Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Gobindmani Dasi v. Shamlal Bysak

Calcutta High Court
Apr 7, 1864
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Full Bench was referred the question of whether a conveyance by a Hindu widow of moveable property, inherited by descent from her husband, is valid during her lifetime if made for causes other than those permitted by Hindu law. Additionally, the Bench was to consider whether the husband's reversionary heirs can sue to recover such property or compel its delivery. The matter was elaborately argued and involved examination of principal authorities on Hindu law.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Is a conveyance by a Hindu widow of moveable property inherited from her husband valid during her life if made for causes other than those allowed by Hindu law?
  2. If such conveyance is invalid, can the reversionary heirs of the husband sue to recover the property or compel its delivery either for themselves or for the widow?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Katayana Widow to enjoy husband's property during life without alienation except for allowed causes Supported principle that widow's disposal of husband's estate beyond simple use or allowed gifts is invalid
Colebrooke's Digest, Vol. III, p. 465 Widow's disposal of husband's property at pleasure, except for benefit of her lord, is invalid Reinforced that widow's conveyance without ownership is void ab initio
Doe d. Bonnerjea v. Bonnerjea Sale by widow of husband's property is void ab initio as she has no proprietary right Confirmed widow's right is usufructuary, not proprietary, rendering sale void
Goluckmonee Dabee v. Degumbur Dey (Supreme Court, 1852) Widow takes entire interest by inheritance, not a mere life estate; no reversion during her life Established widow's estate as full interest, not in abeyance, differing from English life estate
Cossinauth Bysack v. Hurrosoondery Dossee (Privy Council, 1826) Widow entitled to absolute possession and may dispose of property for religious or family purposes Recognized widow's authority to alienate for certain purposes; alienations for other causes may be invalid against heirs
Hurry Doss Dutt v. Sreemutty Uppoornah Dossee Widow's title is restricted but not in the nature of a trust Clarified nature of widow's estate as distinct from trust property
Hemchund Mozoomdar v. Mussamut Taramunnee Deed executed by widow does not preclude heirs after her death but operates during her life Supported principle that widow's conveyance binds only during her lifetime
Kishno Govind Sein v. Gunganarain Sircar Widow has no right to grant her interest beyond allowable causes that inure beyond her life Confirmed widow's limited alienation rights
Ramanunda Mukhopadya v. Ram Krishna Dutt Grant by widow not for benefit of husband's soul is valid for her life Affirmed validity of widow's conveyance during her life even if not for religious purposes
Collychund Dutt v. Mooree Grant made by widow for her own life is valid Supported widow's right to alienate property for her life

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed Hindu law authorities and prior case law to determine the nature of the widow's interest in property inherited from her husband. Earlier opinions held that the widow had only a usufructuary right and no proprietary interest, rendering alienations void ab initio. However, this was distinguished by later authoritative cases which established that the widow takes the entire interest by inheritance, not a mere life estate, and fully represents the estate during her life.

The court noted that while conveyances by the widow for causes not allowed by Hindu law do not destroy her estate or vest ownership in the reversionary heirs, such conveyances are binding during her lifetime. The heirs cannot sue to recover the property or compel its restoration during the widow’s life. However, after her death, the heirs are not bound by such conveyances. The court also acknowledged that if a conveyance is procured by fraud, it would be void.

The court addressed concerns that heirs might suffer prejudice due to inability to sue during the widow’s life by clarifying that heirs may sue to declare the conveyance invalid beyond the widow’s life and may seek remedies against grantees to prevent waste or destruction of property during her life if they establish sufficient cause.

Holding and Implications

Holding: A conveyance by a Hindu widow of moveable property inherited from her husband, made for causes other than those allowed by Hindu law, is valid and binding during the widow's lifetime. The reversionary heirs cannot recover the property or compel its restoration during her life, but are not bound by the conveyance after her death.

Implications: This decision confirms the widow’s full interest in inherited property during her life and protects alienations made by her during that period, except in cases of fraud. It limits the reversionary heirs’ rights to challenge conveyances only after the widow’s death, while preserving their ability to seek court intervention during her life to prevent waste or destruction of the property. No new precedent beyond the case’s direct effect on the parties is established.

Show all summary ...

The opinion of the learned Judges upon the question proposed to them was delivered by

Peacock, C.J:— The question which was referred for the consideration of a Full Bench in these appeals, is whether a conveyance by a Hindu widow of moveable property, which she takes by descent from her husband, is valid during the widow's life, if the conveyance is made for causes other than those allowed by the Hindu law; and if not, whether the reversionary heirs of the husband can interfere by suit to cause the property to be delivered up to themselves or to the widow. The case has been very fully and elaborately argued on both sides. The principal authorities on the subject are collected in the Vyavashta Darpana, a very useful book upon Hindu law by Baboo Shama Churn Sircar.

Katayana says: “Let the childless widow, preserving unsullied the bed of her lord, and abiding with her venerable protector, enjoy the property, restraining herself until her death; after her, let the heirs take it”(1)

Again — “The widow is only to enjoy her husband's estate, she is not competent to make a gift, mortgage, or sale of it”.

In Colebrooke's Digest, Vol. III, p. 465, it is said: “It fully appears that the widow's disposal of her husband's property at pleasure, otherwise than by the simple use of it, or by donation for the benefit of her lord, is invalid.”

Sir William Maenaghten, a very great authority, appears to have been of opinion that a gift or conveyance by a widow other than for allowable cause was void not only as against the reversionary heirs of her husband, but also as against herself (see Macnaghten's Hindu Law, Vol. I, pp. 19, 20). In the case of Doe d. Bonnerjea v. Bonnerjea(2), the plaintiff was non-suited. The decision turned upon another point, and is no authority upon the question now under consideration; but it is important as containing the opinion which was delivered to East, C.J, by Macnaghten, J., drawn up by his son Sir William Macnaghten. The opinion was as follows:— “If a widow make a sale in perpetuity of her husband's landed property, by a deed to that effect, the purchaser, as she had no right to make the sale, will not be benefited by it; nor will he be entitled, in virtue of it, to the interest which the widow has in the estate. This is founded upon the principle of the sale being without ownership, which renders it void ab initio, and not, as I before thought, upon the principle of a greater interest being conveyed by the deed than the widow was competent to grant. The Pandits whom I have to-day consulted agree in saying that, if one of four brothers make a deed of sale of the whole patrimonial property, it will be held good as far as his share is concerned, because the sale creates ownership in the purchaser, and not the deed, which is only proof of the sale, and may be taken to prove it as far as will serve that purpose; though invalid with respect to the conveyance of the property of the other brothers, it is valid against himself, and is proof of his intention. Not so in a deed made by a widow: she has no unlimited proprietary right over any part of her husband's property, but merely a general usufructuary right over the whole indiscriminately. It is clear, therefore, that she cannot convey the whole in perpetuity, but the deed by which she conveys it is void ab initio as to the sale, nor can it convey the interest which she possesses which (independently of its not being transferable) is an interest of a totally different nature from that of proprietary right”(3).

The opinion that the purchaser would not be entitled during the widow's life was founded upon the principle that she had no proprietary right over any part of her husband's property, but merely a general usufructuary right over the whole indiscriminately, and that the sale being without ownership was void ab initio by the Hindu law. The opinion of Sir William Macnaghten was founded upon the same principle, upon which he also gave his opinion in the same case, that the sale of a father's property by a son during the father's life-time was void ab initio, upon the ground that it was a sale without ownership, and, therefore, not binding after the father's death upon the son who succeeded to the property as his father's heir.

Sir William Macnaghten appears to have considered that the widow had no greater right in an estate which she takes by descent from her husband than a son has in the estate of his father during his father's life-time.

This, however, is not the case. In Goluckmonee Dabee v. Degumbur Dey (Sup. Court, November 15th, 1852), the Court said:— “No part of the entire interest, when the widow takes by inheritance, is in suspense or abeyance in any way; nor is there a reversion on a life-estate, but the whole interest is in the widow. When she takes as heir under the Hindu law, she is ranked in all treatises as heir. Sir Francis Macnaghten treats her estate rightly as anomalous, and other writers treat it as coming to her as heir; therefore, when they term it also a life-estate, they use that expression in a sense different from that of a pure and mere life-estate”. The Court goes on to say: “It has been invariably considered, for many years, that the widow fully represents the estate, and it is also the settled law that adverse possession which bars her, bars the heir also after her, which would not be the case if she were a mere tenant-for-life as known to the English law” — ; see also the case of Cossinauth Bysack v. Hurrosoondery Dossee(4) in the Privy Council, 24th June 1826, from which it would seem that the widow takes more than a life-estate. See also Judomoney Dabee v. Saroda Prosono Mookerjee(5); and Macpherson on Mortgages, 3rd edition, page 28. In Hurry Doss Dutt v. Sreemutty Uppoornah Dossee(6), it was held that the title of a widow to her husband's property, though a restricted one, was not in the nature of a trust. There are some decisions in the Sudder Court in which it has been held that the conveyance does not operate as against the widow during her life-time. In Hemchund Mozoomdar v. Mussamut Taramunnee, it was declared by the decree that a deed executed by the widow should not, after her death, operate to preclude the right of the surviving heirs, leaving it to operate during her life-time. In Kishno Govind Sein v. Gunganarain Sircar, the Supreme Court declared a decided opinion that a widow had no right, other than for allowable causes, to make any grant of her interest in the estate which could inure beyond her own life. In the case of Ramanunda Mukhopadya v. Ram Krishna Dutt, it was admitted by all the Judges of the Supreme Court, that the grant which was made by a widow of property inherited from her husband, and which it clearly appeared was not made for the benefit of her husband's soul, was good for her life. In Cossinauth Bysach v. Hurrosoondery Dossee, in the Privy Council, to which we have already referred, Lord Gifford, after reviewing the opinions of the different Pandits, observes: “The result, as it appears to me, of these different opinions is this: that they all agree, as I have already stated; that the widow Hurrosoondery Dossee is entitled to absolute possession; that she has, for certain purposes, a clear authority to dispose of her husband's properly; she may do it for religions purposes, including dowry to a daughter, and making gifts and donations to the husband's family. But they differ in this. The Court Pandits say that if she alienates the property for other purposes, without the consent of the husband's relations, it would be invalid; the others say that though she would incur moral blame, if applied for purposes not allowed, yet the act would be valid as against the relations of the husband. In that respect the four Pandits differ from the Pandits of the Court, founding their opinion on the doctrines contained in the Ratnakara and Chintamani where not overruled by the Dayabhaga and Dayatatwa”. It appears also from the same judgment that two other Pandits were examined, and were asked whether they agreed with or differed from the opinions of the Court Pandits. Their answer was: “We agree with them that such gifts are not valid as against the next heir of her husband; but we say that they are valid as against the widow, who could not reclaim them, whereas the heir is entitled to do so”. In Collychund Dutt v. Mooree, Ryan, C.J, says, “that a grant made by a widow for her own life is good, has been decided in this Court.”

Upon the whole, after considering all the cases upon the subject, we are of opinion that a conveyance by a Hindu widow, for other than allowable causes, of property which has descended to her from her husband, is not an act of waste which destroys the widow's estate and vests the property in the reversionary heirs, and that the conveyance is binding during the widow's life. The reversionary heirs are not, after her death, bound by the conveyance; but they are not entitled, during her life-time, to recover the property either for their own use or for the use of the widow, or to compel the restoration of it to her. If the widow in any case be imposed upon and induced to execute a conveyance by fraud, the conveyance will, in such a case, as in all other cases of fraud, be void.

It has been urged that the reversionary heirs may be prejudiced if they cannot sue for the property during the widow's life, for after her death it may be difficult to procure the necessary evidence to show that the conveyance was executed for causes not allowable; and that, in the case of moveable property, such as money or valuable securities, irreparable injury may be done to the reversionary heirs by the grantees making away with the property during the widow's life; or in the case of immovable property, by committing waste. But our decision will not preclude the reversionary heirs, even during the life-time of the widow, from commencing a suit to declare that the conveyance was executed for causes not allowable, and is, therefore, not binding beyond the widow's life. Nor will it deprive the reversionary heirs, during the life of the widow, of their remedy against the grantee to prevent waste or destruction of the property, whether moveable or immoveable, in the event of their making out a sufficient case to justify the interference of the Court.

Our opinion will be reported to the Division Court by which the question was referred to us, for their information and guidance.