- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Aryan Arcade Ltd., Petitioner(S) v. Deputy Commissioner Of Income Tax (S)
Court Opinion Summary — Akil Kureshi, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner is a company that filed its return of income for Assessment Year (AY) 2010-11 on 15.10.2012 declaring nil income. During the relevant period the petitioner raised funds of approximately Rs. 14.89 crores by issuing Optionally Fully Convertible Debentures (OFCD) and incurred interest liabilities reflected in audited profit & loss accounts. The Assessing Officer (AO) took the return into scrutiny, raised queries, and framed the assessment order on 05.02.2013 making no additions (total assessed income Rs. NIL).
On 23.03.2015 the respondent issued a notice seeking reopening of the petitioner's assessment for AY 2010-11 under section 147 of the Income-tax Act. The AO recorded reasons alleging escapement of income on account of interest claimed in relation to OFCDs: the AO observed that although the petitioner claimed interest of Rs. 7.28 crores, newly raised OFCDs of Rs. 14.89 crores were not used for purchase/repayment of property-related loans and therefore only interest relatable to an addition to building of Rs. 34,53,367 would be allowable; the AO calculated an amount of Rs. 2,61,92,468 as required to be disallowed and treated that sum as escapement of income within the meaning of section 147.
The petitioner filed objections to reopening by communication dated 10.02.2016; those objections were rejected by order dated 11.02.2016. The petitioner then challenged the reopening notice by way of the present petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the notice dated 23.03.2015 reopening assessment for AY 2010-11 under section 147 of the Income-tax Act was validly issued.
- Whether there was escapement of income within the meaning of section 147 in respect of the interest claimed on OFCDs.
- Whether the reopening amounted to a mere change of opinion by the Assessing Officer, given that the interest claim had been examined during the original assessment.
- Whether the reopening notice was issued at the behest of the audit party (and, if so, whether such issuance would be covered by adverse precedent).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The entire interest claim on borrowed funds (including the Rs. 7.28 crores) was examined by the Assessing Officer during the original assessment; reopening now would amount to a prohibited change of opinion.
- Even accepting the AO's articulated reasons, there was no escapement of income: the petitioner contended that funds raised through OFCD were utilized for repayment of past loans and that interest would be allowable under the proviso to section 24B of the Act.
- The issue was first raised by the audit party; the original Assessing Officer was not convinced, and the reopening notice was issued only at the instance of the audit party.
Respondent/Department's Arguments
- In the original assessment proceedings the specific question whether the interest on borrowed funds (not used for acquiring house property) was allowable was not examined by the Assessing Officer; therefore the reopening notice issued within four years on recorded reasons is valid.
- Whether there has been escapement of income is a matter to be adjudicated in reassessment proceedings and cannot be determined in the writ petition at the threshold.
- The present Assessing Officer who issued the notice had independently formed the belief that income chargeable to tax had escaped assessment and did not act merely at the behest of the audit party.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Adani Exports Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax (Asstts), reported in 240 ITR 224 (Guj) | Applied to situations where a reopening notice is issued at the instance of the audit party (i.e., where the original AO is compelled to issue notice following audit suggestions). | The court said that had the original Assessing Officer later been compelled to issue the reopening notice, the matter would have been squarely covered by this judgment. The court examined records to determine whether the present notice was such a case but concluded it need not decide that issue in view of other findings. |
| Indian and Eastern Newspaper Society, New Delhi v. Commissioner of Income Tax New Delhi, reported in 119 ITR 996 (SC) | Also cited in relation to issuance of a reopening notice at the instance of the audit party and the legal consequences of such compulsion. | The court observed that if the original AO had been compelled by the audit party, the issue would attract this Supreme Court authority; however, because the impugned notice was recorded and issued by a later officer (Deputy Commissioner K.L. Solanki) who recorded independent reasons, the court did not have to decide the point given its primary conclusion on change of opinion. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in the following steps (based on the material in the file and the parties' submissions):
- Examination of the assessment record: the court noted that the petitioner had filed audited accounts with the return showing interest payments (claimed as Rs. 7.28 crores) and that the AO had issued extensive queries during scrutiny specifically about unsecured loans, interest paid, and related ledger details. The AO had received and verified the books of account and supporting documents, had test-checked the accounts, and ultimately framed an assessment on 05.02.2013 with total assessed income as nil.
- Scope of the AO's reasons for reopening: the AO's recorded reason for reopening was that the petitioner had claimed interest payable on OFCDs and that newly raised OFCD funds (Rs. 14.89 crores) were not used for acquisition/repayment of property-related loans; consequently only interest attributable to the small addition to building (Rs. 34.53 lacs) would be allowable, leading to a disallowance and escapement under section 147.
- Change of opinion analysis: the court concluded that the specific element of the interest claim now singled out for disallowance had been part of the larger interest claim (Rs. 7.28 crores) that was before the AO during original assessment and had been the subject of multiple detailed queries and verification. Because the AO had examined the matter, obtained documents and ultimately made no disallowance, the court held that reopening to disallow now would amount to a mere change of opinion — the AO would be getting a "second innings" on an issue already scrutinized and decided.
- Relationship to audit party involvement: the court acknowledged evidence that the issue surfaced during audit inquiries and that the original Assessing Officer (of the rank of ITO) had not been convinced by the audit party's suggestions. The court further observed that the impugned notice was issued by Deputy Commissioner K.L. Solanki, who recorded his own reasons and, on the face of the file, had independently applied his mind. The court noted the existence of precedent dealing with cases where reopening is compelled by audit, but found it unnecessary to decide that question because of its primary finding on change of opinion.
- Appropriate scope of writ review: the court remarked that detailed adjudication of escapement of income is typically a subject for reassessment proceedings and not ordinarily undertaken in a writ petition; nevertheless, because the record established that the interest claim had been specifically examined and accepted in the original assessment, the reopening could not stand.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The impugned notice dated 23.03.2015 reopening the assessment for AY 2010-11 is quashed. The petition is allowed and disposed of accordingly.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: the reopening notice issued by the respondent on 23.03.2015 has been set aside; the petitioner will not be subject to reassessment on that notice for AY 2010-11 on the grounds recorded in that notice.
- Broader legal implication: the court based its decision on the factual conclusion that the interest claim had been examined during the original assessment and that reopening would amount to a change of opinion. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond this application of existing law, and the court explicitly declined to decide the separate question whether the notice was issued at the instance of the audit party given its primary conclusion.
Note: This summary is confined to the facts, arguments, reasoning, authorities cited and the disposition explicitly contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer information beyond that text.
Akil Kureshi, J.:— The petitioner has challenged a notice dated 23.03.2015 issued by the respondent, seeking to reopen the petitioner's assessment for the assessment year 2010-11. Brief facts are as under.
2. The petitioner is a company registered under the Companies Act. For the assessment year 2010-11, the petitioner had filed return of income on 15.10.2012, declaring nil income. During the relevant period, the petitioner had raised funds to the tune of Rs. 14.89 crores (rounded off) by issuing Optionally Fully Convertible Debentures (‘OFCD’ for short). On such OFCD, the petitioner would also incur interest liability duly reflected in its profit and loss accounts duly audited. The Assessing Officer took the return of the petitioner in scrutiny, during which, he raised various queries. The Assessing Officer framed the order of assessment on 05.02.2013 making no additions. To reopen this assessment, impugned notice came to be issued which may be noticed, was done within a period of four years from the relevant assessment year. In order to issue the notice, the Assessing Officer had recorded following reasons:
“In this case the assessee filed the return of income on 15.10.2010 showing total income at Rs.NIL/-. An order u/s. 143(3) of the IT Act passed on 05.02.2013 determining total income at Rs.NIL/-.
Subsequently, on verification of the details it is noticed that the assessee company engaged in the business of renting of property had shown receipts from rent at Rs. 4,48,01,028/-. The assessee claimed statutory deduction Rs. 1,34,40,308/- u/s. 24 (i) of the IT Act. The assessee also claimed deduction of Rs. 7,28,00,166/- on account of interest paid on loan. It was further seen that in the balance sheet as on 31.03.2010 there is no unsecured loan. However, the unsecured loan in the form of Optionally Fully Convertible Debentures (OFCD) at Rs. 41.43 cr. have been shown. The assessee has claimed the interest payable on these OFCDs at Rs. 7,28,00,166/- from the income from house property due to following reasons. (a) The interest paid on loan taken for purchase of property is an allowable expenditure u/s. 24(ii) of the IT Act. In the instant case, it can be seen from the statement of fixed assets that the addition on building during the year was just Rs. 34,53,367/- whereas the assessee had obtained loan of Rs. 14,89,67,078/- by way of new Debentures.
(b) The new Optionally Fully Convertible Debenture was not used for purchase of property or repayment of earlier loan. The interest to the extent of Rs. 2,68,14,074/- (18% of Rs. 14,89,67,078/-) was paid on New Optionally Fully Convertible Debenture of Rs. 14,89,67,078/-. Out of this, the addition on building amounting to Rs. 34,53,367/- as shown in the statement of fixed assets can be treated as loan utilized for addition in the existing property and interest of Rs. 6,21,606/- (18% on Rs. 34,53,367/-) was required to be allowed.
Therefore, the interest paid to the extent of Rs. 2,61,92,468/- is required to be disallowed. Since the assessee has not disallowed the said interest of Rs. 2,61,92,468/- there is escapement of income to the extent of Rs. 6,21,606/- (18% on Rs. 34,53,367/- was required to be allowed.
Therefore, the interest paid to the extent of Rs. 2,61,92,468/- is required to be disallowed. Since the assessee has not disallowed the said interest of Rs. 2,61,92,468/- there is escapement of income tot he extent of Rs. 2,61,92,468/-within the meaning of sec. 147 of the IT Act.”
3. The petitioner raised detailed objections to the reopening of the assessment under a communication dated 10.02.2016 Such objections were however rejected by the respondent by an order dated 11.02.2016
4. In this background, counsel for the petitioner raised following contentions.
I. That the entire claim of interest on borrowed f unds was examined by the Assessing Officer during the original assessment proceedings. Any attempt on his part now to disallow such claim, would be based on change of opinion.
II. Even accepting the reasons recorded by the Assessing Officer, it cannot be believed that there has been any escapement of income chargeable to tax. Counsel submitted that the assessee had utilized the fund raised through OFCD for repayment of past loans and the expenditure of interest in connection with such borrowings would be allowable in terms of proviso to section 24B of the Act. III. Counsel lastly contended that the entire issue was raised by the audit party. Though the Assessing Officer was convinced that the interest expenditure cannot be disallowed, only at the instance of the audit party, the impugned notice for reopening of assessment came to be issued.
5. On the other hand, learned counsel Shri Pranav Desai for the department contended that in the original assessment, the question of allowing expenditure of the assessee company towards interest on borrowed funds which were never used for acquiring house property was never examined by the Assessing Officer. Notice for reopening which was issued within the period of four years by recording proper reasons is therefore, valid. Counsel further submitted that whether there has been escapement of income, can be judged only during the reassessment proceedings and cannot be gone into in the present petition. He lastly contended that the present respondent-Assessing Officer had not acted at the behest of audit party but independently held a belief that income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment.
6. Having thus heard learned counsel for the parties and having perused the documents on record, we notice that in the audited accounts that the petitioner filed alongwith the return, the petitioner had pointed out that payments were made to the persons specified under section 40A(2)(b) of the Act to the tune of Rs. 7.28 crores by way of interest expenditure. During the course of assessment, the Assessing Officer had raised multiple queries. Following queries are relevant for our purpose.
“1. A brief note on the nature of activities under taken during the year relevant to A.Y 2010-11. Also furnish the address of the office, branches and other premises if any and the nature of activities conducted from these premises. Please given details of sister concerns, if any, with which you are dealing. (In the following format)
Complete & AddressWhether office, Factory, Godown, Branch office & OthersWhether owned or rentedNature of business activities carried outTelephone/Fax No.Name & designation of the person in-charge
4. As regards unsecured loans (Rs. 414359187/-), please given party wise breakup in descending order. Also give address, PAN and confirmation and ledger copy. Please given interest paid on the loans and tax deducted thereon.
10. Furnish complete details in respect of following incomes:
(i)Other incomeRs. 392786/-(ii)Rental incomeRs. 43167919/-(iii)Advisory FeesRs. 5375000/-
11. Please clarify and give details of tax deducted from following payments.
(1)Salary ExpenseRs. 1678785/-(2)InterestRs. 58664000/-(3)Legal & Professional ChargesRs. 1036056/-(4)Security Service ChargesRs. 1085541/-
14. Please produce copy of all the ledger account of following expenditure claimed as per P&L A/c.
(1)Salary ExpenseRs. 3967632/-(2)InterestRs. 58664000/-(3)AdvertisementRs. 1209174/-(4)Repairs and MaintenanceRs. 231198/-(5)Marketing & Event ExpensesRs. 1762441/-(6)Electricity ExpensesRs. 3086308/-(7)Other ServicesRs. 332500/-(8)Other ExpensesRs. 1416034/-(9)BrokerageRs. 20250/-(10)Mall Operating ExpensesRs. 1557641/-(11)InsuranceRs. 206719/-(12)Los on Sale of Fixed AssetsRs. 206719/-(13)Interest on TDSRs. 1422617/-(14)House Keeping ExpensesRs. 1143549/-(15) Legal & Professional ChargesRs. 1034056/-(16)Security Service ChargesRs. 1085541/-
20. Please furnish details of payment to persons specified in Section 40A(2)(6). Specify nature of work/Service these persons are doing for the company. Produce evidence of qualifications these persons are having with respect to job assigned to them with due justification as to why this claim should not be considered excessive.?”
7. Under letter dated 24.12.2012, the petitioner replied to such queries as under:
Sr. No.ParticularsRemarks1A brief note on the nature of activities under taken during the year relevant to AY 2010-11. Also furnish the address of the office, branches and other premises if any and the nature of activities conducted from these premises. Please give details of sister concerns, if any, with which you are dealing.The Company has acquired a building (mall) at Rajkot, Gujarat on single ownership basis for the purpose of generating rental income from immovable properties. For address of office, branches and other premises, please refer Annexure-I Page Numbers from 01 to 014As regards unsecured loans (Rs. 414359187/- please give party wise breakup in Descending order. Also give address, PAN and confirmation and ledger copy. Please give interest paid on the loans and tax deducted thereon.Annexure-IV Page Numbers from 04 to 0611Please clarify and give details of tax deducted from following payments.Annexure-X(1) Salary ExpenseRs. 2090190/-Page Numbers from 115 to 118(2) InterestRs. 72800166/-(3) Legal & Professional ChargesRs. 2319851/-(4) Security Service ChargesRs. 1377899/-14(1) Salary ExpenseRs. 2090190/-Annexure-X(2) InterestRs. 72800166/-(3) AdvertisementRs. 1209174/-Page Numbers from 119 to 173(4) Repairs and MaintenanceRs. 272862/-(5) Marketing & Event ExpensesRs. 1988216/-(6) Electricity ExpensesRs. 4228061/-(7) Other ServicesRs. 332500/-(8) Other ExpensesRs. 165298/-(9) BrokerageRs. 1735097/-(10) Mall Operating ExpensesRs. 2676947/-(11) InsuranceRs. 206719/-(12) Los on Sale of Fixed AssetsRs. 88779/-(13) Interest on TDSRs. 1422617/-(14) House Keeping ExpensesRs. 1487974/-(15) Legal & Professional ChargesRs. 2319851/-(16) Security Service ChargesRs. 1377899/-20Please furnish details of payment to persons specified in Section 40A(2)(b). Specify nature of work Service these persons are doing for the company. Produce evidence of qualifications these persons are having with respect to job assigned to them with due justification as to why this claim should not be considered excessive?NIL Interest Expense of Rs. 72800166/-has been paid to IL&FS Milestone Fund I.
8. After such detailed inquiries, the Assessing Officer passed the order of assessment in which, he observed as under:
“2. The case was selected for Scrutiny, Statutory notice u/s. 143(2) of the Act dated 26/08/2011 was issued and duly served on the assessee company by speed post. Notice u/s. 142(1) dated 03/01/2012 along with questionnaire was issued and duly served on the assessee. Due to change in incumbency, notice u/s. 143(2) of the Act dated 11/10/2012 was issued and served on assessee on 12/10/2012 by speed post. Further notice u/s. 142(1) of the Act dated 22/10/2012 was issued calling for certain details/Information/documents which was served on Assessee Company on 23/10/2012.
3. In response to the above notices, General Manager of the assessee company Shri K. Ramakrishnan attended and furnished the details/information etc. from time to time. The same have been verified. The Books of Account maintained by the assessee were produced and the same were test checked. He case is heard and discussed.
4. Subject to the above remarks, the total income of the assessee company is computed as under:
Total Income as per returnRs. NIL/-TOTAL ASSESSED INCOMERs. NIL/-
9. It can thus, be seen that the entire claim of interest expenditure was before the Assessing Officer during the original assessment proceedings. The Assessing Officer had raised several queries with respect to the interest paid by the assessee on the borrowed capital. The present issue of interest to the extent of Rs. 2.68 crores forms part of the larger interest claim of Rs. 7.28 crores made by the assessee in the original assessment. The Assessing Officer only after being satisfied, upon examination of various details, materials and documents supplied by the assessee in response to the various queries raised, chose not to make any disallowance. Any attempt on part of the Assessing Officer now to reopen this issue would be based on mere change of opinion. It may be that the present issue of interest expenditure of Rs. 2.68 crores is merely an element of larger claim of assessee of Rs. 7.28 crores. Nevertheless, the Assessing Officer cannot be allowed a second innings by addressing one element of entire claim of the assessee which was scrutinized during the assessment. We may recall, the reasons for the Assessing Officer to reopen the assessment is that according to him the assessee has claimed interest of Rs. 7.28 crores payable on OFCD of Rs. 41.43 crores out of the income from house property. Interest paid on loan taken on purchase of property is allowable expenditure, however, in the present case, the assessee had shown addition only to the extent of Rs. 34.53 lacs towards building, but had obtained loan of Rs. 14.89 crores by issuing new debentures. Thus, according to the Assessing Officer, such sum was not used for purchase of properties or repayment of earlier loan and that therefore, out of the total amount of Rs. 14.89 crores raised through OFCD interest only relatable to Rs. 34.53 lacs would be allowable deduction and the rest of the claim would have to be rejected.
10. As noted, the petitioner had put-forth a claim of interest expenditure of Rs. 7.28 crores for the entire borrowed sum of Rs. 41.43 crores. Interest expenditure of Rs. 2.68 crores against newly issued OFCD of Rs. 14.89 crores was part of this larger claim. When the entire claim was examined by the Assessing Officer by calling upon the assessee to produce all supporting documents and materials, it would now not be possible for Assessing Officer to disallow this claim and contend that this element of assessee's claim was not examined and would be open for reexamination during the fresh assessment.
11. In view of our conclusions, the petitioner's second and third contentions become insignificant. However, we may briefly record that in facts of the case, we would not have been inclined to examine the petitioner's contention on escapement of income since the same would require examination of various aspects, ordinarily not undertaken in a writ petition since this would be in the realm of sufficiency of the reasons recorded by the Assessing Officer for reopening of the assessment. Regarding the petitioner's last contention of issuance of notice at the instance of the audit party, we had perused the original files produced by the counsel for the Revenue. From such files, we have noticed that this issue did surface during audit inquires. There is also material on record to suggest that original Assessing Officer who, we are informed was of the rank of ITO, was not convinced by the suggestions of the audit party. Had he later on been compelled to issue the notice for reopening the issue would have been squarely covered by the judgment of this Court in case of Adani Exports Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax (Asstts) reported in 240 ITR 224 (Guj) and judgment of the Supreme Court in case of Indian and Eastern Newspaper Society, New Delhi v. Commissioner of Income Tax New Delhi, reported in 119 ITR 996 (SC).
12. However, in the present case, the impugned notice has been issued by one Shri K.L Solanki, Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax. He is the officer who has recorded the reasons and the original file would suggest that he had independently applied his mind and found that the issues raised by the audit party are valid. An interesting question would therefore, arise whether it would be the opinion of the original Assessing Officer on the question of income escaping assessment or of the present respondent who has issued the notice for reopening which would prevail. However, in view of our conclusions with respect to the petitioner's first contention, it is not necessary for us to go into this aspect.
13. In the result, impugned notice dated 23.03.2015 is quashed. Petition is allowed and disposed of accordingly.
Alert