- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Suraj Kumar Mundra And Anr. v. The State Of West Bengal & Ors.
Dipankar Datta, J.:— Valuation of the subject property for the purpose of stamp duty and registration fees payable by the vendee was considered by the D.I.G, Registration, Range-X, Raiganj, Uttar Dinajpur & Dakshin Dinajpur, who proceeded to pass an order dated 29.01.2015 Such order was carried in appeal before the Commissioner, Jalpaiguri Division, being the appellate authority, under Section 47B of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899. By the appellate order dated 07.09.2015, determination of market value as well as assessment of stamp duty and registration fees payable by the appellants was confirmed.
2. The appellate order is under challenge in this writ petition primarily on three grounds raised by Mr. Bhattacharya, learned advocate appearing for the petitioners. The same are (1) a report of enquiry was considered by the D.I.G Registration which was not supplied to the petitioner; (2) although the subject property was classified as ‘Bastu’, valuation was determined treating it to be a property used for commercial purpose; and (3) deeds produced by the petitioners were not considered by the appellate authority.
3. Mr. Dutta, learned junior Government advocate appearing for the State has not been called upon to respond since this Bench has not found merit in any of the contentions raised by Mr. Bhattacharya.
4. Insofar as the first two grounds of challenge noted supra are concerned, Mr. Bhattacharya was called upon to show from the appeal petition as to whether such grounds were urged before the appellate authority or not. Mr. Bhattacharya was given time to look into the appeal petition but unfortunately no such ground could be shown to have been taken in the appeal petition for being urged before the appellate authority. The petitioners themselves not having urged points which could be urged before the appellate authority, they must be held to have waived any objection that they had in relation thereto. In course of a judicial review of the appellate order, this Bench cannot entertain the plea of Mr. Bhattacharya, for, no perversity or infirmity is apparent on its face.
5. Regarding the last ground, Mr. Bhattacharya has referred to paragraphs 23 and 25 of the writ petition. The appellate order has been perused, which reveals that all the documents produced by the petitioners as well as the department were examined. The details/particulars of the plot which was sought to be transferred by the sale deed, referred to in paragraph 23 of the writ petition, have not been furnished. It is, therefore, not known as to what is the distance between such property and the subject property which was being valued. On the other hand, the appellate order reveals that the valuation of the subject property was determined by the D.I.G keeping in mind the existence of a State Highway, bus stand, a municipal market, the municipality office as well as State Bank of India, Gangarampur in close proximity thereto. This finding of the appellate authority has not been specifically challenged.
6. In a case of the present nature, the tests of perversity have to be satisfied to enable a Court of Writ to interfere in the exercise of its power of judicial review. No perversity in the appellate order having been demonstrated, there is no question of entertaining the writ petition.
7. The writ petition stands dismissed, without costs.
8. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be furnished to the parties as early as possible.
Alert