- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Narasimha Chari v. Gopala Ayyangar
The finding of the lower Appellate Court is that the condition of the defendant's tenure was that he should perform an annual festival at a cost of Rs. 21. This was in accordance with an arrangement entered into in 1835 by the Jir then in office and which has been continued down to the present time without objection. We are of opinion that, as a matter of law, the Jir, who entered into this arrangement being a trustee, had no power to bind his successors in perpetuity, except on very special grounds which are not alleged in this case, and that it was open to a succeeding Jir to alter this arrangement. See the judgment of the Privy Council in the case reported in Mayandi Chettiar v. Chokkalingam Pillay(1) and the decision of this Court in Vidyapurna Tirtha Swami v. Vidyanidhi Thirtha Swami(2). The defendant, however, was in possession of the land on certain terms which had been acquiesced in by successive Jirs for a long period, and the plaintiff was bound to give him notice of the determination of his existing tenancy. The tender of the patta cannot be treated as notice since it was only tendered on June 26th, 1902, whereas the fasli for which the patta was tendered expired on June 30th of that year. We think the suit ought to have been dismissed upon the ground that no notice was given to the defendant of the change in the conditions of his tenure, and not on the ground taken by the learned Judge.
We dismiss the appeal on the ground that no notice was given. As the plaintiff was in default in not giving notice and the defendant was in default in setting up that he was the absolute owner of the land as to which the findings are against him, we direct that each party do bear his own costs throughout.
Alert