Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Gopal v. Ram Krishna And Others

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Nov 15, 1920

1. Bapurao and Ramkrishna, two of the creditors of Nathu and his brother Ramchandra, filed a petition on the 19th July, 1917, praying that the latter be adjudged insolvents and that a sale-deed, dated the 26th April, 1917, of all their estates executed in favour of the appellant with a view to defeat the petitioning creditors be annulled and the property be put in charge of the Receiver in insolvency. Nathu and Ramchandra were adjudged insolvents on the 23rd October, 1917.

2. In the proceedings to annul the sale-deed the appellant pleaded that the consideration was duly paid, that the sale was effected bona fide for repayment of debts owed by the insolvents and that the insolvents had then been and still were in a position to pay their debts.

3. The following points were fixed for determination:β€”

1. Was the sale effected, bona fide and for the purposes alleged by the purchaser?

2. Was consideration duly paid?

3. Is the sale void as alleged by creditors?

4. The lower Court found that consideration was paid, that by the sale the insolvents transferred practically the whole of their estate, the only property left with them being a house worth Rs. 75, that the sale was not effected for the purpose alleged by the purchaser and that it was not a bona fide transaction. It annulled the sale.

5. In appeal aground was taken, but not seriously pressed, that the petition to annul the sale made out a case under Section 37 of the Provincial Insolvency Act, whereas the Court had treated it as if it made out a case under Section 36. The petition does not suggest that the transferee was a creditor and that the transfer was with a view to give him preference over other creditors.

6. It did not therefore put forward a case under Section 37.

7. It is then argued that the lower Court having found that the appellant had paid consideration, the sale ought to have been presumed to be bona fide, and the burden of proving the contrary lay on the creditors. This contention cannot be supported in view of the wording of Section 36. The section in a general way makes all transfers by insolvents within two years prior to adjudication void against the Receiver and liable to be annulled by the Court. It excepts from the operation of this rule, amongst others, transfers made in favour of purchasers in good, faith and for valuable consideration. Whoever therefore seeks to except his transfer from the operation of the rule must show that it comes under the description given in the exceptions. The appellant had therefore to show that the transfer to him was both for valuable consideration as well as in good faith: vide also The Official Assignee of Madras v. C. Sambanda Mudaliar (1920) 43 Mad. 739 , 60 I.C 205 , 39 M.L.J 245. The mere fact that valuable consideration has been paid for the transfer does not necessarily lead to an inference of good faith also: Daolat Rao v. Pandurang (1920) 55 I.C 57. It may be that in many cases the mere word of the transferee for consideration will in the absence of evidence to the contrary suffice to prove good faith. That however is not the case here. Not only has the purchaser when examined as a witness not expressly stated that he purchased innocently and without any intention to help the insolvent as against his creditors but there are a number of circumstances to which the lower Court has adverted which negative good faith on the appellant's part. The property transferred is substantially the whole of the insolvent's estate. The appellant in fact admits that it was only 2 or 3 days before the date of his deposition, the 24th April, 1918, that he came to know that the insolvents had a house which they had not sold to him. He says that at the time of the purchase he was told by the insolvents that they owed Rs. 2,500 to creditors other than the mortgagee whom he undertook to pay. The appellant knowing, as he must have known, that the vendors were insolvents and that he was purchasing the whole of their property it was his duty to have made inquiries as to the honesty of the vendors' intentions with reference to their creditors' interests. He admits he made no inquiry as to who were the creditors. He is not an agriculturist. He was a Pleader's clerk and is now a Dalai. Apparently he had no object in buying the property, for, he sold it off within eight months of his purchase. His reason for selling it is not that he made a profit thereby but that β€œit was not worth while having it.” These are circumstances which negative good faith.

8. The appeal is dismissed with costs. Pleader's fee Rs. 25. Respondent No. 5 Shriram Shaligram was not a party to the original proceedings and is discharged from the appeal with the appellant's consent. He will get his costs separately. Pleader's fee Rs. 15.

9. Appeal dismissed.