Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Daolat v. Pandurang .

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Jan 30, 1920

1. This is an appeal from an order setting aside a sale at the instance of the receiver in Insolvency Case No. 110 of 1917. An application was made on 11th August 1917, by one of the creditors to have Punjaji Narayan adjudged an insolvent. The order of adjudication was passed on 10th December 1917. The sale which is sought to be set aside was effected on 16th June 1917. The vendee is the son-in-law of the insolvent. The insolvent has admitted that he conveyed the whole of his estate to his son-in-law by the sale deed. It has been found by the lower Court that the consideration for the sale was Rs. 12,000 made up as follows: Rs. 4,770 was paid to one Bajirao who had a mortgage over the property. Rs. 1,027 paid to the vendee as the amount due on a bond. Rs. 200 earnest money. About Rs. 6,000 paid before the registering officer. The lower Court has also held that the whole of Rs. 6,000 was applied by the insolvent in discharge of his debts. It is no longer contended that the sale was a nominal transaction or that the consideration was inadequate. The creditors say that the sale is void under Sections 36, and 37 of the Provincial Insolvency Act. As regards the applicability of S. 36 the question depends on whether or not the sale was made in good faith, for it is now conceded that there was valuable consideration. As regards S. 37, this can only refer to Rs. 1,027 paid to the purchaser on a bond for Rs. 1,000, dated 17th March 1917 which was not repayable till 28th November 1917. The purchaser has not gone into the witness box to show under what circumstances he came to purchase the whole of the immovable-property of his father-in-law who is an agriculturist nor has he stated that he did not know that his father-in-law was heavily indebted at the time. It is not pretended that there was any moveable property of any value still available to the creditors. The whole case rests upon the finding of the lower Court recorded in para. 6 of its judgment. It is to the following effect:

“The vendee is the son-in-law of the vendor and it is very unlikely that he should not have been aware of the financial position of the vendor.”

2. The fact that the purchaser has avoided the witness-box justified the conclusion of the learned Judge who has wide knowledge of the ways and habits of the people in this part of the country.

3. I am not prepared to differ from him on this point. Once this finding is accepted the conclusion of the lower Court is inevitable. The sale was practically of the whole of the debtor's property available to the creditors. The payment of the mortgage money was not under pressure of any impending sale or foreclosure and the money under his own bond was not due till five months afterwards. The balance was handed over to the insolvent and so far as the purchaser is concerned, he took no steps to see that it was applied in payment of other creditors. Where the effect of a conveyance of the whole of the debtor's property is to defeat and delay the creditors it is presumed that the debtor acted with intent to defeat and delay the creditors. Here the financial position of the debtor was known to his son-in-law. In making the purchase he cannot therefore be said to be acting in good faith. In Jukes, In re, Official Receiver, Ex parte [1902] 2 K.B 58 , 71 L.J K.B 710 , 86 L.T 456 , 50 W.R 560 , 9 Manson 249, Wright, J., says:

“I cannot help thinking that if a creditor of a debtor takes the whole, or substantially the whole, of the property of his debtor in payment of a past debt, and knowing that there are other creditors, he cannot be said to be acting in good faith.”

4. By parity of reasoning where a near relation of a debtor purchases the whole, or substantially the whole, of the property of a person in insolvent circumstances with notice of the insolvency he cannot be said to be acting in good faith. I have no doubt that the repayment of a debt, not yet due, by a person in insolvent circumstances is a case of undue preference shown to a near relation. The result is that the case having been correctly decided, the appeal is dismissed with costs. I fix Rs. 200 as pleader's fee to be divided equally between the two sets of respondents who have appeared by counsel in this Court.

P.N/R.K

5. Appeal dismissed.