- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bepin Behari Sarnokar v. Kalidas Chatterjee
The Plaintiff, the applicant before us, was an under-tenant of certain non-agricultural land. A decree was passed against the tenant, under whom he held for arrears of rent, and in satisfaction of that decree the judgment-debtors' interest in the property was sold at auction sale. The applicant bid at the sale, but was unsuccessful. He afterwards made a tender of the amount of the decree under sec. 310A of the Code of Civil Procedure, which tender was accepted. He sued the judgment-debtors in the Small Cause Court to recover the amount which he had so paid. The suit was dismissed in that Court on the ground that the case did not come under either sec. 69 or sec. 70 of Act IX of 1872. He applied to this Court for revision, a rule was issued, and the case is now before us for disposal.
We are disposed to agree with the learned Judge of the Small Cause Court, that the Plaintiff has not made out a case which would entitle him to a decree. It does not appear that any change would have been affected in his status by the auction sale, and we think that it would be difficult to say that after the sale in execution had been completed the amount which the applicant paid into Court was money which the judgment-debtor was “bound by law to pay.” The judgment-debtor was certainly not bound by law to make a payment under sec. 310A of the Code of Civil Procedure. The property had been sold, as we understand, for more than the amount of the decree and it seems to us to have been open to him to allow the amount of the decree to be paid from the sale-proceeds, if he chose to do so.
Again, it would seem, to say the least, extremely doubtful whether the applicant would have any status to pay in the amount of the decree under sec. 310A.
Our attention has been drawn by the learned pleader who appears for the applicant to cl. (g), sec. 108 of the Transfer of Property Act, which enacts that “if the lessor neglects to make any payment which he is bound to make, and which if not made by him, is recoverable from the lessee or against the property, the lessee may make such payment himself and deduct it with interest from the rent, or otherwise recover it from the lessor.” The same difficulty arises here as to whether the lessor, that is, the judgment-debtor, was bound to make the particular payment which the applicant made for him. It has been urged for the applicant that the lower Court, had not before it materials sufficient to enable it to come to a conclusion as to certain matters on which it has expressed an opinion, such as, the effect which the sale would have on the rights of the applicant, the benefit that would accrue to the judgment-debtor, &c. But if that be so, we must say that it was clearly for the applicant as Plaintiff in a suit of this kind to bring himself within some one of the provisions of the law under which he claimed. We think that he has not done this, and therefore that the suit was rightly dismissed.
The rule is discharged with costs, we assess the hearing fee at one gold mohur,
Rule discharged.
Alert