- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mahomed Abdul Mennan (Accused) v. Panduranga Row (Complainant) .
As against the petitioner, the first accused, the present complaint is exactly on the same facts as the previous complaints which were dismissed under section 203 of the Code of Criminal Procedure on the ground, that, primâ facie no criminal offence was disclosed. On revision the District Magistrate refused to interfere with the Magistrate's order and in our opinion that order was right. On the merits therefore we think that this complaint against the petitioner should not have been entertained, and we are further of opinion that, in law, the Magistrate was not competent to entertain it. We are unable to agree with the decision of the majority of the learned Judges of the Calcutta High Court in the case of Mir Ahwad Hussein v. Mahomed Askari(1) and we concur in the previous decisions of the same Court in Nilratan Sen v. Jogesh Chundra Bhuttacharjee(2) and Komal Chandra Pal v. Gour Chand Audhikari(3).
The Allahabad High Court and this Court have taken the same view (see Queen-Empress v. Adam Khan(4) and the rulings of the Court referred to in Weir's; Criminal Rulings pp. 874 and 875.).
The order of the Magistrate dated the 31st of May last directing that the trial be proceeded with on the now complaint is accordingly set aside so far as the petitioner, the first accused, therein is concerned, and the complaint as against him is dismissed.
Alert