- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Karumuru Venkateswami v. Lanka Tripuriah
1. This is a petition under Section 115 of the CPC, and Section 25 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, to revise the order of the District Munsif, awarding defendants Rs. 50 compensation for plaintiff having applied for and obtained an order attaching before judgment in Small Cause Suit No. 672 of 1912.
2. The order sought to be revised is an order under Section 95 of the CPC and is appealable under S. 104. I do not think that the fact that the order was passed in a small cause suit makes any difference; while admitting the petition the Honble Miller, J., made a note to the effect that he would be prepared to treat this petition as an appeal against the order.
3. Having regard to the fact that there has been a bona fide error I treat this petition as an appeal.
4. It is argued by the appellant that the District Munsif had no power to entertain the application for compensation, as there was only an interim order directing attachment pending notice; and Section 7, Clause (b) of the CPC provides that Ss. 94 and 95 are not applicable to Small Cause Courts in so far as they relate to injunctions and interlocutory orders. The contention is that where interim attachment is ordered pending the return of notice it is an interlocutory order within the meaning of S. 7, Cl. (b).
5. I am unable to accede to the contention that though a Small Cause Court is empowered to award compensation if it ordered an attachment before judgment after hearing both parties it cannot do so when it issues an interim attachment and dismisses it after the other side is heard. The words “injunctions and interlocutory orders” in S. 7, Cl. (b), can only refer to the orders contemplated in O. 39.
6. Rules 1 to 5 relate to “injunction” and Rr. 6 to 10 are under the heading “interlocutory orders.” The words “injunctions and interlocutory orders” in S. 7, should be read together and can only mean applications for an injunction and interlocutory orders on such applications.
7. There is nothing in the merits that calls for interference.
8. The petition fails and is dismissed with costs.
S.N/R.K
9. Appeal dismissed.
Alert