Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sunilbhai Sudhirbhai Kothari v. State Of Gujarat

Gujarat High Court
Dec 2, 2014

A.J Desai, J.:— By way of the present application under Section 439(1)(b) read with Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (hereinafter referred to as “the Code”), the applicant has challenged the imposition of two conditions with regard to power of remand of the Investigating Agency, while entertaining the application submitted by him under the provisions of Section 438 of the Code, for releasing him on bail in case of his arrest in connection with an offence registered against him.

2. Brief facts, arise from the record of the case, are as under:

2.1 That an FIR came to be lodged with Rander Police Station of District Surat by one Afzal Fazal Dalal against some unknown persons, alleging that his brother was attacked by these unknown persons by opening fire on him, pursuant to which, he has sustained injuries and has been admitted in the Hospital. The said offence came to be registered on 28/03/2014 against unknown persons for the offence punishable u/s.307 of the Indian Penal Code; under Section 25(1)(A) and 27 of the Arms Act and u/s.135 (1) of the Gujarat Police Act.

2.2 In connection with this FIR, a summon came to be issued to the applicant, u/s.160 of the Code by the Investigating Agency and was asked to remain present before the Police. The applicant apprehended his arrest and, therefore, he submitted an application u/s.438 of the Code before the learned Sessions Judge and prayed that he may be released on bail in case of his arrest in connection with the said offence.

2.3 the learned Sessions Judge, Surat after hearing learned Public Prosecutor, allowed the application being Criminal Misc. Application No. 1193 of 2014 on 21/06/2014 and passed appropriate order. It was ordered that in case of arrest of the applicant, he may be released on producing surety of Rs. 25,000/- as well as personal bond of Rs. 25,000/- and on other terms and conditions. By passing the aforesaid order, condition Nos. (2) and (3) were imposed empowering the Investigating Agency to have right u/s.167 of the Code, for police remand and further by putting additional condition, it was ordered that in case the police remand is granted by the competent court, at the end of such remand period, the applicant may be immediately released.

2.4 One of the conditions was, directing the applicant to remain present before the concerned Police Station within a period of seven days and accordingly, the applicant remained present before the concerned Police Station.

2.5 It is the case of the applicant that the applicant remained present before the Investigating Agency on several occasions as per the instructions given by the Investigating Agency. Ultimately, the applicant came to be arrested by the Investigating Officer on 3/11/2014 and was released on bail as per the order passed by the learned Sessions Judge.

2.6 In the meantime, the applicant preferred a Writ Petition (Criminal) No. 182 of 2014 before the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, challenging the conditions imposed by the learned Sessions Judge with regard to powers of the Investigating Agency u/s.167 of the Code with regard to police remand. On 31/10/2014, the said writ petition came to be entertained and following order was passed:

“Let the writ petition be listed on 24th November, 2014.

Liberty is granted to the petitioner to file an application under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure before the High Court within a week hence, along with an application for interim relief. The High Court is requested to dispose of the same within two weeks therefrom. The order passed in 482 shall be brought on record in this writ petition.”

2.8 Since the petitioner was granted liberty to file the application u/s.482 of the Code with regard to the same issue, the present application was filed before this Court. Aforesaid petition is pending before the Apex Court.

2.9 After hearing learned advocate for the petitioner as well as learned Additional Public Prosecutor, the Co-Ordinate Bench of this Court (Coram: Hon'ble Mr. Justice S.G Shah) passed an order on 7/11/2014, staying the implementation and operation of condition Nos. (2) and (3) passed by the learned Sessions Judge.

“Heard learned senior counsel Mr. Yatin Oza with learned advocate Mr. P.P Majmudar for the applicant and learned APP Ms. Maithili Mehta for the respondent State.

Rule returnable on 17.11.2014. Learned APP waives service of notice of rule on behalf of respondent State.

Perused the record. As an interim measure, condition Nos. 2 and 3 of impugned order are stayed till next date on condition that petitioner shall remain present before Investigating Officer between 11:00 a.m to 5:00 p.m, as and when call upon. For the purpose, whenever petitioners presence is necessary Investigating Officer shall convey the date and time to the petitioner before 24 hrs. Direct Service TODAY is permitted.”

In the background of aforesaid events, the matter was heard.

3.1 Mr. Y.N Oza, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. P.P Majmudar, learned advocate appearing for the applicant would submit that as per the decision rendered in the case of Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra reported in (2011) 1 SCC 694, Hon'ble Apex Court after considering the several judgements delivered by the Hon'ble Apex Court including the case of Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia v. State of Punjab reported in (1980) 2 SCC 565, has held that there is no difference between the application submitted by the accused either u/s.439 and 438 of the Code, by which, learned Sessions Court or High Court can release a person on bail. He would submit that while exercising power u/s.439 of the Code, the Sessions Court or High Court releases an accused on bail after his arrest on such conditions, which are found to be proper.

3.2 It was further argued that the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Siddharam (supra) after considering the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court itself in the case of Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia (supra), held that if an order u/s.438 is passed, the same should not affect the right of the police to further investigate the case.

3.3 He would submit that when the petitioner is released on bail, he can be asked to join Investigating Agency and cannot be sent behind the bar by requesting a competent court to exercise power u/s.167 of the Code. He would further submit that under sub-section 2(i) of Section 438 of the Code, empowers the High Court or Court of Sessions to impose conditions that the accused shall make himself available for interrogation, as and when required by the Investigating Officer, however, that does not mean that though the applicant is released on bail either pursuant to order u/s.439 or 438 of the Code, can be sent again to the police custody.

3.4 Mr. Y.N Oza, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the applicant would submit that while considering the case of Siddharam Mhetre (supra), the Hon'ble Apex Court had directed the accused to join the investigation and fully co-operate with the Investigating Agency, however, condition of police remand was not imposed.

4.1 On the other hand, Mr. P.K Jani, learned Additional Advocate General with Mr. R.C Kodekar, learned APP, has opposed this application and submitted that in case of an accused, released pursuant to an order passed u/d.438 of the Code, the power of the Investigating Agency to interrogate in police custody would not be redundant since the Investigating Agency had no occasion to get information with regard to crime while he is in the custody of the police. He would further submit that when the Investigating Agency submits an application u/s.167 of the Code before the Competent Court, said Court has to hear the accused and if the Investigating Agency fails in establishing their case that custodial interrogation of the applicant-accused is necessary, the Magistrate has all power to reject such application submitted by the Investigating Agency.

4.2 He would further submit that when a person is arrested and detained in custody, Investigating Agency gets minimum 24 hours for interrogation and if it is found that the interrogation could not be completed within 24 hours, Investigating Agency has to produce the arrested and detained person before competent court and thereafter only, the competent court shall decide the case of the prosecution as to Whether any further police custody i.e police remand is necessary or not?

4.3 He would further submits that when an accused is released pursuant to order u/s.438 of the Code, Investigating Agency has no occasion to interrogate the accused even for 24 hours and, therefore, the conditions with regard to power u/s.167 of the Code, are not contrary to the provisions of the Code as well as against the pronouncement of the Hon'ble Apex Court.

4.4 He would submit that in case of Siddharam Mhetre (Supra), the Hon'ble Apex Court has only clarified that the period of anticipatory bail cannot be for a limited period and there is no need to file an application u/s.439 of the Code for releasing him on regular bail and, therefore, the case put forward by the applicant to delete such condition, is without any basis. He would submit that after considering all the judgements including judgement delivered in the case of Siddharam Mhetre (supra), the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Rakesh Prahladram Joshi v. State of Gujarat reported in 2011 (2) GLH 256 has imposed similar conditions, which are challenged in the present petition. He would submit that similar conditions were raised by the one Jashuben w/o. Bhemaji Sendhaji Thakore by way of filing Criminal Misc. Application No. 1842 of 2001 before this Court and the said application came to be allowed by Co-Ordinate Bench of this Court (Hon'ble Mr. Justice Akil Kureshi) vide order dated 14/02/2011, however, it was held that such conditions are necessary since the petitioners are ordered to be released immediately in the event of his arrest and, therefore, custodial interrogation would be necessary. It has been held that if the remand is granted, the applicant would be treated as if in custody but under the protective umbrella of the Court and under an order of anticipatory bail.

4.5 He would submit that it has been further held that since the applicant - accused, who has been enlarged on anticipatory bail has to be immediately released on his arrest and he is to be treated as if he is on bail and, therefore, prosecution has to file an application seeking cancellation of such bail and thereafter only, the order with regard to remand can be passed. He, therefore, would submit that the application may be rejected.

5.1 I have heard learned advocates appearing on behalf of the respective parties. To appreciate rival contentions raised by either side, provision of Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, is required to be appreciated, which reads as under:

438. Direction for grant of bail to person apprehending arrest. - (1) When any person has reason to believe that he may be arrested on an accusation of having committed a non-bailable offence, he may apply to the High Court or the Court of Session for a direction under this section that in the event of such arrest he shall be released on bail; and that Court may after taking into consideration, inter alia, the following factors, namely-

(i) the nature and gravity of the accusation; (ii) the antecedents of the applicant including the fact as to whether he has previously undergone imprisonment on conviction by a Court in respect of any cognizable offence;

(iii) the possibility of the applicant to flee from justice; and

(iv) where the accusation has been made with the object of injuring or humiliating the applicant by having him so arrested, either reject the application forthwith or issue an interim order for the grant of anticipatory bail:

Provided that where the High Court or, as the case may be, the Court of Session, has not passed any interim order under this sub-section or has rejected the application for grant of anticipatory bail, it shall be open to an officer in-charge of a police station to arrest, without warrant the applicant on the basis of the accusation apprehended in such application.

(1A) Where the Court grants an interim order under sub-section (1), it shall forthwith cause a notice being not less than seven days notice, together with a copy of such order to be served on the Public Prosecutor and the Superintendent of Police, with a view to give the Public Prosecutor a reasonable opportunity of being heard when the application shall be finally heard by the Court.

(1B) The presence of the applicant seeking anticipatory bail shall be obligatory at the time of final hearing of the application and passing of final order by the Court, if on an application made to it by the Public Prosecutor, the Court considers such presence necessary in the interest of justice.]

(2) When the High Court or the Court of Session makes a direction under sub-section (1), it may include such conditions in such directions in the light of the facts of the particular case, as it may think fit, including-

(i) a condition that the person shall make himself available for interrogation by a police officer as and when required;

(ii) a condition that the person shall not, directly or indirectly make any inducement, threat or promise to any person acquainted with the facts of the case so as to dissuade him from disclosing such facts to the Court or to any police officer;

(iii) a condition that the person shall not leave India without the previous permission of the Court;

(iv) such other condition as may be imposed under sub-section (3) of section 437, as if the bail were granted under that section.

(3) If such person is thereafter arrested without warrant by an officer in charge of a police station on such accusation, and is prepared either at the time of arrest or at any time while in the custody of such officer to give bail, he shall be released on bail; and if a Magistrate taking cognizance of such offence decides that a warrant should issue in the first instance against that person, he shall issue a bailable warrant in conformity with the direction of the Court under sub-section (1).

5.2 In case of Siddharam Mhetre (Supra), the Hon'ble Apex Court under various heads has considered different subjects with regard to the section 438 of the Code. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has considered historical perspective with regard to introduction of provisions of section 438 of the Code; scope and ambit of Section 438; pronouncements of the Hon'ble Apex Court on the said subject; right to life and personal liberty under the Constitution of India as well as in the different countries; powers u/s.438 and 437 are compared, the limited period of anticipatory bail which had been imposed by several courts in the country; scope and ambit of anticipatory bail; exercise of powers while releasing the person on bail in case of his arrest, etc. It is true that Hon'ble Apex Court has held that the period of anticipatory bail should not be a limited one, but should ordinarily be till the end of the trial and there is no need to file application u/s.439 of Code for regular bail. The scope and ambit of anticipatory bail, the Hon'ble Apex Court in the judgement delivered in the case of Sidhharam (Supra) especially in para 109, reads as under:

“109. A good deal of misunderstanding with regard to the ambit and scope of Section 438 CrPC could have been avoided in case the Constitution Bench decision of this Court in Sibbia case was correctly understood, appreciated and applied. This Court in Sibbia case laid down the following principles with regard to anticipatory bail:

(a) Section 438(1) is to be interpreted in the light of Article 21 of the Constitution of India.

(b) Filing of FIR is not a condition precedent to exercise of power under Section 438.

(c) Order under Section 438 would not affect the right of police to conduct investigation.

(d) Condition mentioned in Section 437 cannot be read into Section 438.

(e) Although the power to release on anticipatory bail can be described as of an “extraordinary” character this would “not justify the conclusion that the power must be exercised in exceptional cases only” Powers are discretionary to be exercised in the light of the circumstances of each case.

(f) Initial order can be passed without notice to the Public Prosecutor. Thereafter, notice must be issued forthwith and question ought to be reexamined after hearing. Such ad interim order must conform to requirements of the section and suitable conditions should be imposed on the applicant.”

5.3 In the case of Mithabhai Pashabhai Patel v. State of Gujarat reported in AIR 2009 SC (Suppl.) 1658, the Hon'ble Apex Court has held that while dealing with the case with regard to further investigation u/s.173(8) of the Code, held that if the accused has been granted bail he has not in the custody of the Court and, therefore, he cannot be taken into custody ordinarily unless his bail is cancelled and, therefore, opinion of the High Court that Investigating Agency has ample power u/s.(2) of 167 for grant of police remand, is not correct. Hon'ble Apex Court has held the same in Paragraph 23 of the aforesaid case, which reads as under:

“23 Appellants had been granted bail. They are not in custody of the court. They could not be taken in custody ordinarily unless their bail was not cancelled. The High Court in our opinion, was not correct in holding that as further investigation was required, sub-section (2) of section 167 of the Code gives ample power for grant of police remand.”

5.4 If we read the provisions of Section 438(2)(i) of the Code, the Court can impose condition to interrogate an accused, who has been enlarged on bail but the question is Whether u/s.167(2) of the Code, can the accused be sent in police custody even if he has been released on bail pursuant to order u/s.438 of the Code?

5.5 Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of State of Punjab v. Raninder Singh reported in AIR 2008 SC 609, dealt with 438(2)(i) of the Code and has held especially in para-5, as under:

“5. It may be mentioned here that Section 438(2)(i) of the Code of Criminal Procedure is very clear that while granting anticipatory bail the Court can lay down a condition that the accused shall make himself available for interrogation by a police officer as and when required. The purpose of such a provision is that anticipatory bail cannot be permitted to be abused. It is therefore, implicit that whenever the Court imposes such a condition in its order, and the accused called for interrogation or for certain investigation does not appear before the investigating officer then it will be open for the State to move the High Court for cancellation of bail.”

5.6 It is pertinent to note that in the case of Rakesh Prahladram Joshi (supra), the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court has not dealt with the power of the Investigating Officer u/s.167 of the Code when an accused in enlarged on anticipatory bail.

5.7 In case the case of Jashuben w/o. Bhemaji Sendhaji Thakore (supra), the co-ordinate bench of this Court (Coram: Hon'ble Mr. Justice Akil Kureshi) while dealing with the submissions about imposing such conditions, has quoted some paragraphs of the judgement delivered in the case of Siddharam Mhetre (supra), however, conclusion are in Para 3.3, which reads as under:

3.3 In the said decision of the Apex Court, above-mentioned two conditions are rendered invalid. With respect to life of the anticipatory bail order, which is for a limited period of 90 days, deletion of such conditions would pose no difficulty However, with respect to the requirement to apply for regular bail within 10 days of arrest and released under an order of anticipatory bail, while deleting such a condition, modification is required to keep the right of the prosecution to seek remand intact. Such a procedure, previously followed, was to enable the prosecution to seek custodial interrogation, before the competent Magistrate. Uptil now, under the order of anticipatory bail, an accused would be, immediately, upon his arrest, released on bail. For the purpose of seeking remand, during such a period, he would be treated as if in custody, but under the protective umbrella of the Court, under an order of anticipatory bail. Right of the prosecution to seek remand of an accused, who has been granted anticipatory bail, deletion of the said condition, without any substitution would create serious complication. In a given case, when the prosecution is desirous of seeking police remand, question would arise whether the anticipatory bail order should be granted and if it is required to be granted on merits, what would be the position of the remand application, which the prosecution may file, later on. Obviously, if an order of anticipatory bail is granted, the accused immediately upon his arrest shall have to be released on bail. As long as he remains on bail, the prosecution cannot seek his remand. The prosecution, therefore, shall have to seek cancellation of the bail, before it can apply for remand. This situation would create two complications. Firstly, parameters for cancellation of bail are entirely different from those, for granting or refusing bail. Secondly, any such application by the police seeking cancellation of bail, may consume considerable time during which period the evidence may be destroyed or lost.”

5.8 It appears from the above referred Para 3.3 of the order delivered by the co-ordinate bench, that if an accused is released, pursuant to order u/s.439 of the Code, he remains on bail and, therefore, prosecution cannot seeks his remand. However, if the investigating agency intends for custodial interrogation, it has to apply for cancellation of bail. There would be complication and, therefore, cancellation of bail may consumer considerable time, during which period, evidence may be destroyed or lost.

5.9 Having considered the above-referred judgements of the Hon'ble Apex Court, when the Hon'ble Apex Court has held that when a person is released either on regular bail or on anticipatory bail, does not make any difference Whether the police would have right to ask for police custody u/s.167 or not?

5.10 As per the judgement delivered in the case of Mithabhai Pashabhai Patel (supra) in the year 2009, the Hon'ble Apex Court has held that once a person is released on bail, the power of the Investigating Agency u/s.167 are not exercised unless the bail is cancelled. He cannot be sent for police custody.

5.11 In the case of State of Punjab v. Jagjit Singh (supra) delivered in the year 2008, Hon'ble Apex Court held that the accused, who has been released on anticipatory bail makes himself available for investigation/interrogation as and when required by the police officer. If an accused does not cooperate with the investigation, prosecution can file an application for cancellation of bail.

6. In my opinion, when an accused complies with all the conditions imposed and executes a bond as per the order u/s.438 of the Code and is released on bail, the powers of Investigating Agency to ask for police custody seizes unless bail already granted is cancelled by the competent court either on the ground of breach of conditions, or non-cooperation in investigation or on the ground of having found out some more material during the investigation, against him.

6.1 If a person is released on bail pursuant to any order passed either u/s.439 or 438 of the Code, the investigating agency is bound to follow procedure prescribed under the Code if it wants custodial interrogation.

6.2 Since the Co-ordinate Bench has dealt with such type of conditions, in my opinion, the matter is required to be referred to the Division Bench to decide the following issue:

Whether the Investigating Agency has power to get police custody u/s.167 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, when an accused is already released on bail under the provisions of Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure?

7. Learned advocate appearing for the respective parties have argued the matter on merits and demerits of the case and the evidence in the case. I have not dealt with the same since in my opinion Trial Court would be the competent court to decide the same on its own merits. In absence of any order on remand application, it is not desirable to discuss the same.

8. Interim relief, granted earlier by this Court vide order dated 07/11/2014 and thereafter continued, shall remain in existence till the matter is placed before Division Bench of this Court and further order is passed thereon.

9. Considering the overall facts and circumstances of the case, Registry is directed to place this matter before Hon'ble the Acting Chief Justice for appropriate order to constitute the Division Bench to decide the aforesaid issue.