Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ajodhya Prasad v. Parashram

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Jul 10, 1929

1. This is an application for revision against the finding of the Additional District Judge, Damoh, on an issue framed in the suit with regard to a document tendered in evidence, its admissibility and the value of the stamp payable upon it. The document in question purports to be a deed of adoption executed by Motiram in favour of the applicant Ajodhya Prasad. It was written upon a stamp of Re. 1, but was produced before the Collector under Section 41 of the Stamp Act, and has been certified and endorsed by the Collector under S. 42 of the Act upon payment of R. 20 as duty.

2. The lower Court has held that the document, although purporting to be a deed of adoption is really a deed of gift as it transfers the whole of the executant's property in favour of the applicant Adjodhya Prasad, and has relied upon Bhagwan Prasad v. Hari Singh A.I.R 1925 Nag. 199 , 22 N.L.R 124.

3. The lower Court has then proceeded to hold that the document is inadmissible in evidence without a proper stamp and has declared the stamp duty to be Rs. 1,500 and the penalty Rs. 15,000 and has recorded a finding that the document is not admissible as-a deed of gift until the applicant, defendant 1 pays Rs. 16,500 as duty and penalty. The application for revision is against this finding.

4. Two points appear to have been overlooked by the Judge of the lower Court. The first is that the deed does not mention the value of the property and therefore according to In the matter of Muhammad Muzaffar Ali A.I.R 1922 All. 82 , 44 All. 339 (F.B) which was a decision upon a reference made by the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority under Section 57 of the Stamp Act, the deed does not require a stamp under the Act; the second point is that, as mentioned above the deed has been validated and certified by the Collector under S. 42 of the Act and is therefore admissible in evidence. The lower Court has brushed this fact aside by simply stating that the document has been stamped as an authority to adopt and not as a deed of gift. But whether the Collector made a mistake or not in the matter, I am of opinion that this decision is now binding and final and that it cannot be disturbed or set aside by the civil Court. In this connexion I have been referred by the learned counsel for the applicant to Tukaram v. Somaji [1911] 7 N.L.R 26 , 10 I.C 702. I am of opinion, then, that the finding of the lower Court is bad on both grounds and cannot be upheld. I therefore set aside the finding of the lower Court as regards the stamp duty leviable upon the document? and its admissibility in evidence, and instead record a finding that the deed must now be held to be sufficiently stamped and that it is admissible in evidence. Costs of this application will be payable by the non-applicant. I fix pleader's fees at Rs. 10 as the application was not opposed and was heard ex parte.

P.N/R.K

5. Revision allowed.