- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ram Khilawan And Another v. Emperor .
Banerji and Aikman, JJ.:— Ram Khilawan, caste Brahman, aged 25, and Mussammat Manki who is also a Brahman by caste and whose age the Sessions Judge estimates at 22, were sent up by the police charged with the murder of Mussammat Bundao, the mother-in-law of Mussammat Manki. The case came before Mr. Mushaffa Ahmad, Magistrate, first class, who on the 7th of July 1905, recorded what the Judge rightly characterises as a judgment of protentous length, and discharged both the accused. Indar Datt, the husband of the murdered woman applied to the Judge for revision of the order of discharge. This application was granted and the learned Judge under the provisions of section 436 of the Code of Criminal Procedure ordered both the accused to be arrested and committed to the Court for trial. We may remark that there can be no doubt that the Deputy Magistrate was wrong on the materials before him in taking it upon himself to discharge the accused. The trial resulted in the conviction of both the accused of the offence of murder and each has been sentenced to death. The learned Judge most unnecessarily, in our opinion, framed additional charges against the accused of offences under sections 193 and 201 of the Indian Penal Code. He has convicted both under the former section and sentenced each of them to three years' rigorous imprisonment. The ground of this conviction is that in the opinion of the learned Judge the acccused endeavoured to make it appear that the murder was committed at a place different from that at which it was perpetrated and thereby fabricated false evidence. In our opinion an accused person cannot be charged either with giving or fabricating false evidence with the sole object of diverting suspicion from himself and concealing his guilt in regard to a crime with which he is charged. We have no hesitation in quashing the conviction under section 193 of the Indian Penal Code and setting aside the sentences passed thereon.
Alert