- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Nibaran Chandra Ghose v. Pratap Chandra Chaudhuri
Factual and Procedural Background
The suit concerns the silted-up bed of a tank (a Noabad Jote) held under Government by the Roy Babus of Noapara. The land was sold for arrears of rent under the certificate procedure on 25 May 1930 and purchased by the pro formâ Defendant No. 53. On 11 February 1931 that purchaser sold the jote to the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff sued the Defendants for ejectment, alleging they were trespassers or that any rights they had were annulled by a notice served under section 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act.
Seven Defendants (grouped as Defendants Nos. 1, 2 and 4; No. 15; and Nos. 16, 22 and 23) appealed against decrees in favour of the Plaintiff rendered by the trial Court and upheld by the lower Appellate Court. The Defendants claimed to be under-tenants (under-raiyats) whose interests constituted incumbrances under section 161 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, and they alleged that no valid notice under section 167 had been served to annul those incumbrances. Both lower courts had decreed for the Plaintiff; the appellate judgment accepted the under-raiyat status but held that section 85(1) of the Bengal Tenancy Act rendered that under-raiyati not an incumbrance and also concluded the notices were not served within time. The Defendants appealed to the present Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Are the Defendants under-raiyats (i.e., under-tenants) as recorded in the settlement record?
- If the Defendants are under-raiyats, does their interest amount to an "incumbrance" within the meaning of section 161 of the Bengal Tenancy Act?
- Was any incumbrance constituted by the Defendants' interest validly annulled by service of notice under section 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act (in particular, was the notice applied for/served within the time limit prescribed)?
- Does section 85(1) of the Bengal Tenancy Act (as relied on by the lower Appellate Court) affect the validity of the under-raiyati interest as an incumbrance?
- Is the appeal abated by the death of one appellant (Pran Krishna Ghose) whose heirs were not substituted?
- Whether a remand is required to determine with specificity whether the Defendants are under-raiyats or merely trespassers, when the lower Appellate Court's findings were said to be insufficiently definite.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' (Defendants') Arguments
- The Defendants asserted they were not trespassers but under-tenants (under-raiyats) under the raiyati jote; their interests therefore constituted an "incumbrance" within the meaning of section 161 of the Bengal Tenancy Act.
- Such incumbrances could be annulled only by a notice served in accordance with the procedure in section 167; no valid notice had been served upon them, or alternatively any notice served was beyond the time limit prescribed by section 167.
- The Defendants relied on the Kevisional Survey (1930) / record-of-rights entries showing Groups I and III as under-raiyats and Group II (Defendant No. 15) as an under-raiyat of the second grade.
Respondent's (Plaintiff's) Arguments
- The Plaintiff (through Mr. Sen) raised a preliminary objection that the appeal was not maintainable because one appellant (Pran Krishna Ghose) died pending the appeal and his heirs were not substituted, arguing the appeal had abated.
- The Plaintiff contended the lower Subordinate Judge should not have gone into the question of the validity/timeliness of the section 167 notice because that question was not considered by the trial Court and the Defendants had not challenged the validity of the notice in the issues originally framed.
- Regarding Defendant No. 15, the Plaintiff argued that an under-raiyat of the second grade (i.e., an under-raiyat under another under-raiyat) did not amount to an incumbrance within the meaning of section 161 of the Bengal Tenancy Act.
- The Plaintiff further argued the Defendants were trespassers and that the record-of-rights was incorrect, contending the lower Appellate Court had decided on hypothetical facts and that a remand should be ordered for definitive factual findings on whether the Defendants were under-raiyats or trespassers.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Satulal Bhattacharjee v. Asiraddi Sheikh | Permissibility of passing a decree in favour of existing appellants notwithstanding the death of another appellant whose heirs have not been substituted. | The Court relied on this authority to reject the Plaintiff's preliminary objection that the appeal had abated because one appellant died; the Court concluded a decree could be passed for those appellants still before the Court. |
| Janaki Nath Hore v. Prabhasini Dasee | Support for the proposition that a sub-lease (unregistered and without landlord's consent) may be valid as between sub-lessor and sub-lessee vis-à-vis a third-party purchaser of the lessor's interest. | The Court invoked this case to hold that the under-raiyati interest (though an unregistered sub-lease) is valid against a third-party purchaser of the raiyat's interest, and therefore can constitute an incumbrance under section 161. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in a structured manner:
- Preliminary objection on abatement: The Court rejected the Plaintiff's contention that the appeal abated due to the death of one appellant (Pran Krishna Ghose). Relying on Satulal Bhattacharjee v. Asiraddi Sheikh, the Court held that a decree could be passed in favour of the appellants who remained before the Court because if any one Defendant established tenancy, the Plaintiff's suit for khas possession would fail as to all.
- Status of section 85(1): The Court found the lower Appellate Judge's reliance on section 85(1) of the Bengal Tenancy Act to be erroneous. It held that section 85(1) had been repealed in 1929 and was therefore not in force at the time of suit; further, even if it were in force, the provision would not affect the Appellants' position because an unregistered sub-lease without landlord's consent may be invalid against the landlord but remains binding as between lessor and sub-lessee and as against a third-party purchaser of the lessor's interest. The Court cited Janaki Nath Hore v. Prabhasini Dasee in support.
- Whether the Defendants' interests constitute an incumbrance under section 161: The Court concluded that if the Defendants are under-raiyats, their interests amounted to an incumbrance within the meaning of section 161, and such incumbrances can only be annulled by notices served in accordance with section 167.
- Validity and timeliness of notice under section 167: The Court analyzed the timing rule in section 167 and held that the time for applying for service of notice runs from either (a) the date of confirmation of the certificate sale or (b) the date on which the purchaser at such sale had notice of the incumbrance. The trial Court had incorrectly measured the period from the date of the Plaintiff's purchase from the original purchaser; that is not the correct starting point. The lower Appellate Court and Subordinate Judge had concluded the application for notice was made too late; the present Court agreed with the Subordinate Judge that the notice was invalid for being out of time.
- Procedural considerations as to remand: The Plaintiff's counsel (Mr. Sen) argued that the notice-validity question had not been considered at trial and that the matter should be remanded. The Court rejected this because the point had been raised in the written statement and had, in fact, been considered by the trial Court (issue No. 7 in the trial Court expressly addressed whether notices under section 167 were duly served). Therefore no remand was necessary.
- Whether Defendant No. 15's status avoids incumbrance classification: The Plaintiff argued that an under-raiyat of the second grade (Defendant No. 15) did not constitute an incumbrance under section 161. The Court rejected this as self-defeating, observing that if Defendant No. 15 is an under-raiyat of the second grade, he cannot be ejected unless the under-raiyati above him has been annulled, and there was no evidence of such annulment.
- Factual status of the Defendants (remand request): The Plaintiff contended the record-of-rights was incorrect and that the lower Appellate Court had not made definitive factual findings as to whether the Defendants were under-raiyats or trespassers. The Court declined a remand, finding the settlement record supported the under-raiyat entries (Groups I and III as under-raiyats and Group II as under-raiyat of the second grade), the lower courts had accepted those entries, and there was no clear evidence in the record that the Defendants were original trespassers.
- Title declaration: The Plaintiff's claim for declaration of title had not been challenged and the Court declared the Plaintiff's title.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court held that the Defendants' interests were incumbrances within the meaning of section 161 of the Bengal Tenancy Act and that those incumbrances had not been validly annulled because the notices under section 167 were invalid (the application for service was not made within the statutory time). Consequently, the decree below was modified and the Plaintiff's suit insofar as it relates to ejectment was dismissed with costs. The Appellants were awarded the costs of the appeal. The Plaintiff's declaration of title was, however, recorded in the judgment.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The Plaintiff retains a judicial declaration of title to the suit land, but cannot obtain ejectment of the Defendants because their under-raiyati interests remain as unannulled incumbrances (the notices purporting to annul them were invalid for being out of time). The ejectment decree is therefore set aside insofar as it sought possession against these Defendants.
- Procedural consequence: The appeal was held maintainable notwithstanding the death of one appellant whose heirs were not substituted; the remaining appellants could obtain relief.
- Broader precedent: The opinion did not state that it was setting a new general precedent; it applied existing statutory interpretation (sections 161 and 167) and authority (including Janaki Nath Hore and Satulal Bhattacharjee) to the facts of this case. No broader rule beyond the Court's application to these facts was articulated in the text of the opinion.
P.C
The Judgment of the Court was as following:—
This appeal is by seven Defendants who may conveniently be divided into three groups. The first group consists of the Defendants Nos. 1, 2 and 4, the second group of the Defendant No. 15 and the third group of the Defendants. Nos. 16, 22 and 23. The subject matter of this suit is the silted up bed of a tank. This land was held under the Government by the Roy Babus of Noapara as a Noabad Jote. It was sold for arrears of rent under the certificate procedure on the 25th May, 1930, and was purchased by the pro formà Defendant No. 53. On the 11th February, 1931, the pro formà Defendant No. 53 sold the jote to the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff then sued the Defendants for ejectment alleging that they were trespassers who had not come on the land under any right. The Plaintiff also alleged that if the Defendants had any right in the land, that right had been annulled by a notice served on them in accordance with the provisions of sec. 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act.
The case of the Defendants is that they were not trespassers, that they were under-tenants under the raiyati Jote, and that, therefore, their interest constituted an incumbrance within the meaning of sec. 161 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. They alleged further that this incumbrance would only be annulled by a notice served in accordance with the procedure laid down in sec. 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. They contended that no notice was served upon them and, further that if it be held that a notice had been served upon them that notice was served beyond the time laid down in sec. 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. They relied on the record of the Kevisional Survey of 1930. In this record the first and the third group of Defendants are shown as under-raiyats and the second group of Defendants is shown as an under-raiyat of the second grade, that is to say, an under-raiyat holding under another under-raiyat. Both the Courts have decreed the Plaintiff's suit. The lower Appellate Court has acted on the footing that the Defendants are under-raiyats, but he says that this under-raiyati did not constitute an incumbrance by reason of the provisions of sec. 85(1) of the Bengal Tenancy Act, and that, therefore, it did not require to be annulled. As regards the notices, the learned Judge has found that they had not been served within time. On these findings he has upheld the decree of the trial Court. The Defendants have appealed.
A preliminary objection has been taken on behalf of the Plaintiff to the maintainability of the appeal. It is pointed out that the Appellant No. 3, Pran Krishna Ghose, died pending the appeal and that his legal representatives have not been substituted in his place. It is pointed out that the appeal as against the heirs of Pran Krishna has abated and that the whole appeal should be considered as having abated inasmuch as a decree cannot be passed in favour of the other Appellants in the absence of the heirs of Pran Krishna. In my opinion there is no substance in this preliminary objection. The Appellants claim to be tenants and they are resisting the Plaintiff's suit for possession on the footing that they are tenants. As has been pointed out by Mr. Gupta appearing on behalf of the Appellants, if any one of the Defendants succeed in establishing that he is a tenant, the Plaintiff's suit for khas possession must necessarily fail. It does not matter therefore, if some of the Defendants are not before the Court, In this connection I would refer to the case, Satulal Bhattacharjee v. Asiraddi Sheikh . In my opinion there would be no difficulty in passing a decree in favour of the Appellants who are now before this Court by reason of the fact that one of the Appellants has died and his heirs have not been brought on the record.
I now proceed to consider the appeal. I shall first deal with the appeal on the footing that the Appellants are under-raiyats. This is the basis on which the lower Appellate Court has dealt with the case. I shall then consider whether if the Appellants are under-raiyats, the Plaintiff is entitled to eject them. In my opinion the reasoning of the learned Subordinate Judge regarding the applicability of sec. 85(1) of the Bengal Tenancy Act is entirely wrong. In the first place sec. 85(1) of the Bengal Tenancy Act was repealed in the year 1929 and, therefore, it was not in existence at the time of the institution of the suit and can have no application. Secondly, if it was in existence it does not affect the position of the Appellants at all. That section runs as follows:—
“If a lessee subleases otherwise than by a registered instrument the sub-lease shall not be valid against his landlord unless made with the landlord's consent”
In the present case, it has been established that the sub-lease of the Appellants was not by a registered instrument and there is no evidence of the landlord's consent. This sub-lease will, therefore not be valid as against the landlord of the lessor, that is to say, as against the Government, but it would be perfectly valid as against the lessor, i.e, the raiyat. In the present case, the purchaser of the raiyati interest is not the landlord of the raiyat, but is a third party. The under-raiyati, therefore is perfectly valid as against him. This is the view which has been held in the case of Janaki Nath Hore v. Prabhasini Dasee . If therefore, the Appellants are under-raiyats, their interest amounted to an incumbrance within the meaning of sec. 161 of the Bengal Tenancy Act which can only be annulled by a notice served in accordance with the provisions of sec. 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act.
This takes me to the question whether the notice served upon the Defendants was a valid one. The lower Appellate Court has held that it was not a valid one inasmuch as the application for the notice was made more than a year after the confirmation of the sale in favour of the purchaser at the certificate sale. The learned Judge has held that there is no evidence to show that the original purchaser had no notice of this incumbrance or that his knowledge of the incumbrance was within one year of the application of the Plaintiff for the service of the notice on the Defendants. In my opinion, the learned Subordinate Judge is quite correct in his view regarding the validity of the notice. Mr. Sen on behalf of the Respondent contends that the learned Subordinate Judge was not right in going into this question at all inasmuch as this question was not considered by the trial Court, and inasmuch as the Defendants did not challenge the validity of the notice. He relies on the fact that in the issues originally framed there was no issue regarding the validity of the notice. He suggests that if the appeal succeeds against the Plaintiff on other points, there should be a remand so that the Plaintiff may show that the application for notice under sec. 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act was made within a year of the knowledge of the original purchaser of the existence of the incumbrance. I have given this matter my anxious consideration, but I am unable to accept the suggestion of Mr. Sen regarding a remand. The question whether the notice was a valid one or not was raised in the written statement. There it was said that the notice was not served and alternatively that it was invalid by reason of the fact that it was not served within the time required by the law. I find from the judgment of the trial Court also that the question whether the notice was served within the time provided by law was raised there. I quote a portion of the judgment of the trial Court which appears at page 12 of the Paper-book. This is what the learned Munsif says:
“The defendants next contended that even if they have no protected interest in the suit land, their interest in the suit land is an incumbrance as defined in section 161 of the Bengal Tenancy Act and as such incumbrance has not been legally annulled by any service of notice under section 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act within the period of limitation the plaintiffs are not entitled to evict them from the suit land.”
In the earlier part of the judgment there is an issue. This is issue No. 7 and it is in these terms:
“Were notices under section 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act duly served upon the defendants?”
It is quite clear that in the trial Court the question of the validity of the notice was considered and in considering the question of the validity of the notice the point whether the application for the notice was made within the time stipulated in sec. 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, was also raised and considered. The learned trial Court, however, went wrong in his decision on this point. It held that as the notice was served within one year from the date of the Plaintiff's purchase, the service was a good one. This is obviously wrong as a reference to the provisions of sec. 167 will show. It is stated there that the application to the Court or to the Revenue Officer for the service of the notice must be made within a year from the date of the confirmation of the sale or the date on which the purchaser at such sale had notice of the incumbrance. It does not matter when the Plaintiff purchased the property from the original purchaser. The time for the application for service of the notice will begin to run from the date of the confirmation of the sale held under the certificate or from the date of knowledge of the purchaser at the certificate sale of the existence of the incumbrance. If the Defendant are under-raiyats, then here can be no doubt that the notice upon them was bad and did not have the effect of annulling the incumbrance. Thus the question whether the notice was in time was raised and considered by the trial Court and there can be no ground for a remand. The notice is obviously out of time and consequently if the interest of the Defendants in the property is an incumbrance, the Plaintiff cannot get possession as the incumbrance has not been annulled.
Mr. Sen on behalf of the Plaintiff Respondent argued that so far as the Defendant No. 15 was concerned, he was shown to be an under-raiyat of the second grade, that is to say, he was an under-raiyat under an under-raiyat. Such an interest, Mr. Sen says, is not an incumbrance within the meaning of sec. 161 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. This argument, as was pointed out by Mr. Gupta, is a suicidal one. If the Defendant No. 15 is an under-raiyat of the second grade he cannot be ejected until the under-raiyati above him has been annulled and there is no evidence to show that there was such an annulment. There is, therefore, no sub-stance in the argument of Mr. Sen that the Plaintiff can get a decree for ejectment against the Defendant No. 15 as his interest does not constitute an incumbrance.
The next branch of Mr. Sen's argument is that the Defendants are not under-raiyats and they came on the land originally as trespassers and remained as trespassers. He argued that the record-of-rights is incorrect. He says further that this question has not been properly considered by the lower Appellate Court for the decision of the question whether the Defendants are under-raiyat or not. He says that the lower Appellate Court has decided this case on hypothetical facts without arriving at definite findings regarding the facts. He says that the case should be sent back for a definite finding whether the Defendants are under-raiyats or not. Here again, I am not able to accept the suggestion of Mr. Sen. The settlement record is against his contentions. It shows that the Defendants of groups I and III are under-raiyats and that the Defendant of Group II is an under-raiyat of the second grade. The Court has accepted the record as being correct in this respect and it has not been shown to me that there is any clear evidence anywhere given to the effect that these Defendants came to the land originally as trespassers without any legal right to be on the land. It seems tome that the parties proceeded in the lower Appellate Court on the footing that the entries regarding the status of the Defendants in the record-of-rights were correct. In these circumstances I do not think I would be justified in remanding the case. The Plaintiff prayed for a declaration of his title to the land in suit. His title has not been challenged and it is declared.
I hold that the interest of the Defendants is an incumbrance within the meaning of sec. 161 of the Bengal Tenancy Act and this incumbrance has not been annulled by reason of the fact that the notice which was required to be served on the Defendants under sec. 167 of the Bengal Tenancy Act was an invalid notice inasmuch as it was not applied for within the time stipulated in the above-mentioned section. In these circumstances the decree of the Court below must be modified and the Plaintiff's suit in so far as it relates to ejectment must be dismissed with costs throughout. The Appellants will get the costs of this appeal.
P.C
Alert