Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shivprasad Petitioner v. Santosh

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Aug 23, 2016

Prakash Shrivastava, J.:— Heard finally with consent.

2. This writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India has been filed by defendant in the suit challenging the order of trial court dated 25/2/16 rejecting the petitioner's application under Order 11 Rule 14 CPC.

3. Learned counsel for petitioner submits that right from beginning the plea of petitioner is that the respondent is in possession of the agreement in question and the said plea has also been taken in written statement and that the same is material document therefore, the trial court ought to have directed for production of the original document.

4. Learned counsel for respondent has opposed the writ petition submitting that respondent is not in possession of said documents therefore, the order of trial court does not suffer from any error.

5. Having heard the learned counsel for parties and on perusal of the record, it is noticed that petitioner had filed an application under Order 11 Rule 14 CPC taking the plea that carbon copy of alleged agreement executed on 11/8/2011 is available with the petitioner but its original is with the respondent. Trial court considering the respective plea of the parties has taken note of the fact that the respondent has stated on oath that no such document is available with the respondent and considering the said statement on oath the trial court has rejected the application.

6. The order of trial court is duly supported by the judgment of the Calcutta High court relied upon by counsel for respondent which is reported in the matter of India Foils Ltd. v. 5th Industrial Tribunal West Bengal wherein Calcutta High court has taken the view that for attracting the provision of Order 11 Rule 14 CPC two conditions are required to be satisfied, firstly the document must be in possession or power of the party against whom the order is made and secondly the documents must relate to the matter in question in the suit and the discretion can be exercised by the trial court in respect of wide powers conferred under the provision in case if these two conditions are satisfied. Same is the view taken by the Karnataka High court in the matter of P. Lakshminarayana v. P. Venkatasubbaiah reported in 2010 (3) Karnataka LJ 334.

7. In the present case the respondent has denied the possession of the document in question on affidavit and nothing has been pointed out from the material on record to show that respondent is in power or possession of said document.

8. Hence the order passed by trial court rejecting the petitioner's application under Order 11 Rule 14 CPC cannot be faulted.

9. In view of the above, I am of the opinion that the impugned order passed by the trial court does not suffer from any patent illegality.

10. Even otherwise, the scope of interference in exercise of jurisdiction under Article 227 of Constitution of India is limited. The Supreme court in the matter of Shalini Shyam Shetty v. Rajendra Shankar Patil, reported in (2010) 8 SCC 329 has held that High court in exercise of its power of superintendence cannot interfere to correct mere errors of law or fact or just because another view than the one taken by the tribunals or courts subordinate to it, is a possible view. The High court can exercise this power when there has been a patent perversity in the orders of tribunals and courts subordinate to it or where there has been a gross and manifest failure of justice or the basic principles of natural justice have been flouted.

11. Keeping in view the aforesaid, I find no ground to interfere in the impugned order of the trial court. The writ petition is accordingly dismissed.

12. C.C As per rules.