Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

R.P.S.C. Ajmer v. Director (Ph) Medical And Health Ors.

Rajasthan High Court
Mar 12, 2015

Service on respondents No. 1 & 3 shall be made through the Office of Advocate General, State of Rajasthan, in the High Court at Jaipur. He is requested to appear in the matter.

Issue notice to respondent No. 2, returnable within four weeks. Steps will be taken, both through ordinary process as well as ‘Speed Post’.

The Rajasthan Public Service Commission, Ajmer (for short, ‘RPSC’), through its Secretary, has filed this Special Appeal against the judgment of learned Single Judge dated 24.2.2015, by which she has non-suited the RPSC from filing the writ petition, on the ground that even if the appointment is made by the State Government, dehors the recommendations made by the RPSC, it cannot be said to be aggrieved, to file a writ petition, challenging such appointment.

This Special Appeal raises a very important question to be considered by this Court, as to whether a State Public Service Commission, established under Article 315 of the Constitution of India, entrusted with the functions, under Article 320, to conduct 2 examinations for appointments to the services of the Union and the services of the State respectively, can file a writ petition, where the State Government acts contrary to, or in ignorance of the recommendations made by it, after the selections were held, for appointments.

Brief facts, giving rise to this Special Appeal, are that the RPSC advertised and held selections for 56 posts of Medical Officer (Dentistry). 52 candidates were empaneled in the merit list. Two candidates, who were allowed to appear provisionally in the examinations, were not found eligible, and in respect of two, police verification is awaited.

A writ petition (S.B Civil Writ Petition No. 14201/2012) was filed, challenging the migration of the candidates of reserved category, to the general category, on account of their scoring higher marks in the selections. An interim order was passed on 19.9.2012, directing that no such migration will be permitted, if they have taken any benefit of the relaxed standards in the written examination, to qualify for interview. The interim order is still in operation, and the writ petition has not been decided.

A second writ petition (S.B Civil Writ Petition No. 1916/2014) was filed by Dr. Goverdhan Singh Shekhawat, at the Principal Seat of the High Court at Jodhpur, in which an interim order was passed on 14.7.2014, after taking on record the photostat copy of the communication dated 15.05.2014 submitted by Additional Advocate General, directing the RPSC to make compliance of the said communication, sent by the government, for the purpose of recruitment of petitioner, on the post in question.

It is submitted by learned counsel appearing for the RPSC that the legal position with regard to denying the benefit of migration, to the reserved category candidate, who scores higher marks than the last candidate of the general category, to the general category, if he has taken any benefit of relaxed standards, has been clarified in Jitendra Kumar Singh v. State of UP (2010) 3 SCC 119. It was explained by the Supreme Court that even if the benefit of relaxed standards has been taken, migration cannot be denied. In Rajesh Singh v. State of Rajasthan, (D.B Civil Special Appeal (Writ) No. 769/2012) decided on 16.01.2014, a Division Bench of this Court has, following the judgment in Jitendra Kumar Singh (supra), clarified the legal position, by which the interim order passed by learned Single Judge on 19.9.2012 in S.B Civil Writ Petition No. 14201/2012, has been rendered otiose, and could not be taken into consideration, while preparing the merit list.

We find substance in the contention of learned counsel appearing for the RPSC, that no such directions were issued by learned Single Judge in S.B Civil Writ Petition No. 1916/2014 on 14.7.2014, by which the petitioner could have got the benefit of selection, inasmuch as learned Single Judge had only directed the communication dated 15.05.2014 sent by the Director (Public Health), Medical & Health Services, Rajasthan, Jaipur, to be complied with. The communication dated 15.05.2014, does not give any such direction to the RPSC, nor any such direction can be given, to include the name of the petitioner, in the select list.

Learned counsel appearing for the RPSC submits that the select list forwarded by the RPSC, to the State Government, was not final select list, nor any recommendation was made for appointment of Dr. Goverdhan Singh Shekhawat, who is at serial No. 38 in the merit list. He is below the 20 male candidates, who were selected in general category, for appointment. He is placed by the RPSC at serial No. 7 in the waiting list.

It is submitted by learned counsel appearing for the RPSC that in the circumstances, stated as above, the RPSC may not be allowed to watch the illegal action of the State Government, giving appointment to the respondent, without any recommendation. The Constitutional mandate entrusting the Public Service Commissions in the States, under Article 320, the functions, for conducting examinations for appointment to the Services of the State, will be frustrated, if appointments are made dehors the recommendations, and in such case, the Public Service Commissions must be concerned, that the appointments are made strictly in accordance with the recommendations made by them. Reliance has been placed on the judgment of the Supreme Court in Vinod Kumar v. State of Haryana, (2013) 16 SCC 293, paragraph 26, in which it was stated that if wrong and illegal acts, applying parameters set out, as above, of judicial review, can be set aside by the Courts, obviously, the same mischief can be undone by the administrative authorities themselves, by reviewing such an order, if found to be ultra vires. Of course it is to be done, after following the principles of natural justice.

We are of the view that the State Government cannot make appointments, in public services, which fall within the purview of the RPSC, without any positive recommendations of the Commission. The Commission cannot be a mute spectator of the appointments made in absence of, or against its recommendations. In Rule 20 of the Rajasthan Medical & Health Service Rules, 1963, the Commission is required to prepare a list of candidates, whom they consider suitable for appointment to the posts concerned, arranged in the order of merit, and to forward the same to the Government, provided that the Commission may, to the extent of 50% of the advertised vacancies, keep names of suitable candidates on the reserve list. The names of such candidates may, on requisition, be recommended, in the order of merit, to the Government, within six months from the date, on which the original list is forwarded by the Commission to the Government.

The interim order passed by this Court dated 14.07.2014 in S.B Civil Writ Petition No. 1916/2014, does not give any such direction to give appointment to Dr. Goverdhan Singh Shekhawat. It was only a direction to make compliance of the communication dated 15.05.2014 The communication dated 15.05.2014 did not make any such request to the RPSC to recommend the name of Dr. Goverdhan Singh Shekhawat, to be considered for appointment.

Prima facie, we are satisfied from the submissions of learned counsel appearing for the RPSC that Dr. Goverdhan Singh Shekhawat placed at serial No. 38 in the merit list, could not be given appointment, firstly, without the recommendation of the RPSC, and secondly, in any case, as only 20 general category male candidates, for the posts advertised for selection, could be appointed from out of the merit list.

Until further orders, the appointment order dated 15.10.2014, making appointment of Dr. Goverdhan Singh Shekhawat, shall remain stayed. The realisation of costs from the RPSC, by the impugned judgment of learned Single Judge, will also remain stayed.