Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Emperor v. Daulat Raibhan

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Apr 12, 1947

1. This is a reference by Mr. J.R Mudhoik ar, Sessions Judge, West Berar Division Akola, in Cri. Revn. No. 103 of 1946 on his file.

2. The order which the learned Sessions Judge recommends should be set aside concerns an award of a maintenance allowance of Rs. 20 per month granted to the non-applicant 2 under Section 488 of the Cr PC.

3. The wife was living separate from her husband and the question was whether she had sufficient reason for refusing to live with her husband. The wife urged two grounds for refusing to live with her husband.

4. The first was cruelty. The learned Magistrate did not consider that ground sufficient inasmuch as he says nothing about it in his order. He bases his order on the second ground. This ground was that the husband was impotent and unable to perform his marital duties. The learned Magistrate thought this to be a sufficient ground for the wife to live separate from her husband.

5. No authority has been cited before me in support of the case of the wife that she is entitled to live separate from her husband on account of his impotence. Reliance was placed on some old texts of Hindu law and the analogy of some civil cases was cited. Reliance was placed on A.I.R 1922 Mad. 399,1 A.I.R 1936 Mad. 6092 and A.I.R 1936 Bom. 138.3

6. As against these learned counsel for the husband contended that the present law on the subject does not take this into account. He referred to Act 19 [XIX] of 1946, and refers to Ss. 444 and 655 of Mulla's Hindu Law (1946 Edn.). He also contends that this is the first case in which such a claim has been urged.

7. I have been unable to find a single case in which such a claim was put forward by the wife. There is nothing to prove that under the circumstances mentioned is this case a wife is entitled to live apart from her husband and claim maintenance under Section 488 of the Cr PC. It is open to me to take this fact into account. Courts in India have not been called upon to examine this question at any time and it is fair to assume that had such a ground been thought good it would have been urged are this.

8. In my opinion the real reason why such a ground was never urged before this, is that Section 488 of the Cr PC, is a summary proceeding. A husband must prima facie support his wife. This he can do by making her share his board and house. If he does not, then the wife has right to be maintained by him. Ordinarily the husband's bona fide willingness to maintain his wife would be a sufficient answer to the petition. Circumstances may arise when the Court may consider that it would not be proper for the wife live with her husband and then the wife may be permitted to live separate and yet claim maintenance. All such grounds have reference to the comfort and safety of the wife. They have no bearing upon conjugal relations except in so far as such relations are rendered unsafe for the wife. In my opinion the failure to discharge the marital obligations by reason of impotence is not a good ground. Conjugal relations are hardly relevant to the order for maintenance under Section 488 of the Cr PC. I am fortified in this view by the observations of Burn, J., in 56 Mad. 913,4 at p. 914:

“I cannot see that Section 488 of the Cr PC, hag anything to do with ordinary conjugal rights; it deals with ‘maintenance’ only….”

9. In that case the wife insisted that she should be treated as a member of the family with a right to live in the family house. It was held that she was not entitled to be treated as a ‘wife’ but only to be maintained. Separate maintenance was accordingly refused.

10. I, therefore, accept the reference and set aside the order of maintenance passed by the trial Court.

11. Reference accepted.