Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

K.P. Anil Rajagopal v. State Of Kerala

Kerala High Court
Oct 3, 2017
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, an Assistant Professor and Finance Coordinator at the College of Engineering, Thalassery, submitted a report (Ext.P7) regarding expenditure for a personality development training program coordinated by the 6th respondent. The petitioner alleged that the original report was "abducted" by the 6th respondent. The 6th respondent filed a complaint under the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 ("Act of 2013"), based on the petitioner's report. An Enquiry Committee constituted under Section 11 of the Act conducted an inquiry and found the petitioner liable to apologize to the 6th respondent. The petitioner challenged these findings through a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner's report and the language used therein can constitute sexual harassment under the Act of 2013.
  2. Whether the writ petition challenging the Committee's findings is maintainable under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
  3. Whether the Committee acted within the scope of its powers under the Act of 2013 in finding the petitioner liable for sexual harassment.

Arguments of the Parties

6th Respondent's Arguments

  • Objected to the maintainability of the writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution.
  • Asserted a wider connotation of sexual harassment under sub-section (2) of Section 3 of the Act of 2013, arguing that the petitioner's actions fall within this ambit.
  • Alleged that the petitioner's report was prejudiced, ill-motivated, and prepared with mala fide intention to sexually harass her at the workplace.
  • Denied the petitioner's allegations of abduction of the original report and forgery of attendance sheets, stating these were baseless and without enquiry.
  • Claimed the petitioner's report created an intimidating, offensive, and hostile work environment, adversely affecting her mental health.

Petitioner's Position

  • Maintained that the petitioner's report was made in the capacity of Finance Coordinator to highlight discrepancies and negligence by the 6th respondent.
  • Denied any acts of sexual harassment or intent of sexual exploitation in the allegations.
  • Contended that the term "abducted" was improper language but did not amount to sexual harassment under the Act.
  • Asserted that allowing such complaints under the Act would hinder supervisory functions over female employees.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the definition of sexual harassment under Section 2(n) and the circumstances enumerated under Section 3(2) of the Act of 2013. It found no specific complaint or allegation of physical contact, sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, sexually colored remarks, or any other unwelcome sexual conduct against the petitioner. The Court emphasized that mere allegations of ill-motivation or hostile environment, without connection to sexual acts or behavior, do not constitute sexual harassment under the Act. The Court noted that the Committee's finding was based solely on the use of the word "abducted" in the petitioner's report, which was deemed improper language but not sexual harassment. Further, the Court held that the Committee acted beyond its powers under the Act by treating the petitioner's report as sexual harassment. The Court also addressed the maintainability of the writ petition, stating that since the College of Engineering is a State under Article 12 and the matter involves serious consequences under the Act, Article 226 jurisdiction was appropriate.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is allowed.

The Court set aside the Committee's recommendations and held that the complaint was not maintainable under the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013. The decision directly affects the parties by relieving the petitioner from the obligation to apologize and clarifies that mere supervisory criticism or improper language, absent sexual conduct, does not constitute sexual harassment under the Act. No new precedent was established beyond the facts of this case.

Show all summary ...

K. Vinod Chandran, J.:— The petitioner is aggrieved with the findings of the Committee, as entered in Ext.P21, based on a complaint by the 6th respondent, which is produced at Ext.P10 The complaint is under the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 (‘Act of 2013’ for short). Ext.P7 report by the petitioner is said to have resulted in the complaint. The Enquiry Committee conducted an enquiry as per Section 11 of the Act of 2013 and found that the petitioner is liable to apologize to the 6 respondent; which is impugned herein.

2. The petitioner, an Assistant Professor in the College of Engineering, Thalassery, is also the Finance Coordinator. A personality development training program was conducted from 25 to 27 July, 2015, coordinated by the 6 respondent as Programme Coordinator. A report on expenditure was to be made by the petitioner regarding the training program, which was made as per Ext.P7 In that report, the petitioner had made a statement that the “original report was abducted by Smt. P. Rinitha” (sic). The petitioner intended to convey that it was taken away and suppressed by the 6 respondent.

3. The learned Counsel appearing for the 6 respondent specifically objected to the maintainability of the writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The 6 respondent also submits that there is a wider connotation to sexual harassment, as seen from sub-section (2) of Section 3 of the Act of 2013. The actions enumerated therein also would constitute an offense leading to sexual harassment, is the argument.

4. The petitioner, in his capacity of the Finance Coordinator, had made a report, on the basis of which the competent authority will have to find if the expenditures were proper or not. There are some discrepancies pointed out in the report, which were alleged to be occasioned by the negligence of the Programme Coordinator, the 6 respondent. It was also alleged that the original report was abducted (sic) by the 6 respondent. The 6 respondent had replied to the said allegations by Exhibit P8; which was considered by the Monitoring Committee (not one constituted under the Act of 2013, but, an administrative committee), as seen from Exhibit P9. The Committee, based on the allegation of harassment, resolved to recommend that the Principal call for a written explanation from the 6 respondent as to the allegation raised by her. Significantly, the Committee simultaneously directed the 6 respondent to explain as to why the report of the programme was revised. Evidently, the first recommendation had led to the complaint under the Act of 2013.

5. The 6 respondent then filed Exhibit P10 complaint with the following allegations:

4) According to the complainant, the report submitted by the respondent is prejudiced, ill-motivated and with mala-fide intention. The report is submitted by the respondent suppressing the material facts. In the report, the respondent alleged that, the complainant had abducted the report (Meant the report submitted by the complainant after conclusion of the training program) and made forgery in the attendance sheet. These two allegations against the complainant are serious in nature and which is without having any pinch of truth.

5) The complainant submits that, the respondent had prepared the report not on facts & real circumstances. It is ill-motivated and willfully and intentionally prepared to sexually harass the complainant at the work place. The respondent had questioned the dignity & integrity of the complainant and abused his power as a Financial Coordinator and exceeded the limit for his own whims and fancies. Earlier, the respondent had submitted a letter dt. 20-10-2015 to the Principal in which, the respondent contended that, he had seen the report (Meant the report submitted by the complainant after conclusion of the training program) and it is subsequently missing from his file. That itself shows that, the complainant had submitted the report and it is missing while it was under his custody. The respondent is the custodian of his files and he alone is responsible for the missing of report submitted by the complainant. The missing of report is a concocted story by the respondent. No point of time, the respondent raised such a complaint, that the report submitted by the complainant had abducted by the complainant. The letter submitted by respondent to the Principal is numbered in the inward register as 1059 itself unveils the real facts. When the report was prepared by the respondent in the month of November, after 27 days of above referred letter, 1st time he made an allegation that, the report was abducted by the complainant. If the allegation is true, the respondent would have been report the same to the higher authorities and is supposed to mention the date, time, place etc. of abduction.

6) The respondent made an allegation of forgery against the complainant in the report. The said allegation is also strongly denied by the complainant since it is false and baseless. Before making such an allegation, the respondent not even conducted any enquiry in this regard. The complainant, the concerned students, or any other persons connected in this allegation could not get an opportunity of enquiry. The signatures in the attendance sheet are put by the concerned students and in this regard the complainant is ready & willing for any legal & scientific inquiry to substantiate the contentions. Without making any enquiry in this regard, the respondent jumped into a false conclusion that those signatures are forged one. This is not fair and it is the violation of principles of natural justice. The finding of the respondent is with mala-fide intention and it is meant for harassing & defaming the complainant.

7) The respondent by submitting such a false report, explicitly threatened the present and future employment of the complainant in the institution and created an intimidating or offensive or hostile work environment in the institution. The false allegation of abduction of report & forgery of attendance is really a humiliating treatment for the complainant and which is adversely affected the mental health of the complainant.

6. The bland allegation is that the petitioner had made a report against the 6 respondent making certain allegations which are ill-motivated and intentionally prepared to sexually harass the complainant. There is no specific allegation of an act perpetrated of sexual harassment or the harassment alleged being aimed at sexual exploitation.

7. The Act of 2013 is intended at prevention of sexual harassment, the definition of which, as seen from sub section (n) of Section 2 of the Act of 2013, is as follows:

“(n) “sexual harassment” includes any one or more of the following unwelcome acts or behaviour (whether directly or by implication) namely:—

(i) physical contact and advances; or

(ii) a demand or request for sexual favours; or

(iii) making sexually coloured remarks; or

(iv) showing pornography; or

(v) any other unwelcome physical, verbal or non-verbal conduct of sexual nature;”

8. There is no complaint made of any such act having been committed by the petitioner.

9. Section 3 (2) reads as under:

“(2) The following circumstances, among other circumstances, if it occurs or is present in relation to or connected with any act or behaviour of sexual harassment may amount to sexual harassment:—

(i) implied or explicit promise of preferential treatment in her employment; or

(ii) implied or explicit threat of detrimental treatment in her employment; or

(iii) implied or explicit threat about her present or future employment status; or

(iv) interference with her work or creating an intimidating or offensive or hostile work environment for her; or

(v) humiliating treatment likely to affect her health or safety.”

10. As already noticed, there is no sexual harassment complained of and a solitary allegation of any or all of the acts enumerated under Section 3(2), cannot constitute an offense under the Act of 2013. Any such act should be connected with and in relation to any act or behaviour of sexual harassment. This Court also does not find any allegation of a promise, threat or an offensive or hostile work environment or a humiliating treatment against the 6 respondent, from the complaint; which is in connection with an act or behaviour of sexual harassment. There is no allegation that the purported harassment was intended at sexual exploitation of the complainant; which can only be if there is any allegation as such of a sexual offense.

11. What is complained of is the report made as to the 6 respondent having ‘abducted’ (sic) the original report. The complaint is that the allegation in the report was only to harass the complainant which cannot constitute a sexual harassment merely because it was made against a female employee. If such complaints are allowed to be made under the Act of 2013, then, there could be no independent report made against any women employee in any organisation and no controlling authority would be able to properly supervise the work of a female employee.

12. As to the ground of maintainability; this Court is of the opinion that the College of Engineering, being a ‘State’ under Article 12 of the Constitution of India, and the action having been taken under the Act of 2013, especially causing serious consequences to the petitioner, this is a fit case where Article 226 of the Constitution of India can be invoked. The Committee's report also does not disclose any finding of sexual harassment. The statements made before the Committee indicate that the report of the Programme made by the 6 respondent; after submission was taken back by the 6 respondent and resubmitted. The Committee only found that the language used by the petitioner, specifically the word ‘abducted’ was improper. Intemperate language, if at all, used in a report, merely because the report was against a female employee, cannot constitute sexual harassment. The Committee constituted under the Act of 2013 acted far beyond the scope of the powers conferred on it. In such circumstance, the recommendations of the Committee are set aside and the complaint found to be not one capable of institution under the Act of 2013.

13. The writ petition is allowed. No Costs.