Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mannoolal Sonar v. Nandkishore Mishra And Others

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Jan 21, 1933

1. Chitroo, defendant 2, executed a sale-deed in favour of the plaintiffs two days, after Manoolal, defendant 1, had applied for attachment in execution of his decree. After the house was attached the plaintiffs filed an objection but were unsuccessful. Accordingly they filed this suit for a declaration of their title. The suit was dismissed by the trial Judge but has succeeded in appeal. In second appeal it has been urged that the burden of proof has been wrongly placed. Reliance is placed on Ghunsham v. Umaprasad AIR 1919 PC 6 , 15 NLR 68 , 50 IC 264 (PC). In that case their Lordships after mentioning that a mortgage-deed had been executed in a great hurry and with much secrecy, stated that the District Judge rightly threw on the plaintiff the onus of establishing that the transaction was entered in good faith. In V.E.A.R.M Firm v. Maung Ba Kyin AIR 1927 PC 237 , 5 Rang 852 , 105 IC 788 (PC) their Lordships also dealt with a suit instituted under O. 21, R. 63 of the CPC. They stated:

“Now they (i.e the plaintiffs) being the ostensible owners of the property under a duly registered deed and a deed of transfer, obviously the party claiming to attach that property for somebody else's debt, not their debt, but the debt of the original debtor, must show that the sale was a fraudulent one.”

2. In Mohammad Ali Mohammad Khan v. Mt. Bismillah Begam AIR 1930 PC 255 , 128 IC 647 (PC) their Lordships after mentioning the circumstances in which certain deeds were executed, stated:

“Under O. 21, R. 63, the decision in the said claim proceedings was final subject to the result of this suit which the plaintiff instituted for a declaration that the deeds are valid and that the said properties are not liable to be attached in execution of the decree of the appellant.

3. In their Lordships' opinion she is not entitled to this declaration unless she establishes to their satisfaction that the deeds in question were bona fide and were intended by defendant 2 to pass the beneficial interest in the premises in favour of the muttawali of the wakf and the plaintiff respectively.”

4. There is at first sight a little difficulty in reconciling the law laid down in Ghunsham Das v. Umaprasad AIR 1919 PC 6 , 15 NLR 68 , 50 IC 264 (PC) and Mohammad Ali Mohammad Khan v. Mt. Bismillah Begam AIR 1930 PC 255 , 128 IC 647 (PC) with that laid down in V.E.A.R.M Firm v. Maung Ba Kyin AIR 1927 PC 237 , 5 Rang 852 , 105 IC 788 (PC). But in my opinion their Lordships' remarks in each case were made by the reference to the circumstances of that case. Where the ostensible owner of property under a registered sale-deed institutes a suit under O. 21, R. 63 and facts are admitted which throw suspicion on the genuineness of the transaction the burden of proof lies on the plaintiff; but if no such facts are admitted the contrary is the case. In the case under appeal the learned Judge discussed much of the evidence before dealing with the burden of proof. He has believed the evidence that Rs. 50 was paid and the plaintiffs' evidence that a bond debt existed. He has found that the vendor left the house in which he was living soon after the execution of the deed. He has noted that the parties to the transaction were of different castes and there is no evidence to show that they were on very friendly relations. He has given a reason for the payment of the excessive price namely that the plaintiffs had no other means of recovering the sum due to them. It was then proper for the Court of first appeal after consideration of some of these circumstances to hold that it was for the defendants to prove bad faith and want of consideration. It may be that I should have come to a different conclusion on consideration of the evidence but I cannot interfere in second appeal: Chintumanrao v. Vithal AIR 1931 Nag 67 , 27 NLR 8 , 131 IC 662. The appeal therefore fails and is dismissed. Costs on appellant. Counsel's fee Rs. 30.

5. Appeal dismissed.