Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

M/S. Chakreshwari Construction Pvt. Ltd. v. Manohar Lal

Rajasthan High Court
Jan 8, 2015

BY THE COURT:

The petitioner-landlord (hereinafter ‘the landlord’) challenges the order dated 26-2-2014 passed by the Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division) and Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate No. 5, Jaipur Metropolitan cum Rent Tribunal Jaipur Metropolitan (hereinafter ‘the Tribunal’) dismissing his application under Section 21 of the Rent Control Act, 2001 (hereinafter ‘the 2001 Act’) read with Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC for taking documents on record.

Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the impugned orders dated 26-2-2014 passed by the Tribunal.

An eviction petition was filed by the landlord against the non applicant-tenant (hereinafter ‘the tenant’) inter alia on the ground that the tenant had acquired alternate accommodation adequate for his requirement. The tenant was stated to have acquired a shop at Loha Mandi, Sansar Chandra Road, Jaipur, where from he was alleged to be engaged in business in the name and style of Virat Iron Store. Reply to eviction petition was filed in the year 2008 specifically denying that the tenant was carrying out any business in the name and style of Virat Iron Store. On the basis of pleadings of the parties issues were framed, evidence was recorded and the matter fixed for final arguments.

At this stage, the landlord moved an application under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC read with Section 21 of the 2001 Act stating therein that he had come into possession of a document from the office of Commercial Taxes Officer on 17-1-2013 on the basis of an application moved by him on 7-1-2013 under the provisions of Right to Information Act, 2005 relevant to the tenant's shop at Loha Mandi Sansar Chandra Road Jaipur, where from he was carrying on business in the name and style of Bright Iron Traders. The applicant sought that the said document be allowed to be taken on record as it was central to the landlord's case against the tenant on the ground of his having acquired alternative accommodation adequate for his requirement and liable to be evicted from the tenanted premises.

The Tribunal however took the view that the application under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC read with Section 21 of the 2001 Act was belatedly filed, as the tenant had denied as early as in the year 2008 itself in his reply to the eviction petition the factum of his owning a shop and doing business in the name and style of Virat Iron Store. Taking into consideration the delay in filing the application and the fact that the case was fixed for final arguments, the learned Tribunal dismissed the application filed by the landlord. This order is under challenge as being vitiated for reason of the Tribunal having failed to exercise its discretion in accordance with law.

Heard. Considered.

Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC provides that the document which ought to be produced in court by the plaintiff when the plaint is presented, or to be entered in the list to be added or annexed to the plaint, but not so produced or entered accordingly, shall not without the leave of the court be received in evidence on his behalf at the hearing of the suit. It is thus evident that the exercise of powers under Order 7 Rule 14(3) CPC is a matter of discretion of the court with reference to facts of a given case. It is thus to be seen whether the discretion was lawfully exercised by the Tribunal. In my considered view as the underlying eviction petition was at the stage of final hearing and the tenant had already denied carrying on any business in the name and style Virat Iron Store as early as in the year 2008 itself, the Tribunal has not erred in not exercising its discretion in the year 2014 to allow the landlord to restate and re-agitate his case afresh and in dismissing the application filed by him. This court in the exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India cannot upset a discretionary order without the order being vitiated on a principle of law or for being perversely exercised with reference to relevant facts. Such a situation does not obtain on the facts in the case at hand. The impugned order is neither perverse nor vitiated by any misdirection in law.

The petition is without any force. Consequently dismissed.