Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Paschim Gujarat Vij Company Limited Petitioner(S) v. Sarifaben Mehboobbhai Solanki & 1 (S)

Gujarat High Court
Feb 16, 2016

N.V Anjaria, J.:— Petitioner-Paschim Gujarat Vij Company Limited is aggrieved by order dated 30th March, 2015 of Electricity Ombudsman, Gujarat State.

2. By the I aforesaid order, the Ombudsman accepted the appeal of respondent Nos. 1 and 2 herein being Case No. 19 of 2015. The appeal was preferred by the said private respondents upon being aggrieved by the demand for payment of electricity charges in the nature of unpaid dues of the previous owner of the premises, sought to be recovered from respondent Nos. 1 and 2. As the appeal came to be allowed, the electricity connection at the premises in question which already granted and existed, remained undisturbed.

3. Stating the relevant facts leaving aside the unnecessary details, it appears that the premises/land originally belonging to Kanti Cotton Mills Private Limited, was sold to one M/s. Jay Mahakali Infrastructure Private Limited on 28 June, 2004. The property/premises changed hands further and finally the present respondent Nos. 1 and 2 purchased and became the owners of the plot in place of said M/s. Jay Mahakali Infrastructure Private Limited in the year 2012.

3.1 An application was made on 04 October, 2014 by the private respondents to the electricity company for grant of electricity connection at the said place. It appears that the connection at that time was refused by the electricity company on the ground that the electricity dues by the first owner-previous owner Kanti Cotton Mills Private Limited were unpaid. The dues were to the tune of Rs. 99,60,670.17ps.

3.2 It appears that said M/s. Jay Mahakali Infrastructure Private Limited-predecessor-in-title of respondent Nos. 1 and 2 was also denied electricity connection on the same ground. The said party had an occasion to file Special Civil Application No. 12624 of 2005 which came to be allowed by this Court on the ground that dues sought to be claimed by the electricity company from the said subsequent purchaser-M/s. Jay Mahakali Infrastructure Private Limited had become non-recoverable as time-barred. Against that order, Letters Patent Appeal No. 1518 of 2006 was preferred by the electricity company.

3.3 The said Letters Patent Appeal came to be dismissed by the Division Bench by judgment dated 04 April, 2014 observing and holding as under:

“7. We have heard learned counsel for both the sides and have perused the documents on record. Before we advert into the merits of the case, we clarify that we have not gone into the question of applicability of Condition-2(j) in the present case. We propose to decide the matter only on the point whether the claim is barred by limitation or not.

8. It appears from the record that the electricity connection was permanently disconnected on 01.06.1977 meaning thereby, that the dues must be for prior to May 1997, i.e for more than three years. The said dues are sought to be recovered by the appellant in the year 2004/2005. In our considered opinion, such dues cannot be said to be legally recoverable as they have become time barred. The appellant cannot be permitted to recover the dues that have become time barred from the subsequent purchaser under the guise of Condition-2 (j).

9. The appropriate remedy available to the appellant was to file a civil suit or to get a garnishee order so that the purchaser would know that there is a liability on the property in question. In our view, the decisions relied upon by learned counsel Mr. Vyas will govern the issue on hand. We are in complete agreement with the reasonings given by the learned single Judge in the impugned judgment and find no reasons to disturb the same.”

4. Heard learned advocate Mr. Maulik Nanavati for the petitioner.

5. Evidently, the impugned order of the Ombudsman allowing the appeal of the private respondents is based on the aforesaid decision of the Division Bench of this Court which held that the electricity dues claimed by the company were time-barred, therefore not recoverable. The electricity company issued the demand notice to the private respondents asking for the very dues of electricity unpaid by the said erstwhile owner. The company thereby tried to dispute the entitlement of the private respondents to have continued the electricity connection.

5.1 The recoverability of the dues was dealt with by the Division Bench which held that the said dues were not recoverable. Therefore, in accepting the appeal of the private respondents, the Ombudsman committed no error whatsoever. The Ombudsman in his order allowing the appeal only followed the findings and declaration made by the Division Bench. Therefore, the impugned order passed by the Ombudsman is eminently just, proper and legal. It does not book any infirmity.

6. Learned advocate for the petitioner however submitted and asserted that before the Letters Patent Bench, the electricity company could not raise several legal contentions. For that, learned advocate invited attention of this Court to grounds (d), (e) and (f) in the memorandum of the present petition (pages 11 and 12). By pressing into service the said grounds, it was harped that they were strong grounds to be considered. The submission of learned advocate was that had those grounds been placed before the Division Bench, the complexion of the case would have been different.

6.1 The aforesaid submission that particular ground/s was/were not canvassed before the Letters Patent Bench, could not be canvassed before this Court. The judgment of the Division Bench is binding. It thoroughly ill-lies in the month of the electricity company to contend before this Court that the petition may be entertained because certain grounds were not put-forth before the Letters Patent Bench, eventhough the Division Bench held that dues in question to be non-recoverable as time-barred. None of the grounds could be entertained by this Court in view of binding decision of the Division Bench.

7. The impugned order of the Ombudsman therefore does not book any error. Petition is dismissed.