- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ishri Prasad v. Baijnath And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
Daulat Ram, owner of property in the village of Daryapur, sold it on 6th August 1900 to Musammat Ram Bai, mother of the plaintiff Baijnath, and executed a sale-deed on that date. Despite this sale, Daulat Ram sold the same property again on 12th August 1900 to the defendant-appellant Ishri Prasad, who had his sale-deed registered on 13th August 1900. On the same day, the earlier sale-deed dated 6th August 1900 was presented for registration by Inayat-ullah, a pleader acting under a power of attorney from Musammat Ram Bai. However, the power of attorney was not executed or authenticated as required by section 33 of the Registration Act. The Sub-Registrar ignored this defect, summoned Daulat Ram, who admitted execution of the deed, and registered the document on 17th November 1900.
The dispute is between Baijnath, heir of Musammat Ram Bai (deceased), claiming title under the sale to his mother, and Ishri Prasad, who claims title under his duly registered sale deed of 13th August 1900. The lower courts held that the defect in the power of attorney was insufficient to invalidate the registration of the 6th August deed and decreed in favor of the plaintiff. The defendant appealed this decision.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the registration of the sale-deed dated 6th August 1900 was valid despite the power of attorney used to present it not being executed or authenticated as required by section 33 of the Registration Act.
- Whether the defect in the power of attorney amounted to a procedural defect curable under section 87 of the Registration Act or was a jurisdictional defect invalidating the registration.
- Whether the Sub-Registrar had jurisdiction to register the sale-deed when presented by an agent not duly authorized under the Act.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendant-Appellant's Arguments
- The sale-deed of 6th August 1900 was not properly registered because the power of attorney authorizing presentation was not executed or authenticated as mandated by section 33 of the Registration Act.
- Due presentation of the sale deed is a condition precedent to the Sub-Registrar's jurisdiction to register; since this was not fulfilled, the registration was invalid.
- The Sub-Registrar had no authority to register the deed as the agent presenting it lacked legal authority.
- Relied on the Privy Council ruling in Mujib-un-nissa v. Abditr Bahim, which held that registration without proper authority to present is illegal and void, not a mere procedural defect.
Plaintiff-Respondent's Arguments
- The defect in the power of attorney was merely procedural and cured by the attendance of Daulat Ram before the Sub-Registrar and his admission of execution of the deed.
- Section 87 of the Registration Act remedies defects in procedure, thus validating the registration despite the defective power of attorney.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mujib-un-nissa v. Abditr Bahim | Registration without proper authority to present a document is illegal and invalid; not a mere procedural defect under section 87 of the Registration Act. | The Court distinguished the facts but relied on the principle that only duly authorized agents can invoke the jurisdiction of the Registration officer, and registration without such authority is void. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined sections 32 and 33 of the Registration Act, which require that documents presented by an agent must be accompanied by a power of attorney executed and authenticated as prescribed by the Act, and that only such powers of attorney shall be recognized. It was admitted that the power of attorney held by Inayat-ullah was not executed or authenticated in the required manner.
The Court held that the jurisdiction of the Sub-Registrar to register a document depends on its due presentation by a properly authorized person. Since Inayat-ullah was not legally entitled to present the sale-deed, the Sub-Registrar lacked jurisdiction to register it, regardless of the vendor’s subsequent admission of execution.
The Court rejected the plaintiff's contention that the defect was merely procedural and curable under section 87, relying on the Privy Council’s ruling in Mujib-un-nissa v. Abditr Bahim, which clarified that the absence of any party legally entitled to present a deed is not a procedural defect but a jurisdictional bar.
Therefore, the registration of the sale-deed dated 6th August 1900 was invalid because it was not duly presented in accordance with the law, and the Sub-Registrar had no authority to register it.
Holding and Implications
The Court allowed the appeal, set aside the decrees of both the lower courts, and dismissed the plaintiff's claim with costs, including higher scale fees in this Court.
The direct effect of this decision is that the sale-deed dated 6th August 1900 is invalid for want of proper registration, and the plaintiff cannot claim title under it. No new precedent beyond the application of existing statutory provisions and binding precedent was established.
Stanley, C.J:— A question of registration law of some difficulty is involved in this appeal. One Daulat Ram who was the owner of certain property situate in the village of Daryapur, sold it to Musammat Ram Bai, the mother of the plaintiff, Baijnath, on the 6th of August, 1900, and executed on that date a sale-deed in her favour. Notwithstanding this sale, he, a few days later, namely, on the 12th of August, again sold the same property to the defendant-appellant, Ishri Prasad, and on the following day a sale-deed in favour of the defendant-appellant was duly registered. On the same day the sale-deed of the 6th of August, 1900, was presented for registration by one Inayat-ullah, a pleader, acting under a power of attorney from Musammat Ram Bai. He was accompanied on the occasion by the plaintiff. The power of attorney which Inayat-ullah held, was not executed or authenticated in the manner prescribed by section 33 of the Registration Act. This is admitted. The sub-Registrar took no notice of this defect and summoned the executant, Daulat Ram, and on his admission that the document was executed by him, registered it on the 17th of November, 1900.
2. The competition in this litigation is between Baij Nath, the heir of Musammat Ram Bai, who is dead, and Ishri Prasad. Baij Nath claims to be entitled to the property by virtue of the sale made in favour of his mother on the 6th of August, 1900, while Ishri Prasad contends that that document was not properly registered and that by virtue of his sale-deed of the 13th of August, 1900, which was admittedly duly registered on the same day he is entitled to the property.
3. Both the lower Courts held that the neglect of the requirements of section 33 in regard to the power of attorney was not sufficient to invalidate the registration of the sale-deed of the 6th of August and therefore decreed the plaintiff's claim. From this decision the present appeal has been preferred.
4. Section 32 of the Registration Act provides that except in the cases mentioned in sections 31 and 89 (neither of which sections are applicable to the present case,; every document to be registered under the Act whether such registration be compulsory or optional, shall be presented at the proper registration office, by some person executing or claiming under the same or by the representative or assign of such person, or by the agent of such person representative or assign duly authorised by power of attorney, executed and authenticated in the manner thereinafter mentioned. By the succeeding section it is enacted that for the purposes of section 32 the powers of attorney thereinafter mentioned shall alone be recognised, that is to say, if the principal at the time of executing the power of attorney resides in any part of British India in which the Act is for the time being in force, a power of attorney executed before and authenticated by the Registrar or Sub-Registrar within whose district or sub-district the principal resides. This provision of section 33 is admittedly applicable in the present case. Section 32 clearly prescribes in the case of a document presented at the Registration office for registration if presented by an agent that the agent shall be duly authorised by power of attorney, executed and authenticated, in the manner subsequently-prescribed, and section 33 directs that powers of attorney executed and authenticated, as required by the Act, “shall alone be recognised.” The language used is imperative. It is admitted as we have said that the power of attorney under which Inayat-ullah purported to act, was not executed or authenticated in the manner so prescribed. Therefore, on the part of the defendant-appellant, it has been strenuously contended that the due presentation of the sale deed in favour of Musammat Ram Bai for registration being a condition precedent to the exercise of his jurisdiction by the Sub-Registrar and that document not having been duly presented as required by the Act, the Sub-Registrar has no authority to register it; in other words that the jurisdiction of the Registration officer only arises when a document has been presented to him for registration in strict accordance with the provisions of the Act. On behalf of the plaintiff, Baijnath, this contention was repelled, and it was further contended that the defect in the presentation was cured by the attendance before the Sub-Registrar of Daulat Ram, the vendor, and the admission made by him of the execution of the deed of sale, and further that the defect was one of procedure merely and so is remedied by section 87.
5. The defendant-appellant relied upon a ruling of their Lordships of the Privy Council in the case of Mujib-un-nissa v. Abditr Bahim(1) as governing the case. In that case the executant of a document disposing of immoveable property, executed a power of attorney in favour of an agent authorising him to present it for registration but died before the presentation. The Sub-Registrar accepted and registered the document. It was held that this was not a mere defect in procedure falling under section 87 of the Registration Act (which provides that nothing done in good faith pursuant to the Act by any registering officer shall be deemed invalid merely by reason of any defect in his appointment or procedure), but that the registration was illegal and invalid. In the course of their judgment, their Lordships say “when the terms of section 32 are considered with due regard to the nature of registration of deeds, it is clear that the power and jurisdiction of the Registrar only come into play when he is invoked by some person having a direct relation to the deed. It is for those persons to consider whether they will or will not give to the deed the efficacy conferred by registration. The Registrar could not be held to exercise the jurisdiction conferred on him if hearing of the execution of a deed he got possession of it and registered it, and the same objection applies to his proceeding at the instigation of a third party who might be a busybody.” The facts of that case are distinguishable from those of the present case. In it the power of attorney had come to an end by the death of the executant of it. While in this case the executant of the power of attorney was alive when the presentation of the sale deed was made. This fact is strongly relied upon by Mr. Malaviya as differentiating the two cases. Their Lord ships in their judgment emphasise this fact. They say “In the interval between the execution of the completed deed and its presentation to the Registrar, the Munshi (i.e, the executant of the power of attorney) died. The legal question now to be considered turns on this last fact.” But their Lordships do not seem to us to have rested their decision upon this fact alone for they say in their judgment “It is perfectly plain not merely from the general law but from the terms of this section 82 itself that after the man's death the only attorney who would have any locus standi would have been the attorney of the representa tive or assign of the deceased.” They based their decision as well on the terms of section 32 as on the general law, and as we have pointed out, section 32 is clear and specific in its direction that where a document is presented for registration, by an agent, such gent shall be duly authorised by a power of attorney executed and attested in the manner prescribed by the Act and that only powers of attorney duly executed and authenticated as by the Act is prescribed shall be recognised. Inayat-ullah was not legally entitled to present the deed for registration as he did not hold such a power of attorney as could be recognised by the Registrar. He had no authority to invoke the power and jurisdiction of the Registration officer and the latter, we think, not being legally invoked, had no jurisdiction to entertain his application. The Statute has made presentation by a duly authorised agent the indispensible foundation of the juris diction of the registration officer if a document is presented for registration by an agent.
6. In answer to the argument that the error of the Sub-Registrar was a defect in procedure only, and in view of section 87 of the Act did not invalidate the act of registration, it is only necessary to refer to the comment of their Lordships in the case above mentioned upon two cases which were cited and relied upon by the appellants before them. “Neither case,” they say, “gives any countenance to the view that the absence of any party legally entitled to present a deed for registration is a defect in procedure falling under section 87.” Now Inayat-ullah was not legally entitled to present the deed for registration, and therefore the Registrar was not justified in accepting the deed for registration from him. The fact that the Sub-Registrar summoned Daulat Ram before him and obtained his consent to the registration of the deed, does not, we think, help the plaintiff-respondent, in as much as the Sub-Registrar had no authority whatever to carry out the registration, the document not having been duly presented to him for registration. His jurisdiction only comes into force if and when a document is presented to him in accordance with law. The principle which underlies the ruling of their Lordships in the case to which we have referred, seems to us to be applicable to this case.
7. For these reasons we allow the appeal, set aside the decrees of both the lower Courts and dismiss the plaintiff's claim with costs in all Courts, including fees in this Court on the higher scale.
J.B.LAppeal decreed.
Alert