Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Syed Moazim Hossein Khan Bahadur v. Raphael Robinson

Calcutta High Court
Jun 18, 1901
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff is the legal representative of Herman Robinson. The defendants are father and son: Syed Moazim Hossein Khan Bahadur (the father) and Syed Mutahar Hossein, Barrister-at-law (the son). The suit is founded on an ex parte judgment of the Queen's Bench Division of the High Court of Justice in England for an amount equivalent to 6,551 rupees and odd, recovered against both defendants. Neither defendant appeared in the English action. In their defences the father and the son contended that they were not served with the writ in England, had not been within the jurisdiction of the English Court (the son admitted he had been in England previously but left before the suit), and that the English judgment was without jurisdiction and therefore inoperative as against them. Both also alleged that the English action should not have been passed on the merits and that it was fraudulent. Evidence was taken: the father gave some testimony denying dealings with Robinson; the son did not give evidence. The lower court rendered a decree against both defendants; appeals were heard and opinions were delivered by Maclean, C.J., and Banerjee, J., addressing jurisdiction, service, evidentiary presumptions under the Code of Civil Procedure, and the claim for interest.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the English (foreign) judgment is binding on the defendants.
  2. Whether the English Court had jurisdiction over the defendants (including whether territorial residence or statutory service out supported jurisdiction).
  3. Whether the defendants had personal notice of the English suit (service of process).
  4. Whether, under sec. 13 Explanation VI of the Code of Civil Procedure, the presumption of jurisdiction attaching to a produced foreign judgment could be rebutted by proving want of jurisdiction.
  5. Whether the plaintiff can recover interest on the English judgment when the English judgment itself makes no provision for interest and relevant English interest statutes do not apply to India.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' (Defendants') Arguments

  • The English judgment is not binding because neither defendant resided within the territorial jurisdiction of the English Court when the English suit was brought.
  • The English judgment is not binding because neither defendant had personal notice (service) of the English suit.
  • The English Court lacked jurisdiction over the subject-matter (the cause of action was not within the territorial jurisdiction of the English Court as to the defendants).
  • The English judgment should not attract interest in India because the English statutes conferring interest do not apply to India, and the English judgment says nothing about interest.
  • The defendants relied on sec. 13 Explanation VI of the Code of Civil Procedure to contend that the presumption of jurisdiction arising from production of a foreign judgment could be rebutted by proof of want of jurisdiction.

Plaintiff-Respondent's Arguments

  • The English judgment is presumptively evidence that the English Court had competent jurisdiction (sec. 13 Explanation VI), and that presumption stands unless the defendants rebut it.
  • Order XI (1883), Rule 1, sub-sec. (e) (an English procedural order allowing service out) has statutory force and constitutes a legislative act of the sovereign power, authorising English Courts to obtain jurisdiction over British subjects wherever they may be; thus British subjects (including natives of British India) may be bound by English judgments in cases falling within that order.
  • The plaintiff also contended that the defendants had notice of the English action and that relevant English provisions on interest are inapplicable to recovery in India, but the plaintiff sought interest based on English judgment practice; the court was asked to consider whether such interest could be recovered in India.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gurdyal Singh v. Raja of Faridkot States the general rule that a plaintiff must sue in the court to which the defendant is subject; a decree in absentia by a foreign court lacking jurisdiction over a defendant is, by international law, a nullity. The court quoted this Privy Council authority at length to frame the general territorial rule of jurisdiction, then examined whether its principles applied to British subjects (natives of British India) as opposed to foreigners who owe no allegiance to the forum state.
Schibsby v. Westenholz Principle that if defendants were subjects of the country at the time of judgment, that country's laws would bind them (i.e., personal allegiance can make a difference). Cited to support the proposition that where a defendant is a subject of the sovereign of the forum at the time of judgment, the forum's laws may bind him; used in considering whether British subjects resident in India could be bound by English jurisdictional statutes.
Rousillon v. Rousillon Authority relating to enforcement of foreign judgments and the effect of residence/subjecthood and notice. Invoked alongside Schibsby to show that subjects of the forum may be bound; also cited in relation to the question of notice and service. The court relied on it when considering the binding effect of an English judgment on British subjects.
Whaley v. Busfeld Observation that service out of jurisdiction interferes with ordinary law, but an Act of Parliament can validly give jurisdiction over British subjects wherever they may be. The court relied on this observation in assessing whether Order XI (service out) constitutes valid territorial legislation giving English Courts jurisdiction over British subjects outside the territorial limits of England.
The Credits Gerundeuse, Limited v. Van Weede Authority for the proposition that the object of service out of jurisdiction is to give notice of a proceeding affecting rights, enabling a defendant to appear and defend. Referred to in discussing whether Order XI's object is merely to give notice (particularly for foreigners) and whether that is sufficient to create jurisdiction over British subjects resident in dependencies such as India.
Sreehuree v. Gopal Chunder Authority relating to the question of personal notice (service) of proceedings abroad. Listed among authorities the court considered on the question of personal notice; the court noted those authorities but found on the facts that personal notice had been established and thus the defendants' notice contention failed.
Edulji v. Manehji Authority cited in relation to the requirements or effects of notice/service in foreign proceedings. Grouped with other authorities on notice; the court relied on the evidence rather than these authorities to conclude notice had been given.
Bangarusami v. Balasubramanian Authority cited concerning notice/service in foreign actions. Referred to in support of the proposition that lack of personal notice could invalidate a foreign judgment; the court, however, found notice established on the evidence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The courts applied a structured analysis addressing jurisdiction, service, the evidentiary presumption attaching to foreign judgments under the Code, and the claim for interest.

  1. Presumptive Effect of a Produced Foreign Judgment:

    The court treated production of the English judgment as "presumptive evidence" that the English Court had competent jurisdiction (sec. 13, Explanation VI of the Code of Civil Procedure). However, that presumption could be rebutted by proof of want of jurisdiction.

  2. Evidence on Service and Notice:

    On the factual question of service/notice in the English action, the son did not give evidence to dispute testimony (e.g., the witness Nibaran Chandra Chattopadhya); the father vaguely said he did not recollect being served. On the balance of the evidence the court held both defendants were duly served (i.e., had notice), and therefore the defendants' contention that they had no notice failed on the evidence.

  3. Distinction between Foreigners and British Subjects; Statutory Service Out:

    The court carefully examined whether the general rule (from authorities such as Gurdyal Singh) that territorial jurisdiction is necessary to bind a defendant applied equally to British subjects resident in India. It considered that Order XI, Rule 1, sub-sec. (e) (an English procedural order permitting service out) had statutory force and could be read as legislative regulation of jurisdiction over British subjects wherever they might be. Accordingly, the order could, in principle, give English Courts jurisdiction over British subjects resident in British dependencies, provided the case fell within the order.

  4. Rebuttal on Jurisdictional Basis (Application to the Father and Son):

    The court analyzed whether the particular English action in this case fell within the scope of Order XI, Rule 1(e) — that is, whether the cause of action was one which the English Court was entitled to assume jurisdiction over (e.g., breach occurring within its jurisdiction). The father gave unrebutted evidence that he never entered into any contract with Herman Robinson and had no dealings with him; the court concluded that on that evidence the English Court had no jurisdiction over the father because the claimed cause of action did not arise within English jurisdiction. This satisfied Explanation VI's requirement to prove want of jurisdiction in respect of the father, and therefore the judgment could not be enforced against the father in India. Conversely, the son produced no evidence to rebut the presumption that the English Court had competent jurisdiction. The English judgment therefore stood, as to him, as presumptive evidence of English jurisdiction and was not displaced by countervailing evidence.

  5. Claim for Interest:

    The court examined the plaintiff's claim for interest and held that the plaintiff could not recover interest beyond what appeared on the face of the English judgment. The English statutes relied on to assert interest (Order XLII, Rule 16; Statute 1 and 2 Vict., c. 110, sec. 17) were held not applicable to India; nor did the Indian statute (Act XXXII of 1839) assist. Therefore the plaintiff could not recover interest in India on the English judgment when the English judgment itself did not provide for it.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

  • Appeal of Defendant No. 1 (the father): ALLOWED. The decree against him was set aside; the suit as against him was dismissed with costs (including costs of the appeal), because he successfully rebutted the presumption of jurisdiction by unrebutted evidence that no contract (and hence no breach within English jurisdiction) existed as to him.
  • Appeal of Defendant No. 2 (the son): DISMISSED. The decree as against him was affirmed (subject to modification described below) because he put in no evidence to rebut the presumption that the English Court had jurisdiction.

Modification / Direct Consequences:

  • The decree against the son was modified to disallow recovery of interest on the English judgment: the plaintiff cannot recover interest in India where the English judgment does not provide for interest and the English statutes relied upon do not apply to India.
  • Costs: The father was to have the costs of the appeal; the modification on interest as to the son was deemed a small matter that should not affect the costs of the appeal, and his appeal was dismissed with costs.

Implications: The opinion applies existing principles about territorial jurisdiction, service and the evidentiary presumption attaching to produced foreign judgments (sec. 13 Explanation VI). It distinguishes between (a) foreigners who owe no allegiance to the forum and (b) British subjects resident in a dependency (British India), holding that statutory provisions such as Order XI, Rule 1(e) may operate to give English Courts jurisdiction over British subjects in specified circumstances. The decision resolves the dispute between the parties on the facts but does not purport to create a broader new legal precedent beyond its application of established authorities and statutes. No broader rule beyond the direct effects on the parties is declared in this opinion.

Show all summary ...

Maclean, C.J:— The Plaintiff in this suit is the legal personal representative of one Herman Robinson, and the Defendants are father and son, viz., Syed Moazim Hossein Khan Bahadur, and Syed Mutahar Hossein, Barrister-at-law. I shall refer to them as the father and the son. The suit is on a foreign judgment, viz., on an ex parte judgment of the Queen's Bench Division of the High Court of Justice of England, for an amount equivalent to 6,551 rupees and odd, a judgment recovered against both the Defendants. In his defence the father pleaded that he was not served with the writ or any copy thereof in the English action, that he had never been within the jurisdiction of the English Court, and that the judgment was made without jurisdiction, and was inoperative as against him. His son's defence was substantially the same, though he admitted he had been in England for upwards of two years, but had left some time before the date of the institution of the suit. Both Defendants pleaded that, on the merits, the judgment in the English Court ought not to have been passed, and that it was a fraudulent action. Upon this latter point I may remark at once that, even if it were competent for the Defendants to go into the merits of the suit on which the English judgment was based, which I do not think they can properly do, the son has not tendered himself as a witness in this case, nor put in any evidence whilst the father does not go beyond saying that he had no dealings with Herman Robinson, and that he never undertook to pay the boarding and lodging expenses of his son with the latter. The claim in the English Court was apparently for board, lodging and tuition. Neither of the Defendants appeared in the English action, or submitted to the jurisdiction of that Court. Upon the question of whether or not the Defendants were duly served, and had notice of the English action, the son has not ventured to go into the box and challenge the statement as to service, told by the witness Nibaran Chandra Chattopadhya, whilst the father only ventures to say that he does not recollect that any writ from England was served upon him. On the evidence, it must be taken that both Defendants were duly served. Assuming there was jurisdiction in the English Court, and that it was properly exercised, it has not been disputed that, as a general principle, the Court in which the suit on the foreign judgment is brought cannot properly go into the merits of the action which resulted in the foreign judgment sued upon, but the Appellants contend that by virtue of the last words of explanation 6 of sec. 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which explanation runs as follows: “Where a foreign judgment is relied on, the production of the judgment duly authenticated is presumptive evidence that the Court which made it had competent jurisdiction, unless the contrary appear on the record; but such presumption may be removed by proving the want of jurisdiction,” they are entitled to rebut the presumption by proving the want of jurisdiction of the English Court. It is said for the Appellants that the jurisdiction of the English Court was based entirely upon the view that the case fell within Order XI of 1883, Rule 1, sub-sec. (e), and the Defendants say they are entitled to show that was not so, and consequently that there was a want of jurisdiction in the English Court. I think they are entitled to show this. The father says he has substantiated this by his evidence, that he never wrote to Herman Robinson and had no dealings with him, and in this suit that evidence is uncontradicted, and may, I think, be relied upon. This argument, however, does not assist the son, for he has put in no evidence. I now pass to the important question of whether the English Court had jurisdiction over the Defendants, and upon this point I refer to the case of Gurdyal Singh v. Raja of Faridkot where the law on the subject was very carefully considered. That no doubt was the case of a judgment obtained in a foreign country, but against one who was not a subject of that country. In the present case the English Court is a “foreign Court” within the meaning of sec. 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the judgment is a foreign judgment. There Lordships of the Judicial Committee say:—“Under these circumstances, there was, in their Lordships' opinion, nothing to take this case out of the general rule, that the Plaintiff must sue in the Court to which the Defendant is subject at the time of suit (“actio sequitur forum rei”) which is rightly stated by Sir Robert Phillimore (International Law, Vol. 4, sec. 891) “to lie at the root of all international, and of most domestic, jurisprudence on this matter. All jurisdiction is properly territorial and extra territorium jus dicenti, impune non paretur.” Territorial jurisdiction attaches (with special exceptions) upon all persons either permanently or temporarily resident within the territory, while they are within it; but it does not follow them after they have withdrawn from it, and when they are living in another independent country……As between different provinces under one sovereignty (e.g, under the Roman Empire) the legislation of the sovereign may distribute and regulate jurisdiction; but no territorial legislation can give jurisdiction which any Foreign Court ought to recognise against foreigners, who owe no allegiance or obedience to the power which so legislates.

“In a personal action to which none of these causes of jurisdiction apply, a decree pronounced in absentem by a Foreign Court, to the jurisdiction of which the defendant has not in any way submitted himself, is by International law an absolute nullity. He is under no obligation of any kind to obey it, and it must be regarded as a mere nullity by the Courts of every nation except (when authorized by special local legislation) in the country of the forum by which it was pronounced.

“These are doctrines laid down by all the leading authorities on International law; among others, by Story (Conflict of Laws, 2nd edition, secs. 546, 549, 553, 554, 556, 586) and by Chancellor Kent (Commentaries, Vol. I, p. 284, note (c) 10th edition), and no exception is made to them in favour of the exercise of jurisdiction against a defendant not otherwise subject to it by the Courts of the country in which the cause of action arose, or (in cases of contract) by the Courts of the locus solutionis. In those cases, as well as all others, when the action is personal, the Courts of the country in which a defendant resides have power, and they ought to be resorted to, to do justice.” I have cited from this judgment at length, as it was much relied upon by the Appellants. Here the father was never permanently or even temporarily resident within the territorial jurisdiction of England, and consequently, had he been a foreigner, that jurisdiction would not have attached upon him. But then arises the question whether the principles laid down in the Privy Council case from which I have quoted, apply to the case of an Indian who is a subject of the Sovereign both of England and of British India, or merely to the cases of foreigners who owe no allegiance or obedience to the power, the Courts of which have passed the judgment sued upon.

In Dicey's “Conflict of Laws,” p. 369, the following rule is laid down; “in an action in personam in respect of any cause of action the Courts of a Foreign country have jurisdiction.”

Case 2.—“When the defendant is at the time of the judgment in the action, a subject of the Sovereign of such country,” and reference is made to Schibsby v. Westenholz(2) and Rousillon v. Rousillon(3). In the former case the Court said: “We think some things are quite clear on principle. If the defendants had been, at the time of the judgment, subjects of the country where judgment is sought to be enforced against them, we think that its laws would have bound them.” In the present case the Defendants were, at the time of the judgment, subjects of the sovereign both of England and of British India, though at the date of the judgment they were not within the territorial jurisdiction of England: they were resident in British India. It is, however, contended for the Plaintiff that quâ the circumstances of this case, there exists territorial legislation of the sovereign power giving the English Courts jurisdiction over British subjects wherever they may be, and placing them under the jurisdiction of the English Courts, or at least making it compulsory upon them to come in and submit to that jurisdiction. Upon this point may perhaps refer to the observations of the late Lord Justice Cotton who says, in the case of Whaley v. Busfeld “service out of the jurisdiction is an interference with the ordinary course of the law, for generally, Courts exercise jurisdiction only over persons who are within the territorial limits of their jurisdiction. If an Act of Parliament gives them jurisdiction over British subjects wherever they may be, such jurisdiction is valid, but apart from Statute, a Court has no power to exercise jurisdiction over any one beyond its limits.” It is contended for the Plaintiff that Order XI of 1883, Rule 1, sub-sec. (e) which has a statutory force and which order was referred to by Lord Justice Ery in the case I have just cited as “a complete code governing service out of the jurisdiction”—(I am referring to the English Courts' orders)—gives the English Courts jurisdiction over subjects of the British Crown wherever they may be. The Appellants say that the object of service under that order is not to give jurisdiction over the party served, but only to give him notice of a proceeding affecting his rights, so as to give him an opportunity of coming in to defend them, The Credits Gerundeuse, Limited v. Van Weede(5). This no doubt is so, in the case of a foreigner, but is it so in the case of a subject of the British Crown resident outside the territorial jurisdiction of England, but in a Dependency of the British Crown 1 Though no doubt, British India has its own Legislative Councils, the subjects of the British Crown there are subject to the Supreme Legislative authority of the Imperial Parliament, and Order XI Rule 1, sub-sec. (e) would appear to be general in its sphere of operation excepting only Scotland and Ireland.

In my opinion the order in question constitutes a Legislative Act of the Sovereign power regulating the jurisdiction in the case of a British subject resident in British India, and outside the ordinary territorial jurisdiction of the English Courts, and gives the English Courts jurisdiction over such British subjects, assuming that the particular case falls within the order. I think, however, that it was open to the Defendants to show, and that the father has shown, that the action in the English Court was not founded, as it purported to be, upon any breach or alleged breach within the jurisdiction of the English Court of any contract made by him, which was to be performed within such jurisdiction, and consequently that the English Court had no jurisdiction in the matter or to order service out of its jurisdiction. The present suit therefore must fail as against the father, and the suit as against him be dismissed with costs, and he must have the costs of the appeal.

The case of the son is different. No evidence has been put M on his behalf to rebut the presumption that the English Court was one of competent jurisdiction, as was done by the father, and that being so, I think, upon the grounds which I have stated, that he is liable. I do not think, however, that he is liable for interest on the amount of the English judgment: the Plaintiff cannot, I think, recover more than appears on the face of the judgment sued upon. The English Statute as to judgments carrying interest does not apply to India, nor does the Indian Statute as to interest assist the Plaintiff. The decree against the son must be modified to that extent. That however is a very small matter, and should not affect the costs of the appeal. The decree, therefore, subject to such modification, must stand as against him, and his appeal must be dismissed with costs.

Banerjee, J.:— I am of the same opinion.

This appeal arises out of a suit brought by the Plaintiff-Respondent against the Appellants. The suit is based on a judgment of the Queen's Bench Division of the High Court of Justice in England, which is a Foreign judgment within the meaning of the term as defined in sec. 2, of the Code of Civil Procedure; and the main question for determination in this appeal is whether that judgment is binding on the Appellants.

It is contended for the Defendants-Appellants, first, that the judgment upon which the suit is based is not binding on the Defendants as neither of them resided within the territorial jurisdiction of the Court when the suit was brought; secondly, that it is not binding on the Defendants as neither of them had personal notice of the suit; thirdly, that it is not binding on the Defendants as the Court which passed it hd no jurisdiction over the subject-matter of the suit; and, fourthly, that the claim for interest is untenable.

In support of the first contention, it is argued that residence, permanent or temporary, within the territorial jurisdiction of the Court, is necessary to make a Defendant, who is a foreigner, subject to its jurisdiction; and Story's Conflict of Laws, secs. 539 and 546, Phillimore's International Law, Vol. IV, sec. dcccxci, and Sirdar Gurdyal Singh v. Raja of Faridkot are relied upon. Upon principle as well as upon authority, it is no doubt true, as a general rule, that a Court can exercise jurisdiction over a foreigner only if he is resident within the limits of its territorial jurisdiction. But the reason of the rule is, as stated by Story in his Conflict of Laws, (sec. 539) that “no Sovereignty can extend its process beyond its own territorial limits to subject either persons or property to its judicial decisions;” and the same reason is given by the Privy Council in Gurdyal Singh v. Raja of Faridkot in the following passages of their Lordships' judgment: “As between different provinces under one Sovereignty (e.g, under the Roman Empire) the legislation of the sovereign may distribute and regulate jurisdiction; but no territorial legislation can give jurisdiction which any Foreign Court ought to recognise against foreigners who owe no allegiance or obedience to the power which so legislates.” Now can it be said that the same reason holds good when the foreigner is a native of British India, and the Court which passed the judgment in question was the Queen's Bench Division of the High Court of Justice in England? Though the Defendants here are foreigners they owe allegiance to the common sovereign of England and British India, and are subject to the supreme Legislative authority in the British Empire. It is true that India has a separate Legislature, and an Act of Parliament does not apply to India unless India is expressly included in its operation; but that is based upon convenience of legislation and not upon any want of authority in the Parliament to legislate for India. If, therefore, the Supreme Legislature in the British Empire authorises an English Court in any class of cases to exercise jurisdiction over anon-resident foreigner by reason of the cause of action arising within its jurisdiction (as is the case where Order XI, Rule 1 (e) under the Judicature Acts applies), and the foreigner is a native of British India, he cannot treat the judgment passed as a nullity, merely because he did not reside within the jurisdiction of the Court which passed it. The first contention of the Appellants must, therefore, in my opinion fail.

The second contention might upon the authorities, see Sreehuree v. Gopal Chunder(6), Edulji v. Manehji(7), Bangarusami v. Balasubramanian(8) and Rousillon v. Rousillon have succeeded, if it had been shown that the Defendants had no personal notice of the suit in the English Court. But upon the evidence I do not think that has been made out; and I agree with the Court below in holding that they had notice of the suit. The second contention therefore must also fail.

It remains now to consider the third contention of the Appellants. By sec. 13, Explanation VI of our Code of Civil Procedure the Foreign judgment produced is presumptive evidence that the Court which made it had competent jurisdiction, but the presumption may be removed by proving want of jurisdiction; and in my opinion that has been done so far as Defendant No. I is concerned. For the only basis of the jurisdiction of the English Court in this case was that under Order XI, Rule 1 (e), that is, by reason of the breach of contract upon which the suit was founded having occurred within the jurisdiction of that Court; and the evidence of Defendant No. 1 on this point, which stands unrebutted and which I see no reason to disbelieve, shews that he never entered into any contract with the Plaintiff and so there never could have been any breach of contract by him within the jurisdiction of the English Court. I may add that in saying this I am not going into the merits of the case but am only considering the evidence which it is open to the Defendants under Explanation VI of sec. 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure to adduce to shew that the Foreign Court had no jurisdiction to pass the judgment in question.

The case of Defendant No. 2, however, stands on a different footing. There is no evidence adduced on his behalf on this point, and the judgment of the English Court which is presumptive evidence in favour of that Court having jurisdiction, stands unrebutted in his case. The fourth contention in appeal, namely, that relating to interest, is, I think, well-founded. The foreign judgment on which the suit is based says nothing about interest; and neither Order XLII, Rule 16 nor Statute 1 and 2 Vict., c. 110, sec. 17 on which the claim for interest seems to be based, is applicable to India; nor does the case come within the scope of Act XXXII of 1839.

The result then is that this appeal will be allowed and the decree of the Court below set aside with costs as regards Defendant No. 1, but as regards Defendant No. 2, the appeal will be dismissed and the decree of the lower Court affirmed with costs, subject to the modification indicated above, namely, that the claim for interest is disallowed.

H.P.C
Appeal of Deft. No. 1 allowed.
Appeal of Deft. No. 2 dismissed.