Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dulalram Deb 2Nd Party, v. Baishnab Charan Deb 1St Party, Opposite.

Calcutta High Court
Jan 16, 1906

This rule was issued on the Deputy Commissioner to show cause why the order passed by the Extra Assistant Commissioner on the 26th September 1905 under sec. 139, Cr. P.C, should not be set aside on the ground that the Extra Assistant Commissioner had no power to refer the matter to the jury for disposal until he had himself first determined the question whether the claim, if any, set forward by the Petitioner to the land in question was a bonâ fide claim of right or not.

It appears that the opposite party complained to the Assistant Commissioner that the Petitioner had obstructed a pathway which he alleged to be a public pathway and on that application the Magistrate passed an order under sec. 133, Cr. P.C, directing the Petitioner to remove the obstruction or to appear and show case.

The Petitioner appeared and stated that the pathway was not a public pathway and in his petition mentioned facts in support, of that allegation. The Magistrate without making any enquiry into the bonâ fides of the claim set up by the Petitioner as to the pathway being a private pathway, appointed a jury under sec. 138 to determine the question whether his order was a reasonable order or not, and what the jury appear to have decided when the matter was referred to them, was whether the pathway was a public pathway or not. The decisions of this Court which are reported in Luckhee Narain Banerjee v. Ram Kumar Mukherjee(1), Preo Nath Dey v. Gobordhon Malo(2) and Matuk Dhari Tewari v. Hari Madhab Das(3) distinctly lay down that, before any proceedings can be taken by the Magistrate under sec. 133 and before any reference can be made to a jury it is incumbent on the Magistrate himself when a claim for right is set up to determine whether that claim is a bonâ fide claim of right or not, and whether the road or pathway is a public pathway or not. It is not open to him to leave the decision of that question to the jury appointed under sec. 138 who are not a jury which hear evidence in the Court but are simply persons selected by the parties to determine in an informal way whether the order as passed by the Magistrate for the removal of the obstruction is or is not a reasonable order. In this case the Magistrate did not decide before referring the matter to a jury the question which he had to decide whether the pathway was a public pathway or not, and whether the claim set forward by the Petitioner was a bonâ fide claim of right or not.

Under those circumstances the order which he has passed based on the opinion of the jury that the pathway was a public pathway, was not a correct order, and we make the rule absolute and set aside that order.

B.C
Rule made absolute.