Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of U.P. And 2 Ors. v. Dhirendra Pal Singh, Restired Asstt. Store Superintendent

Allahabad High Court
May 31, 2016
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This matter arises from a Special Appeal filed by the State of U.P. and two others challenging the validity of an order dated 10.12.2015 passed by a learned Single Judge in Writ Petition No. 49921/2015 (Dhirendra Pal Singh v. State of U.P.). The Single Judge allowed the Writ Petition and directed the appellants to ensure payment of interest w.e.f. 30.06.2009 till actual payment.

The petitioner (opposite party) was employed as Assistant Store Superintendent. Prior to his superannuation (30.06.2009), discrepancies emerged during physical verification of registers supplied by him. He acknowledged in correspondence that records did not tally and explained that, at handover on his date of retirement, things would be clear; he requested time and later submitted detailed replies (including on 04.05.2010) indicating items lying on the spot and suggesting valuation at depreciated value.

After retirement, provisional pension was paid and certain retiral dues (70% gratuity, G.P.F, leave encashment and other dues) were paid; however 30% of gratuity and the pension computation amount were not paid. The petitioner filed Original Suit No. 338 of 2012 (which remained pending and later was dismissed as withdrawn), filed Writ Petition No. 66978 of 2014 (dismissed as not maintainable), and ultimately filed Writ Petition No. 49921 of 2015 which was allowed by the Single Judge.

The appellants had issued an order dated 23.07.2015 putting retiral dues on hold and a consequential order dated 06.08.2015 effecting recovery from the remaining retiral dues; these orders were challenged in the writ petition which the Single Judge allowed.

Procedural adjunct: The Court condoned a delay of 103 days in filing the Special Appeal and treated the Special Appeal as filed within time, based on reasons in the supporting affidavit.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the learned Single Judge erred in quashing and setting aside the departmental order(s) which put petitioner’s retiral dues on hold and directed recovery (orders dated 23.07.2015 and 06.08.2015), i.e., whether recovery could be directed in the absence of departmental or judicial proceedings as required by the Civil Service Regulations.
  2. Whether the statutory/regulatory scheme (notably Regulations 351, 351-A, 351-AA and 919-A of the Civil Service Regulations) permits withholding/withdrawing pension or ordering recovery from pension in the circumstances of this case—where no departmental inquiry was conducted and more than four years had elapsed after the events complained of.
  3. Whether the procedural and temporal prerequisites for initiating proceedings that can lead to withholding of pension or recovery (including the four-year limitation and the requirement for charges to be framed or for proceedings to be instituted) were complied with before directing recovery from the petitioner’s retiral dues.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (Shri A.K. Goyal, Additional Chief Standing Counsel)

  • It was contended that the learned Single Judge misdirected himself in quashing the order which sought to initiate recovery. In the facts of the case, such an order directing recovery ought not to have been quashed.

Respondent / Petitioner-opposite party's Arguments (Shri Prabhakar Awasthi, Advocate)

  • It was contended that the Single Judge's order was correct and no interference was warranted with the relief granted by the Single Judge.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's reasoning proceeds from a close reading of the Civil Service Regulations relied upon by the parties and reproduced in the opinion. The Court set out and analysed the relevant provisions and applied them to the undisputed factual matrix.

Relevant regulatory framework summarized and interpreted by the Court:

  • Regulation 351: reserves to the State Government the right to withhold or withdraw a pension (or part of it) if a pensioner is convicted of a serious crime or found guilty of grave misconduct; the decision of the State Government on such withholding/withdrawing is final.
  • Regulation 351-A: reserves to the Governor the right to withhold/withdraw pension (permanently or for a specified period) and to order recovery from a pension of any pecuniary loss caused to the Government if, in departmental or judicial proceedings, the pensioner is found guilty of grave misconduct or to have caused pecuniary loss by misconduct or negligence. It contains provisos requiring sanction where proceedings are instituted after retirement, limits the period of events to not more than four years before institution of proceedings, and requires proceedings to follow the procedure applicable to dismissal.
  • Explanation (b) to the second proviso clarifies when departmental or judicial proceedings shall be deemed to have been instituted: departmental proceedings when charges are framed or suspension date; criminal proceedings on complaint or charge-sheet; civil proceedings on presentation of plaint or application.
  • Regulation 351-AA and Regulation 919-A provide for provisional pension when departmental or judicial proceedings or an enquiry are pending at the date of retirement (919-A specifies the amount, period and adjustment mechanism; it also bars payment of death-cum-retirement gratuity until conclusion of proceedings).

Applying these provisions to the facts, the Court observed:

  • Even though discrepancies in records were noted before the petitioner’s superannuation and the petitioner accepted in principle that records did not tally (and provided particulars and proposed valuation), no departmental inquiry of any substance was conducted to determine negligence or misconduct that could justify withholding/withdrawing pension or ordering recovery.
  • Regulation 351-A requires a determination in departmental or judicial proceedings that the pensioner was guilty of grave misconduct or caused pecuniary loss by misconduct or negligence before recovery could be ordered; the procedural safeguards and time limits (notably the four-year limit) must be followed.
  • Departmental proceedings are deemed instituted only when charges are framed (or when suspension date applies); in the present case, there is no record of framing of charges or institution of departmental proceedings within the regulatory time limit.
  • Because no inquiry 'worth the name' had been conducted, and because action was taken after the four-year period post-retirement without adherence to the procedural requirements, the impugned recovery order was outside the parameters prescribed by the Regulations.
  • The mechanism in Regulations 351, 351-A, 351-AA and 919-A establishes that withholding/withdrawing pension or ordering recovery is conditional on finding of misconduct/pecuniary loss in the requisite proceedings and adherence to the procedure and timelines; absent these, recovery cannot be legitimately directed.

On this basis the Court concluded that the learned Single Judge correctly quashed the orders which withheld retiral dues and effected recovery, because the State-appellants had not instituted the requisite proceedings within the regulatory framework and had attempted recovery after the four-year period without interim restraint or proper procedural foundation.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The Special Appeal is dismissed. The Court confirmed that the Single Judge was right in quashing the impugned order(s) which put the petitioner’s retiral dues on hold and directed recovery, because the statutory/regulatory prerequisites (departmental or judicial proceedings, framing of charges, adherence to the four-year time limit, and procedural requirements) had not been complied with. Additionally, the Court allowed the Delay Condonation Application and condoned a delay of 103 days, treating the Special Appeal as filed within time.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The dismissal of the Special Appeal leaves intact the Single Judge's order allowing the writ petition and directing relief to the petitioner (including the order regarding interest as previously directed by the Single Judge). The State-appellants cannot rely on the attempted recovery orders that were quashed in the absence of compliant departmental/judicial proceedings.
  • No broader precedent was stated beyond the application and interpretation of the quoted regulations; the opinion resolves the controversy by applying those regulations to the specific factual situation. The Court's determination emphasizes that recovery or withholding of pension under the Regulations requires formal proceedings and adherence to the temporal and procedural safeguards set out in Regulations 351, 351-A, 351-AA and 919-A.
Show all summary ...

1. For the reasons stated in affidavit filed in support of Delay Condonation Application, which constitutes sufficient cause, Application is allowed. Delay of 103 days is condoned. Special Appeal is treated to have been filed well within time.

Ref: Special Appeal

2. State of U.P and two others are before this Court, assailing the validity of the order dated 10.12.2015 passed by learned Single Judge in Writ Petition No. 49921/2015 (Dhirendra Pal Singh v. State of U.P), wherein learned Single Judge has proceeded to pass an order, allowing the Writ Petition and directing appellants to ensure payment of interest also w.e.f 30.06.2009 till the date of actual payment.

3. Brief background of the case are that petitioner-opposite party was performing and discharging duties as Assistant Store Superintendent and before he could attain his date of superannuation it was reflected that in physical verification made qua the registers supplied by petitioner-opposite party, there has been difference and accordingly petitioner-opposite party was asked to explain his position. Petitioner-opposite party has proceeded to write a letter mentioning therein that he would attain his age of superannuation in June, 2009 and at the said point of time when he would handover charge, everything would be clear and time was prayed for. This much is also reflected that petitioner-opposite party has attained his age of superannuation and at the said point of time, provisional pension was ensured to him and 70% of the gratuity, G.P.F amount and payment towards leave encashment and other retiral dues although were paid to him but 30% of the gratuity and the amount of computation of pension was not paid. This much is also reflected that thereafter letters have been sent and petitioner-opposite party submitted his reply mentioning therein that the items in question are there lying on the spot and further request was made to remedy the situation. This much is also reflected that petitioner-opposite party on 04.05.2010 submitted his reply giving therein details of the various items that were lying and to levy the depreciated amount. This much is further reflected that thereafter petitioner-opposite party filed Original Suit No. 338 of 2012 and the said suit remained pending and in between petitioner-opposite party has proceeded to file Writ Petition No. 66978 of 2014 and this Court proceeded to dismiss the said writ petition as not maintainable and then suit was also dismissed as withdrawn and then present Writ Petition No. 49921 of 2015 has been filed, wherein pleadings inter-se parties have been exchanged and writ petition has been allowed.

4. Shri A.K Goyal, learned Additional Chief Standing Counsel has submitted with vehemence that, in the present case, learned Single Judge has misdirected himself at the point of time when he has proceeded to quash the order in question by which recovery was sought to be initiated and it is being contended that in the facts of the case such an order could not have been passed.

5. Shri Prabhakar Awasthi, Advocate, on the other hand, contended that rightful order has been passed by learned Single Judge and no interference be made.

6. After respective arguments have been advanced, the factual situation that is so emerging, in the present case, is that even before petitioner-opposite party could attain his age of superannuation on 30.06.2009, there has been correspondence on-going pointing out that the records were not at all tallying with the items shown and this much is also reflected that petitioner-opposite party was accepting this situation in principle that it is not tallying and in support of the same, petitioner-opposite party came forward by giving details that items were lying and to evaluate the same on the depreciated value and do the needful. This much is reflected that after the said reply has been submitted, no action has been taken on the same and the matter has remained pending. This much is also clear that petitioner-opposite party filed suit and said suit has been dismissed as withdrawn and thereafter questioning the validity of the order dated 23.07.2015, whereby the retiral dues of petitioner-opposite party has been kept on hold and the consequential order dated 06.08.2015 whereby the recovery has been made from the remaining retiral, dues has been questioned.

7. Accepted position is that petitioner-opposite party has attained his age of superannuation and this much is also accepted position that for making out the pecuniary losses at no point of time any departmental action whatsoever has been taken. The record in question reflects that there has been correspondence on-going in between petitioner-opposite party and the department but at no point of time any departmental action whatsoever has been taken by undertaking proceedings for effectuating pecuniary losses on account of negligence on the part of petitioner-opposite party.

8. Once such is the factual situation that is so emerging and directives have been issued for recovery, then it has to be seen as to whether such an action that has been so taken is within the parameters of the rules that holds the field.

9. In order to appreciate the respective arguments, relevant regulations of Civil Service Regulations are being looked into:

“Regulation 351 provides as follows:

“351. Future good conduct is an implied condition of every grant of a pension. The State Government reserve to themselves the right of withholding or withdrawing a pension or any part of it, if the pensioner be convicted of serious crime or be guilty of grave misconduct. The decision of the State Government on any question of withholding or withdrawing the whole or any part of pension under this regulation shall be final and conclusive.”

Regulation 351-A insofar as is material to this proceeding is as follows:

“351-A. The Governor reserves to himself the right of withholding or withdrawing a pension or any part of it, whether permanently or for a specified period and the right of ordering the recovery from a pension of the whole or part of any pecuniary loss caused Government, if the pensioner is found in departmental or Judicial proceedings to have been guilty of grave misconduct, or to have caused pecuniary loss to Government by misconduct or negligence, during his service, including service rendered on re-employment after retirement.

Provided that:

(a) such departmental proceedings, if not instituted while the officer was on duty either before retirement or during re-employment.

(i) shall not be instituted with the save with the sanction of Governor.

(ii) shall be in respect of event which took place not more than four years before the institution of proceedings and

(iii) shall be conducted by such authority and in such place or places as the Governor may direct and in accordance with the procedure applicable on which an order of dismissal from service may be made

Explanation (b) to the second proviso of Regulation 351-A, inter alia, provides as follows:

(a) departmental proceedings shall be deemed to have been instituted when the charges framed against the pensioner are issued to him, or, if the officer has been placed under suspension from an earlier date, on such date.

(b) judicial proceedings shall be deemed to have been instituted:

(i) in the case of criminal proceedings, on the date on which complaint is made, or a charge-sheet is submitted, to a criminal court ; and

(ii) in the case of civil proceedings, on the date on which the plaint is presented or, as the case may be, an application is made to a civil court.”

Regulation 351-AA is as follows:

“351-AA. In the case of a Government Servant who retires on attaining the age of superannuation or otherwise and against whom any departmental or Judicial proceedings or any enquiry by Administrative Tribunal is pending on the date of retirement or is to be instituted after retirement a provisional pension as provided in Regulation 919-A may be sanctioned.”

Regulation 919-A reads as follows:

“919-A. (1) In case referred to in Regulation 351-AA the Head of Department may authorise the provisional pension equal to the maximum pension which would have been admissible on the basis of qualifying service upto the date of retirement of the Government servant or if he was under suspension on the date of retirement upto the date immediately preceding the date on which he was placed under suspension.

(2) The provisional pension shall be authorised for the period commencing from the date of retirement upto and including the date on which after conclusion of departmental or judicial proceeding or the enquiry by the administrative Tribunal; as the case may be, final orders are passed by the competent authority.

(3) No death-cum-retirement gratuity shall be paid to the Government servant until the conclusion of the departmental or judicial proceedings or the enquiry by the Administrative Tribunal and issue of final orders thereon.

(4) Payment of provisional pension made under clause (1) above shall be adjusted against final retirement benefits sanctioned to such Government servant upon conclusion of the proceedings or enquiry referred to in clause (3) but no recovery shall be made where the pension finally sanctioned is less than the provisional pension or withheld either permanently or for special period.”

10. Regulation 351 thus reserves to the State Government the right to withhold or withdraw pension or a part thereof upon a pensioner being convicted of a serious crime or being guilty of a grave misconduct. Conviction of a serious crime within the meaning of regulation 351 postulates that after a criminal trial, a pensioner has been found guilty of an offence involving a serious crime. In other words, there has to be a judicial determination by which the pensioner is convicted of a serious crime. Regulation 351-A reserves to government the right of withholding or withdrawing of pension and the right to order a recovery from the pension, if a pensioner is found in departmental or judicial proceedings to be guilty of grave misconduct or to have caused a pecuniary loss to the Government by his misconduct or negligence. Hence, regulation 351-A operates in two areas:

(i) if the pensioner is found in departmental or judicial proceedings to be guilty of grave misconduct;

(ii) if the pensioner is found in departmental or judicial proceedings to have caused pecuniary loss to the government by his misconduct or negligence, during service or on re-employment.

11. Government has the power to withhold or withdraw the pension and a power to recover any pecuniary loss suffered. Regulation 351-A postulates that there has to be a determination in departmental or judicial proceedings. Regulation 351-AA deals with a situation where a departmental or judicial proceeding or any enquiry by the Administrative Tribunal is pending on the date of retirement or is to be instituted after retirement in which case a provisional pension under regulation 919-A may be sanctioned. Where a departmental or judicial proceeding is pending on the date of retirement, regulation 351-AA stipulates that a provisional pension would be admissible and the modalities for the payment of a provisional pension are prescribed under regulation 919-A. Time frame and procedure to be adhered in taking action has also been provided for. Regulation 919-A(1) makes a reference to the situation which is referred in regulation 351-AA and authorises the payment of a provisional pension by the Head of Department. The provisional pension is to be authorised for the period commencing from the date of retirement upto and including the date of conclusion of departmental or judicial proceedings or, as the case may be, the enquiry by the Administrative Tribunal. Regulation 919-A(3) contains an expression prohibition on the payment of death-cum-retirement gratuity to a government servant until the conclusion of the departmental proceeding, judicial proceeding or as the case may be, an enquiry by the Administrative Tribunal. Regulation 41 provides that except when the term ‘Pension’ is used in contradistinction to gratuity, ‘Pension’ would include gratuity. Consequently, regulation 919 (3) which contains a bar on the payment of gratuity till the conclusion of a departmental or judicial proceeding would allow the payment of a provisional pension stipulated in clause (1) of regulation 919-A.

12. A full fledged mechanism has been provided for, which clearly reflects that the amount in question can be kept on hold/recovered only once there are departmental proceedings, wherein pecuniary losses have been caused to Government by misconduct or negligence and in order to substantiate this fact that there is misconduct, necessary inquiry has to be conducted by following the procedure meant to be adhered in the matter of dismissal of employee and by ensuring that said departmental proceeding is not in respect of an even that took place more than four years before the institution of such proceedings and further as per the explanation, departmental proceeding will be deemed to have been instituted when the charges framed against the petitioner are instituted against him or if the officer has been placed under suspension from an earlier date. In the present case, no inquiry worth name has been conducted and after the time frame provided for has come to an end, recovery has been directed and thus the learned Single Judge is right in quashing the said order in question, inasmuch as, action has been sought to be taken after four years period after attaining the age of superannuation of petitioner-opposite party and in between there was no interim order restraining the State-appellants from taking such action, in view of this, Special Appeal sans merit and the same is dismissed accordingly.