- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kashi Ram (Petitioner) v. Mani Ram (Opposite Party).
[211] Sir John Edge, C.J, and Blair, J.:— The appellant here put his decree in execution in the Court of the Subordinate Judge of Cawnpore. The respondent had a decree against the same judgment-debtor, and was proceeding in execution of his decree in the Court of a Munsif. The respondent got his execution proceedings transferred to the Court of the Subordinate Judge, and applied under s. 295 of the Code of Civil Procedure to participate in the assets. The Subordinate Judge, holding that the respondent's decree was time-barred, made an order refusing him participation in the assets. On that the respondent here appealed against that order to the Court of the District Judge. The District Judge entertained the appeal, set aside the order of the Subordinate Judge, and remanded the case to the Court of the Subordinate Judge. From that order of remand this appeal has been brought. An order passed under s. 295 is not an order appealable. Section 588 of the Code prohibits an appeal against any order passed under s. 295. The question then remains, was the order of the Subordinate Judge appealable as a decree, reading “decree” as defined in s. 2 of the Code. Unless the order in question was an order under s. 244 of the Code, it would not be a decree as defined in s. 2. The parties to the appeal below were the respondent here, a decree-holder, and the appellant here, another decree-holder. The judgment-debtor was not a party to the appeal below. Consequently we have only to consider whether the question decided below was a question which arose between the parties to the suit in which the decree was passed or their representatives within the meaning of cl. (c) of s. 244. The parties to the appeal below were not parties to any common suit. Each was a decree-holder in his own separate suit, and the only person common to both suits was the judgment-debtor. Now in those proceedings these decree-holders could not be treated as representatives of each other or of the judgment-debtor; consequently we cannot treat the order of the Subordinate Judge as one which was made or capable of being made under s. 244 of the Code. An appeal is a creation of statute. There is, so far as we can see, no section in the Code of Civil Procedure which gave an appeal from the order of the [212] Subordinate Judge, but there is a provision in s. 295 allowing a party a right of suit in a case of this kind. For these reasons we are of opinion that the appeal below did not lie. We accordingly allow this appeal with costs here and in the lower appellate Court, and, setting aside the order of remand, we reinstate the order of the Subordinate Judge with costs.
Appeal decreed.
Alert