- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Umrao Singh v. Fakir Chand
Straight, J.:— I am of opinion that, in passing his order of the 19th November, 1880, the Magistrate unwisely and improperly exercised the discretion given him by s. 47 of the Criminal Procedure Code. The petition upon which it was based disclosed on adequate or satisfactory grounds for the removal of the case from the Deputy Magistrate, and to withdraw the matter from his cognizance upon such ridiculous grounds as those urged by Fakir Chand was to pass a reflection upon the judicial qualifications and impartiality of the Deputy Magistrate, for which is can find neither justification nor excuse. It is true that the powers given by s. 47 are very large, but for this very reason they should be most carefully exercised, and Magistrates of Districts should use the extensive discretion given them to divert the course of procedure from its ordinary channel, only when it is absolutely necessary for the interests of justice that they should do so. ??? when an application is made to the Magistrate of a District for the withdrawal or removal of a case from the Court of a Sub-ordinate Magistrate by one of the parties to such case, notice of such application should be given to the opposite party, and an opportunity should be afforded him, if desirous of doing so, to show cause against its being granted. Nothing of this kind was done on the present instance; on the contrary, altogether ignoring any objections the complainant Umrao Singh might have had to urge, and without stating any grounds or reasons for his decision, the Magistrate, although the whole of the statements of the complainant and his witnesses had been taken and recorded by the Deputy Magistrate, summarily transferred the case to the Court of the Joint Magistrate for disposal. It appears to me that, in taking this course, the Magistrate acted wholly without adequate or sufficient reason, if he accepted the grounds urged in the petition of Fakir Chand as justifying him in granting that person's application; and that if he did not act upon these, the least he could have done would have been to record the reasons that induced him to make his order at so late a stage of the Deputy Magistrate's proceeding. In considering the question of revision by this Court, is express no opinion, one way or the other, upon the merits of the charge of mischief instituted by Umrao Singh against Fakir Chand, and is simply confine myself to the points urged by the applicant upon the question of procedure. The orders of the Magistrate dated 19th November, 1880, and of the Joint Magistrate of the 22nd November, 1880, will be set aside and the case will be restored to the file of the Deputy Magistrate, for him to proceed with the inquiry and pass such orders as may to him appear proper.
Alert