 28/2004 of the CJM Court, Ernakulam filed a complaint in the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court II, Ernakulam which was forwarded to Town North Police Station for investigation. Without considering the case pending before the Central Police Station, Ernakulam, the Town North Police filed Annexure III final report. In CC 28/2004 the defacto complainant's case is that the first and second accused in the above case misappropriated the funds of the Vidyodaya Trust which come nearly 42 lakhs and appropriated that amount for their own use. That being the position, for the same set of facts the second accused in C.C 28/2004 could not file another case against the first accused alone. Therefore, the trial of the case based upon the final report in Crime No. 5/2002 is a mere abuse of process of Court. If that be so, it is suitable to quash the proceedings by invoking the inherent jurisdiction. Apex Court in State of Haryana v. Bhajanlal (1992 SCC (Cri) 426) held as follows:
“(1) Where the allegations in the FIR/complaint, even if they are taken at their face value do not prima facie constitute any offence against the accused. (2)
Where the allegations in the FIR of other materials do not constitute a cognizable offence justifying an investigation by the police under Section 156(1) of the code except under an order of a Magistrate within the purview of Section 155(2). (3) Where the uncontroverted allegations in the FIR/complaint and the evidence collected thereon do not disclose the commission of any offence. (4) Where the allegations in the FIR/complaint do not constitute any cognizable offence but constitute only non-cognizable offence to which no investigation is permitted by the police without the order of Magistrate under Section 155(2).
(5) Where the allegations are so absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of which no prudent person can ever reach a just conclusion that there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused. (6) Where there is an express legal bar engrafted in any of the provisions of the Code or the Statute concerned (under which the proceeding is instituted) to the institution and continuance of the proceedings and/or where there is a specific provision in the code or in the statute concerned, providing efficacious redress for the grievance of the aggrieved party. (7) Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly attended with mala fide and/or where the proceeding is maliciously instituted with an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance on the accuse with a view to spite him due to private and personal vengeance.”
So also the decisions in Madhu Limaye v. State Of Maharashtra. ((1977) 4 SCC 551 and R.P Kapoor v. State of Punjab (1960 SC 860), the same view was taken by the Apex Court.
7. Accepting the principles laid down by the Apex Court in the aforesaid decisions, it is found that prima facie case is made out against the first and second accused in C.C No. 28/2004. Therefore it is difficult to quash Annexure A6 complaint in Crl.M.C No. 1732 of 2004 at this stage. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner in Crl.M.C 1732 of 2004 submits that since Annexure A6 complaint is pending before the trial court for a quite long time and bail was not taken, it is for the accused in the above case to surrender before that Court and apply for bail. If any such application is filed before the learned Magistrate, the learned Magistrate shall consider that application and dispose of the same in accordance with law. In the said circumstance Crl.M.C No. 1732/2004 is dismissed.
But in Crl.M.C No. 2641 of 2007 petitioner is the sole accused in Annexure II FIR, Annexure III charge sheet and all its consequent proceedings pending as C.C No. 2682 of 2002 on the file of the JFCM-II, Ernakulam, is hereby quashed and the said petition is allowed.
Alert