- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bishan Chand v. Radha Kishan Das
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal arises from a decree of the Subordinate Judge of Benares dated 22nd August 1895. The plaintiff sought to recover Rs. 6,500 from the defendant, claiming that he had entered into a contract to purchase a decree held by the defendant against two persons, Sundar Das and Baij Nath Prasad. The plaintiff, related to Sundar Das, agreed to pay the amount secured by the decree along with any miscellaneous expenses incurred by the defendant. He paid Rs. 6,500 as a deposit and part payment. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant sent drafts of a sale-deed and an agreement which he refused to execute, as he had not contracted to do so. He requested details of miscellaneous charges, which the defendant did not provide, and instead put the decree into execution and realized the amount without completing the sale. The defendant refused to return the Rs. 6,500 deposit, prompting the plaintiff to sue for recovery with interest and costs.
The defendant denied breach of contract, claimed the plaintiff was at fault for not paying the balance and miscellaneous charges (claimed to be Rs. 2,000), and denied sending any draft agreement for execution, only a draft sale-deed mentioning Rs. 2,000 as miscellaneous charges. The defendant also claimed loss due to non-completion and pleaded that the plaintiff, having broken the contract, was not entitled to sue.
The Subordinate Judge found in favor of the plaintiff on all issues and granted a full decree. The defendant appealed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Which party was guilty of the breach of contract to purchase the decree?
- Whether the plaintiff was entitled to recover the Rs. 6,500 deposit after allegedly breaching the contract?
- What decree should be passed in light of the breach and the defendant's partial tender of Rs. 4,500?
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff's Arguments
- Entered into a contract to purchase the decree from the defendant, agreeing to pay the decree amount plus miscellaneous expenses.
- Paid Rs. 6,500 as deposit and part payment.
- Refused to execute the draft agreement sent by the defendant as it was not part of the contract.
- Requested details of miscellaneous charges, which were not provided.
- Defendant breached the contract by executing the decree and realizing the amount without completing the sale and refused to return the deposit.
Defendant's Arguments
- Denied breach of contract; alleged plaintiff failed to pay balance and miscellaneous charges of Rs. 2,000.
- Denied sending any draft agreement for execution; only sent draft sale-deed mentioning Rs. 2,000 miscellaneous charges.
- Claimed loss of Rs. 2,000 due to non-completion of contract.
- Pleading that plaintiff, having broken the contract, was not entitled to sue for recovery of the deposit.
- Had postponed sale of Sundar Das' property at plaintiff's request.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ex parte Barrell, in re Parnell | Where a contract for sale fails by default of the purchaser, the vendor may retain the deposit as a guarantee for performance of the contract. | The Court relied on this principle to hold that the plaintiff, having broken the contract, was not entitled to recover the deposit. |
| Howe v. Smith | A deposit serves both as part payment and as a guarantee for contract performance; if the purchaser repudiates, the deposit is forfeited. | The Court followed this rule to affirm that the plaintiff had no right to return of the deposit after repudiation. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court identified the central issue as which party breached the contract. After reviewing the facts, it differed from the lower court and found that the plaintiff was the party who broke the contract. The Court applied established legal principles from precedent cases which hold that when a purchaser repudiates a contract, the vendor is entitled to retain the deposit as a guarantee of performance. The Court reasoned that since the plaintiff was at fault, he was not competent to sue for the deposit's return.
However, the defendant did not insist on strict legal rights and had tendered Rs. 4,500 to the plaintiff, which the plaintiff refused. The Court considered this tender and the plaintiff's refusal wrongful, concluding that the decree should be modified accordingly.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is allowed.
The Court struck Rs. 2,000 off the principal sum decreed to the plaintiff, set aside the lower Court's order allowing any costs or interest to the plaintiff, and directed that the plaintiff pay all costs of the appeal and the lower Court. The plaintiff was held not entitled to recover the full deposit as he breached the contract, but the defendant was required to pay Rs. 4,500, which he had tendered and the plaintiff refused to accept. This decision directly affects the parties by modifying the decree and cost orders but does not establish any new precedent beyond applying established principles regarding forfeiture of deposits on breach by the purchaser.
Burkitt, J. (Knox, J. concurring):— This is an appeal by the defendant in the suit from a decree of the Subordinate Judge of Benares, dated the 22nd of August 1895.
The claim was for the recovery of Rs. 6,500 from the defendant. The plaintiff outs his case as follows:—He says that the defendant held a decree (No. 163 of 1892) against two persons named Sundar Das and Baij Nath Prasad; that the plaintiff, being related to Sundar Das, desired, to purchase the decree in order to help him; that he entered into a contract with the defendant to purchase the decree, agreeing to pay any “miscellaneous expenses” which the defendant had incurred in obtaining the decree in addition to the amount secured by the decree, costs, &c., and that he sent to the defendant Rs. 6,500 as a deposit and in part payment of the consideration money. The plaint then goes on to allege that the defendant sent to the plaintiff two written drafts one of a sale-deed and the other of an agreement that the plaintiff refused to execute the agreement as he had not contracted to execute such a document; that he called on the defendant to send him a detail of the miscellaneous charges, but that the defendant insisted on the execution of the draft agreement, and neither completed the sale-deed nor sent the detail of “miscellaneous charges,”, but in breach of his contract put the decree into execution and realized the amount due on it. Finally, the plaintiff alleged that the defendant refused to return the Rs. 6,500. He accordingly instituted this suit to recover that amount with interest, costs, &c.
The defendant in reply contended that he had not broken the contract, and asserted that it was the plaintiff who was in fault by trot having paid up in proper time the balance of the purchase money and the miscellaneous charges, which he put at Rs. 2,000, though the defendant at the plaintiff's request had the sale of [491] Sundar Das' property under his decree postponed. He denied that he had ever sent any draft agreement to the plaintiff or had asked him to execute such a document, but asserted that he had sent a draft sale-deed to the plaintiff in which Rs. 2,000 were entered as Being payable on account of the “miscellaneous charges.” The written statement of defence further alleged that defendant had sustained a loss of Rs. 2,000 by the non-completion of the contract, and in its last paragraph there is a plea that as the plaintiff was the person who broke the contract a suit by him was not maintainable.
The Subordinate Judge found on every issue in favour of the plaintiff and gave him a decree in full. The defendant appeal.
The only really important issue in this case is which side was guilty of the breach of contract.
After a discussion of the facts of the case, the Court, differing from the Court of first instance, found that the contract to purchase had been broken by the plaintiff. The judgment then continued:—
The question now remains what decree, should be passed in this appeal. If the defendant had persevered in the last plea set forth in his written statement, we should unhesitatingly have dismissed the suit. On our finding that the plaintiff was the person who broke the contract, we are of opinion that the plaintiff was not competent to sue to recover the deposit. In the case of Ex parte Barrell, in re Parnell it was held that where a contract for sale goes off by default of the purchaser the vendor is entitled to retain the deposit, Lord Justice James remarking that “the money was paid to the vendor as a guarantee that the contract should be performed the trustee refuses to perform the contract and then says—‘Give me back the deposit;’—there is no ground for such a claim.” And in the same case Lord Justice Mellish is reported to have said:— “It appears to me clear that, even where there is no clause in the contract as to forfeiture of the deposit, if the purchaser repudiate the contract he cannot have [492] back the money, as the contract has gone of through his default.” That case was cited with approval in the later case of Howe v. Smith, in which it was held by the Lords Justices Cotton, Bowen and Fry that a “deposit, although to be taken as part payment if the contract was completed, was also a guarantee for the performance of the contract, and that the plaintiff having failed to perform the contract within a reasonable time had no Tight tea return of the deposit.” Following the rule of law laid down in the above cited cases, we hold that the plaintiff, having broken his contract to purchase, had no right to a return of the deposit, and that the Subordinate Judge ought to have given effect to the last plea in the written statement of defence by dismissing the suit. In this appeal, however, the defendant appellant has not stood on his strict legal rights. He says he is willing to pay Rs. 4,500 to the plaintiff, and in the Court below, he called evidence which we believe to be true, to show that he had tendered Rs. 4,500 to the plaintiff, who refused to accept it on the ground that he was entitled to the full Rs. 6,500. In this appeal the defendant appellant has contented himself with contesting the decree as to Rs. 2,000 and as to interest and costs. Had the appellant appealed against the whole decree, we most certainly should have dismissed the suit. But, as matters stand, the decree we pass is that we allow this appeal, that we strike Rs. 2,000 off the principal sum decreed, that we set aside the order of the lower Court allowing any costs or interest to the plaintiff, and, as we are of opinion that the plaintiff ought thankfully to have accepted the Rs. 4,500 tendered to him by the defendant, and that this suit was wrongfully instituted, we direct that the plaintiff respondent do pay all the defendant's appellant's costs in this Court and in the lower Court.
Appeal decreed.
Alert