Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Wasudeo And Others v. Dayaram .

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Dec 10, 1914

1. The question for determination at this stage is, whether the memorandum of appeal is sufficiently stamped.

2. The appellants sued on the 19th July, 1910 to obtain foreclosure of a mortgage.

3. They joined as one of the defendants a co-mortgagee named Chinba, whom they alleged to have parted with his rights to their predecessors-in-title. That suit bears No. 176 on the file of the Additional District Judge, Nagpur, and is the one out of the which the present appeal arises.

4. Just 10 days earlier Chinba has instituted Suit No. 156 in the Additional District Judge's Court. He claimed on foot of the same mortgage as that which the appellants made the basis of their suit, but admitted their right to the extent of a half share and made them defendants as they refused to be co-plaintiffs with him.

5. A single trial was held in the two suits, but two decrees were drawn up. The Additional District Judge held that Chinba was still a co-mortgagee, his interest being one-half. A certain payment proved by the mortgagors was credited against the present appellants' share only, and the decree in each suit directed payment to the plaintiff therein of the sum found due to him.

6. The total sum payable on the mortgage up to the 30th October, 1914 was held to be Rs. 6,736-11-6. The decree in Suit No. 156 ordered payment of Rs. 4,409-13-0 to Chinba, while that in Suit No. 176 ordered the mortgagors to pay Rs. 2,326-14-6 to the appellants.

7. The object of this appeal is to obtain a decision that the entire sum payable under the mortgage belongs to the appellants, and that the said sum is Rs. 11,229-14-0, i.e, more by Rs. 8,902-15-6 than the Additional District Judge decreed to them.

8. In the memorandum the relief claimed in appeal is described as a declaration, but in argument the appellants' learned Counsel contended that the Court-fee should be calculated on the principal sum secured by the mortgage, namely, Rs. 2,000, Dhiraj Singh v. Rajaram (1910) 6 N.L.R 164 , 8 I.C 1125 is relied on, the argument being that a suit for foreclosure by a mortgagee the value for purposes of Court-fee is the same at all stages of the litigation, being that prescribed in Clause (9), Section 7 of the Court Fees Act. For the respondent Chinba reliance is placed upon Onkar v. Lakmichand (1909) 5 N.L.R 130 , 3 I.C 920 and Court-fee is said to be payable on the amount by which the appellants seek to have the mortgage-money increased, namely, Rs. 8,902-15-6.

9. We are very clearly of opinion that the respondent's contention is correct. We have ascertained from our brother Stanyon, who decided Dhiraj Singh v. Rajaram (1910) 6 N.L.R 164 , 8 I.C 1125, that he did not intend to lay down therein that Court-fee is payable on the principal sum secured even if the subject-matter of the dispute in appeal is merely the amount payable. On the contrary, he meant by the penultimate paragraph of the placitum to convey that where a mere enhancement or reduction of the mortgage-money is sought by the appellant, Court-fee must be paid ad valorem according to the sum so put in question. So far then as the matter before us is concerned, there is no difference between the view taken in Onkar v. Lakmichand (1909) 5 N.L.R 130 , 3 I.C 920 and that expressed obiter in Dhiraj Singh v. Rajaram (1910) 6 N.L.R 164 , 8 I.C 1125. We are in complete agreement with the ratio decidendi in the former case and would further observe that the obiter dictum with which the judgment of Edge, Chief Judge, in Pirbhu Narain Singh v. Sita Ram (1891) 13 All. 94 concludes supports the respondent's contention. In that case the mortgagor had sued for redemption, alleging the debt to have been completely satisfied and had appealed against the amount the Court of first instance had ordered him to pay. The learned Chief Justice said:—

“If on the other hand, the decree below had decreed redemption on payment of, say, Rs. 500 and the defendants-mortgagees were appealing on the ground that the amount due was Rs. 2,00,000. I am of opinion that the amount of Court-fee should be calculated on the difference between Rs. 500 and Rs. 2,00,000.”

10. In the case before us the appellants not only seek enhancement of the mortgage-money, but also to appropriate the entire sum to themselves. We see no difference in respect of the principle to be applied between a claim like this and one by the mortgagor to obtain reduction of the mortgage-money. The appellants must, therefore pay, an additional Court-fee of Rs. 425, the full fee payable ad valorem on Rs. 8,902-15-6 being Rs. 435 and Rs. 10 only having so far been paid. Time till the 15th January 1915 is allowed for payment and on that date as order regarding the hearing of the appeal on the merits will be passed.

P.N/R.K

11. Appeal dismissed.