- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
(Ragireddi) Subba Rao v. (Ragireddi) Subba Rao And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
This suit concerns partition of a coconut garden (the "suit land") of about 6 acres 10 cents and recovery of a one-third share with mesne profits. Plaintiff 1 is the son of Plaintiff 2. Plaintiff 2, the late Narayanaswami (defendant 1's father), and defendant 2 were brothers and members of an undivided Hindu family. In December 1916 the three brothers effected a partition of a substantially larger family holding (described as nearly 60 to 100 acres). The properties falling to each branch were enjoyed thereafter.
The plaintiffs allege that at the 1916 partition the suit property was not divided but reserved for future division and that defendant 1 is wrongfully in possession and refuses to effect partition. Defendant 1's possession is said to be justified by a claim that his father received the suit land as jyeshtabagam at that partition. The plaintiffs contend that any allotment as jyeshtabagam is illegal under Hindu law and seek a decree directing division into three equal shares and delivery of one share to the plaintiffs.
The defence asserts that the 1916 partition was a family arrangement acted upon by all parties, that the suit property was allotted to defendant 1's father with the consent of plaintiff 2 and defendant 2, and that the plaintiffs cannot now impeach that allotment after a lapse of about 11 years. Evidence shows that the extra allotment to defendant 1's branch was not questioned until the suit; leases (including one dated 30th September 1920 executed in favour of defendant 1 during his minority) were entered into to the knowledge of plaintiff 2 and defendant 2 and attested by them.
Both lower courts found the plaintiffs' claim that the property was reserved for future division to be false and recorded documents indicating the allotment was recited as jyeshtabagam. The lower courts nevertheless held that since allotment as jyeshtabagam is illegal under Hindu law, plaintiff 1 was entitled to recover one-sixth share (with plaintiff 2 and defendant 2 estopped by their earlier assent). The present opinion arises in a second appeal from those decrees.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the allotment of the suit land (6 acres 10 cents) as jyeshtabagam to defendant 1's father rendered the 1916 partition fraudulent or unfair so as to permit plaintiffs to impeach that partition.
- Whether a father, as representative of his branch, is competent to consent to and bind his minor sons by a family partition (including an extra allotment to his branch) absent proof of fraud or prejudice to the minors' interests.
- Whether an allotment described as jyeshtabagam (or an extra allotment to one branch) is illegal per se under Hindu law and hence voidable by the minors or other members of the family after an extended acquiescence.
- Whether plaintiff 1 (who was a minor at the time of the partition) can, in the form of the present suit, recover a separate share without seeking to set aside the partition as prejudicial to himself.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiffs' Arguments
- The suit land was not divided at the 1916 partition but reserved for future distribution; defendant 1 is in wrongful possession and refuses partition.
- The suit property had been allotted as jyeshtabagam to defendant 1's father and such an allotment is illegal under Hindu law; therefore the plaintiffs are entitled to impeach that allotment and seek division into three equal shares and possession of one share.
Defendants' Arguments
- The partition of December 1916 was a family arrangement acted upon by all parties and the suit property was allotted to defendant 1's father with the consent of plaintiff 2 and defendant 2; it is not open to the plaintiffs to impeach it after about 11 years of acquiescence.
- Evidence of continued recognition of the allotment includes leases executed in favour of defendant 1 (including Ex. 9 dated 30th September 1920 during his minority) and later leases attested by plaintiff 2 and defendant 2.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| 1933 All 1381 | Establishes that a father is entitled and competent to represent his sons in a partition with his brothers; a partition effected by him will bind his sons unless shown to be fraudulent, unfair or prejudicial to their interests. | The court relied on this authority to support the proposition that the father could represent his branch at the 1916 partition and bind his minor sons unless fraud or prejudice were demonstrated. |
| 35 All 3372 (Privy Council) | Affirmed that where a bona fide family arrangement (including a father’s disposition by will) is accepted and acted upon, the acceptance binds the parties and their branches; the principle applied to partitions effected bona fide by the father as representative of his branch. | The court applied the Privy Council's reasoning by analogy: if a bona fide partition effected by the father was acted upon, it will be upheld and bind the sons; thus an extra allotment to a branch, if bona fide, may not be impeached by the sons. |
| 39 MLJ 3823 | Relied upon for the proposition that allotment of property as jyeshtabagam is illegal under Hindu law (an asserted position by counsel). | The court acknowledged the authority but qualified that while allotment as jyeshtabagam is obsolete and not enforceable, an agreed extra allotment bona fide made and acted upon by the family might nonetheless be binding. |
| 8 MLW 4004 (and relatedly 8 MLW 400) | Held (in a mother-as-representative case) that an allotment of an extra share to an eldest member was not binding on minor sons where the mother represented them; the transaction may be regarded as a gift and the mother lacked a representative power equivalent to a father's. | The court distinguished that authority: where a mother represented minors she lacked representative power; by contrast the father has a different, stronger representative position. Thus the mother-case did not control where the father had represented his branch. |
| Mullah's Hindu Law, Edn. 8, p. 391 | Textual authority explaining the principle that the Privy Council's reasoning supports situations where a bona fide partition is effected by a father as representative of his branch. | The court cited this doctrinal source to reinforce that the principle sustaining a father's bona fide partition extends beyond will-partitions to other bona fide family arrangements. |
| 30 Cal 7385 at 752 | Authority for the proposition that if a partition is unfair or prejudicial to a minor's interests, the minor may, on attaining majority, by proper proceedings set it aside so far as regards himself. | The court used this precedent to note that the minor (plaintiff 1) had a specific remedy upon attaining majority, but observed that plaintiff 1 had not pursued such a remedy and instead joined with his father in a suit seeking recovery on behalf of the entire family. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded along these analytical steps, based strictly on the findings and materials in the opinion:
- Found as a factual matter (consistent with lower courts) that the claim the suit property was reserved for future division was false and that partition documents expressly recited that the suit land was allotted as jyeshtabagam to defendant 1's father.
- Observed that the family possessed a much larger estate (about 60 to 100 acres) and that the partition otherwise effected an equal division among the three branches, with the suit property constituting an extra allotment to defendant 1's branch. The practical effect of the extra allotment was to deprive plaintiffs' branch of about 2 acres 5 cents (of which plaintiff 1 would be entitled to half).
- Addressed whether the allotment made the partition fraudulent or unfair. The court accepted the legal proposition that a father is competent to represent his sons at a partition and that a partition effected by him will bind his sons unless it was fraudulent, unfair or prejudicial to their interests (relying on the cited authorities).
- Noted strong evidence of long acquiescence by the family: the extra allotment was not questioned for about 11 years; leases (including Ex. 9 dated 30th September 1920 entered during defendant 1’s minority) were executed to defendant 1's benefit with the knowledge and attestation of plaintiff 2 and defendant 2. The court inferred there must have been some consideration or basis for the family's consent even though the specific claim of meritorious service was not proved.
- Considered authorities asserting that allotment as jyeshtabagam is obsolete/illegal and recognised that while such allotments may not be enforceable as jyeshtabagam, an extra allotment agreed honestly and acted upon by adult family members may not be treated as an invalid gift or alienation that can be impeached by minors who were represented by their father.
- Distinguished precedents where a mother represented minors (in which instances an extra allotment was held not binding on minors) by explaining that the father's representative role is legally different and stronger: the father is entitled to represent his sons and bind them by partition-consent, whereas the mother acts merely as a natural guardian without power to consent to transactions depriving minors of property.
- Noted the specific procedural point that plaintiff 1 (a minor at the time of partition) had not, on attaining majority, sought to set aside the partition as prejudicial to himself alone; instead the present suit sought recovery on behalf of the whole family. The court explained that a different remedy (re-opening the entire partition and seeking appropriate re-adjustment) would have been available had plaintiff 1 sued on his own behalf to set aside the partition as prejudicial to him.
- Concluded that because the partition was otherwise fair and there was no proof of fraud or unfairness beyond the extra allotment, and because of long acquiescence and conduct of family members, the plaintiffs were not entitled to impeach the allotment in the manner pursued in this suit.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appellate court reversed the decrees of the lower courts and dismissed the plaintiffs' suit. The opinion concludes: "Decrees reversed."
Direct consequences for the parties:
- The plaintiffs' suit for partition and recovery of a one-third share of the suit land is dismissed.
- The decrees of the lower courts (which had given plaintiff 1 a one-sixth share and treated plaintiff 2 and defendant 2 as estopped) are reversed.
- The appellate court awarded costs of the appeal to the respondents (the successful parties in the second appeal) and directed that each party bear their own costs in the lower courts.
The opinion does not undertake an extended discussion of broader legal consequences beyond applying established authorities to the facts of this case; it does not purport to establish a novel legal principle. It emphasizes that a father’s bona fide representation and family acquiescence can preclude later impeachment of an extra allotment, and that a minor wronged by such a partition has a distinct remedy on attaining majority which was not pursued here.
1. This is a suit for partition of the suit land of about 6 acres 10 cents in extent and recovery of one-third share therein with mesne profits. Plaintiff 1 is the son of plaintiff 2. Plaintiff 2, defendant 1's father, the late Narayanaswami and defendant 2 were brothers and formed members of an undivided Hindu family. The family was in possession of considerable property. In December 1916 the brothers effected a partition and the properties which fell to each were being enjoyed by the respective branches ever since the said date. It is alleged in the plaint that at the said partition the suit land which is a cocoanut garden was not divided but was reserved for future partition, that defendant 1 is in possession of the same wrongfully, refusing to effect a partition and delivery of the same on the ground that his father got the same as and for his jyeshtabagam at the partition between his brothers, and that the allotment of any property which has been given to defendant 1's father as jyeshtabagam is illegal under the Hindu law and the plaintiffs are therefore entitled to impeach the same. They accordingly prayed that a decree may be passed directing the division into three equal shares of the jirayatl cocoanut garden situate in Mondepulanka village as per the A marked schedule filed herewith, regarding the same as the joint family property of the plaintiffs, and defendants I and 2 and directing that one share thereof be put in possession of the plaintiffs.
2. The defence was that the partition between the brothers was a family arrangement and was acted upon by all the parties, and that the suit property was allotted to defendant 1's father at the partition with the consent of plaintiff 2 and defendant 2, and it is not open to them now to impeach the same after the lapse of 11 years. It is clear from the evidence that the family at the time of the partition between the three brothers was possessed of nearly 60 to 100 acres of immoveable property, and that there was equal division of all the properties into three shares except with regard to the suit property which was given to defendant 1's branch in addition. It is also clear that this extra allotment to defendant 1 was never questioned by the family up to the date of suit. In fact after the death of defendant l's father in 1917 there were leases executed in favour of defendant 1 to the knowledge of plaintiff 2 and defendant 2, and Ex. 9 dated 30th September 1920 was a lease in respect of the suit property executed in favour of defendant 1 during his minority after the death of his father, and it was brought about by plaintiff 2 and defendant 2. Exs. 2 and 5 are leases after defendant 1 attained majority and they were attested by plaintiff 2 and defendant 2.
3. It is also concurrently found by both the lower Courts that the case set up by the plaintiffs, that the property was reserved for future division, was false, and that in the said documents there are clear recitals to the effect that the suit property was allotted to defendant 1's father as jyeshtabagam. But both the lower Courts however held that as the allotment of any property towards jyeshtabagam is illegal under the Hindu law, plaintiff 1 is entitled to recover one sixth share of the suit property though plaintiff 2 and defendant 2 will be estopped from recovering any portion thereof by reason of their assent at the time of the partition.
4. It is now contended before me in second appeal by Mr. Lakshmanna that the view taken by the lower Courts is not sound. There can be no doubt that a father is entitled to and competent to represent his sons in a partition with his brothers and a partition effected by him will be binding on the sons unless it is shown that it was fraudulent or unfair or prejudicial to their interests. The fact that some of the members are minors would not prevent the father in virtue of his position as the head of his branch to represent them: vide 1933 All 1381. There is absolutely no proof that the partition effected between the three brothers was in any way unfair or fraudulent, save in so far as this suit property was allotted to defendant 1's father. The question, therefore, is whether this allotment of 6 acres 10 cents is such as to render the partitions fraudulent or unfair. The family was possessed of nearly 60 to 100 acres. The result of giving the suit property to defendant 1's father will be to deprive the plaintiff's branch of about 2 acres 5 cents and plaintiff 1 can be said to have been deprived of half of it. It seems to me that if the partition is otherwise fair, it is open to the father as representative of his branch to consent to this extra, allotment and if it was done bona fide it will not be open to his sons to impeach the same. In 35 All 3372, a father by means of a will purported to divide the family property between his three sons and awarded a double share to the eldest son and one-fourth share to each of the remaining sons, himself taking no share. The arrangement was acted upon for sometime and thereafter it was sought to be impeached on the ground that the father had no right to effect a partition of the joint family property by means of a will and that the allotment of a double share to the eldest son was invalid. But the Lordships negatived both the contentions and upheld the arrangement. Lord Moulton, in the course of his judgment, observed as follows at p. 346:
Bat the property was ancestral and therefore Rao Balwant Singh, although head of the family, had no right to make a partition by will of that property among the various members of the family except with their consent. They had independent rights in it with which he could not interfere. The main question therefore is whether there is evidence sufficient to establish the consent of the plaintiff Rao Karan Singh and Kunwar Sheodin Singh to this family arrangement. If they accepted it, their acceptance would bind not only them but also their sons, who are the remaining plaintiffs, as they would be representing in the transaction their respective branches of the family.
5. No doubt the question prominently before the Privy Council was in regard to the right of the father to effect a partition by a will, but the principle upon which the arrangement is upheld will apply to every case where a bona fide partition has been effected by the father as representative of his branch (vide Mullah's Hindu Law, Edn. 8, p. 391). Mr. Somasundaram relied very strongly on two decisions of our High Coart, namely 39 MLJ 3823 and 8 MLW 4004, for the position that the allotment of jyeshtabagam is illegal under the Hindu law. It is true that the allotment of any property as jyeshtabagam has become obsolete and the Court would not enforce it. But if the members of a joint family agree in effecting a partition to give some extra property to their eldest members or even to one of them bona fide, such an arrangement cannot be considered to be illegal on the ground that a certain property was allotted as for jyeshtabagam or was given in excess of his legitimate share. It is contended it would be virtually an alienation by the father without any necessity and would be tantamount to a gift and therefore not binding on his sons. But in my opinion if is not accurate to regard partition as an alienation.
6. No doubt in 8 MLW 400, where a mother represented her minor sons at a partition, the allotment of an extra share to the eldest member of the family was held not binding on the minor sons and it was held that the transaction may well be regarded as a gift. But in that case the minor himself was the representative of his branch and the mother was representing him as the natural guardian at the partition. As observed in 8 MLW 400, the mother has no right of representation in respect of the family property. The position of the father is entirely different. The father is the only person entitled to represent his sons at a family partition, and it is only through the father that the sons take their share in the joint family property, whereas the position of the mother is only that of a natural guardian and her powers can only be adjudged in that capacity and a guardian has no power to consent on behalf of the minor to any act which would deprive him of any portion of his property. In this case there is no evidence to show under what circumstances this extra allotment was made to defendant 1's father who died about 10 years ago. Both plaintiff 2 and defendant 2 are acting in violation of the arrangement which they have entered into. One must presume there must have been some consideration which prompted the adult members of the family to agree to the extra share being given to defendant 1's branch though no doubt the specific case that it was given to defendant 1's father for meritorious service done to the family has not been proved. In the face of evidence of the conduct of the family for over a period of 11 years, it does not lie in the mouth of the plaintiffs to impeach this transaction. As has been already stated the fact that there are minor members of the family is no bar to the partition being effected and much more so when there is the father to represent his minor sons. As observed by the Privy Council, if the partition was unfair or prejudicial to the minor's interests he might on attaining majority by proper proceedings set it aside so far as regards himself: 30 Cal 7385 at 752.
7. But that is not what is sought to be done in this case. Plaintiff 1 who was a minor at the time of the partition is not seeking to set aside the partition as regards himself, but both the father and the son are trying to recover this property on behalf of the entire family. If plaintiff 1 was aggrieved by the partition effected by the father he ought to have filed a suit asking that the entire partition may be re-opened on the ground that it has prejudicially affected him making his father also defendant and claiming one-sixth share for himself. In such a case it would have been open to the Court to so adjust the division by allowing one-sixth share to the plaintiff and making the extra allotment divisible among the second plaintiff and the first and second defendant branch. But it is not possible to do so owing to the manner in which the plaintiffs have framed their case. The lower Courts were not warranted in making a distinction between plaintiff 1 and plaintiff 2's case. Plaintiff 1 does not impeach the partition as unfair or prejudicial to him and he does not seek to recover any share so far as regards himself, and it is not open to the lower Court to make any declaration separately in his favour. I therefore reverse the decrees of the lower Courts and dismiss the plaintiff's suit with costs of this appeal. I direct each party to bear his own costs in the lower Courts.
C.R.K/B.D
8. Decrees reversed.
Alert