- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mohan Bashi Podder v. Bilat Ali
The Judgment of the Court was as follows:—
These analogous appeals arise out of two rent suits heard together in the Courts below and disposed of by the same judgment. The Plaintiffs are the Same in both the suits but the Defendants are different.
In R.S 135 of 1937 the Plaintiffs claimed rent for the years 1342 and 1343 B.S at the annual jama of Rs. 37-6-6 pies and in R.S 136 of 1937 they claimed rent for the same period at the annual jama of Rs. 5-5-6 pies.
The defence was that the annual jamas were Rs. 31-8 and Rs. 4-8 respectively and that the rents for the period in suit had been paid off.
At the trial it was admitted on behalf of the Plaintiffs that the original jamas were Rs. 31-8 and Rs. 4-8 as asserted by the Defendants but it was alleged that these jamas were enhanced amicably in 1334 B.S and rent was realised at the enhanced rate since that date.
The learned Munsif found that as the enhancement was at the rate of three annas in the rupee it was in contravention of sec. 29(b) of the Bengal Tenancy Act and consequently could not be recovered “even if in these two cases the Defendants had agreed to the enhancement.”
He accordingly held that the original jamas of Rs. 31-8 and Rs. 4-8 still subsisted and after taking into account the excess payments made by the Defendants since the year 1334 B.S made a decree for Rs. 7 only in suit No. 135 of 1937 and for annas fourteen and pies six only in Suit No. 136 of 1937.
From the said decision the Plaintiffs appealed before the District Judge but were unsuccessful. They then preferred the present appeals.
The main point that has been argued before me on behalf of the Appellants is that the Courts below were in error in re-opening the question of payment since the year 1334 B.S and in deducting the excess sum realised by the Plaintiffs from their claim in suit.
It is to be noticed that counterfoil rent receipts Exs. A to A(2) filed by the Defendants themselves, clearly show that payments were made at the rate claimed by the Plaintiffs and that rents were cleared and paid off till 1341 B.S
This, to my mind, excludes any possibility of a running account existing between the parties which could be reopened in the manner in which it has been done by the Court below. The nature of relationship and the course of dealing between the parties militate against the case of accountability; in any event, no issue regarding liability to render account was framed in the suits. The sums that were realised in the previous years were towards the arrears of rent for those years and not towards any arrears for the years in suit, although the realisations were in excess of what was legally recoverable as rent.
In these circumstances I do not think it is open to the Defendants to demand a deduction of the illegal realisations made by the Plaintiff during a period of nearly seven years, from their claim for rent in the present suit. Reference in this connection may be made to the case of Vyravan Chetty v. Srimath Deivasikamani Nataraja Desikar (1).
The appeals are accordingly allowed to this extent only that the order for deduction on account of excess payments made by the Defendants is set aside. The decision of the Court below in other respects is upheld.
There will be no order for costs of the appeals in this Court.
C.C
Alert