Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Apeejay Shipping Ltd. v. Cochin Shipyard Ltd.

Kerala High Court
Aug 11, 2014

JUDGMENT

I concur with the court below to the effect that there is no necessity to examine the umpire. More than five years have elapsed since the award was passed. The complaint of the petitioner is that the umpire did not afford sufficient opportunity. The court below has in this context observed as follows in Ext.P3 order.

“However, it is to be noted that the umpire has passed the award with the evidence available on record. The evidence produced by the petitioner and accepted by the umpire, produced by the petitioner and not accepted by the umpire and the evidence sought to be produced by the petitioner are available in the proceedings. Even if the umpire is examined he may not be remembering what transpired during the time of evidence and why the questions put to the witness are not recorded or rejected.”

2. The petitioner is free to produce other available evidence to substantiate its claim.

3. I however permit the petitioner to examine its employee as the second witness in the proceedings. His evidence shall however be appreciated bearing in mind the scope of Section 30 of the Arbitration Act, 1940. The proceedings are only to set aside the award and there cannot be a re-appraisal of evidence as if in an appeal. Ext.P3 order is modified to the limited extent of enabling the petitioner to examine its employee as a second witness. Ext.P3 order in I.A No. 5625 of 2011 in O.P (Arb) No. 30 of 2009 is affirmed in other aspects. The petitioner is also free to summon the entire records including the interim orders passed in the course of the arbitral proceedings.

Original Petition is disposed of.