- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Saurendra Mohan Tagore Judgment-Debtor, v. Hurruk Chand And Others Decree-Holders,
Woodroffe, J.:— Sec. 287, cl. (c) of the Civil Procedure Code requires that the sale-proclamation should state “every other thing which the Court considers material for the purchaser to know in order to judge of the nature and value of the property to be sold. Whether this clause requires that the value should be stated in all cases or not, the Court has, in the present instance, elected to state the value in the Bale-proclamation and has thus considered that element to be a material one. If in the opinion of the Court it is material, the value must be stated with approximate accuracy. For that purpose, it may be and in some cases it will be necessary for the Court to make an enquiry in order to ascertain what the value of the property really Is, and this will be necessary in such a case as the present one, where there is conflict between the value placed on the property by the judgment-creditor and that by the judgment-debtor. In the present Instance there is a very great discrepancy. The value as stated by the judgment-creditor is Rs. 15,000 and that put upon the property by the judgment-debtor is Rs. 1,50,000. It appears to me obvious that in order to ascertain which of these statements is true, some enquiry must be made by the Court settling the sale-proclamation. In the present proceedings, no such enquiry has been made. The learned Judge dealing with the question of value says this: “As for the value, I do not think at this stage I can ask the decree-holder to put such value on the property as the judgment-debtor may consider proper.” In other words, he accepts the value given by the decree-holder without enquiry, and refused an enquiry into the accuracy of the valuation given by the judgment-debtor. In this, I think, he was clearly wrong. Our attention has been drawn to the case of Kashi Pershad Singh v. Jamuna Pershad Sahu. If that case Intended to lay down what is stated in the head-note, I am unable to agree with it. However that may be, this decision is not in my opinion binding upon us. The passages relied upon are obiter dictum. The learned Judges in that case in dealing with the question of value say: “Id (the lower Court) has allowed only ten years' purchase, because the property is subject to the mortgage charge for the loan of Rs. 3,25,000 the principal of the debt, and for future interest on the Defendant. We consider that in the circumstances the Court could not have estimated the value at any higher rate.” That as a finding of fact concluded the appeal, and the observations of the learned Judges referred to were unnecessary.
For these reasons I consider that the appeal should be decreed and the case remitted to the Subordinate Judge with directions to make such enquiry as he may consider necessary for the purpose of ascertaining the approximate value of the property which is to be sold and such value should be stated in the sale-proclamation.
The costs of this appeal will abide the result—hearing fee, five gold mohurs.
Let the record the sent down as early as possible.
Holmwood, J.:— I would decree this appeal and remand the case to the Subordinate Judge for enquiry Into the approximate value of the property on the short ground that the discrepancy in the value as given by the decree-holder and that given by the judgment-debtor is so patent that it primâ facie necessitated an enquiry; when such a discrepancy appears on the face of the sale-proclamation, it is certainly the duty of the Court to as certain approximately the correct value for the benefit of the Intending purchasers. I do not understand that this Court in Kashi Pershad Singh v. Jamuna Pershid Sahu, intended to lay down that in no case should any enquiry be made before Issuing the sale-proclamation. In any case, as is pointed out by my learned brother, their observations on that point were not necessary for the decision of the case before them. It seems to me that the enquiry which has been ordered by the Subordinate Judge Into the existing incumbrances necessarily Involves an approximate finding as to the saleable value of the property; and I can, therefore, see no reason why the value should not be ascertained by the Subordinate Judge. I, therefore, agree in the order passed.
N.G
Appeal allowed.
Alert