Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Laxmi Bank Ltd. v. Harikisan

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Oct 7, 1947

1. This is a revision by defendants 1 and 3 in Civil suit No. 2B of 1946 pending in the Court of the Additional District Judge, Khamgaon, against the order of that Court refusing to stay the suit pending the decision of First Appeal No. 18 of 1945 pending in the High Court.

2. In order to appreciate correctly the subject-matter of this revision it is necessary to state facts in detail. ‘Sitaram Bindraban’ a partnership firm at Khamgaon (hereafter called a firm) dealt in cotton, cottonseed etc. and it also carried on business as adtiya and commission agents for purchases and sales of these articles for its constituents and it also financed its constituents in their transactions. Harikisan was one of the constituents of the firm and he did cotton business in the adat of the firm between 14-8-1942 and 21-3-1943. The business consisted inter alia of purchase of 496 bales of cotton through the pakki adat of the firm which also financed Harikisan. Harikisan agreed to pay interest, adat, brokerage and loss, if any, to the firm. It is alleged that the bales were in the custody of the firm by way of security for money advanced for purchasing the bales until these bales were sold by Harikisan to the firm from time to time until 6-3-1943. As he suffered loss in this and other businesses carried on through the adat of the firm he was unable to repay the amount due from him to the firm. As Harikisan failed to satisfy his liability to the firm, the latter instituted against Harikisan and others civil Suit No. 6-B of 1918 and claimed Rs. 12,868-2-9 as a result of all the dealings between Harikisan and the firm or through the adat of the firm. Subsequently, the firm also instituted another suit—Civil Suit No. 7-B of 1943 against Harikisan for recovery of Rs. 15,202-4-0 which was realised from the firm on a hundi dated 12th February 1943 drawn in favour of Laxmi Bank by Harikisan and in which the firm was the drawee. These two suits were consolidated and the claim of the firm was decreed on 22nd September 1944 for Rs. 17,216-3-0. The firm has filed an appeal against the dismissal of a part of its claim and it is pending as First Appeal No. 38 of 1945 in the High Court. On 6th March 1946, Harikisan instituted civil Suit No. 2-B of 1946 against Laxmi Bank, Kisanlal, the Sub-agent of Laxmi Bank and the firm Sitaram Bindraban at Khamgaon for recovery of Rs. 57,094-7-0, made up of Rs. 45,358 as the price of 250 bales of cotton on 22nd April 1943 or by way of damages and Rs. 11,736-7-0 as interest thereon at 9 per cent, per annum. In this suit Harikisan alleged that as on 17th September 1942 the firm ‘Sitaram Bindraban’ pressed Harikisan for a substantial repayment he applied for a loan of Rs. 14,000 from the Laxmi Bank on the security of his bales of cotton and it was granted to him under the hypothecation bond dated 17 September 1942. According to the bond 250 out of 496 bales were pawned with the Bank and delivered in its custody and the Bank paid Rs. 14,000 to the firm by a cheque for Rs. 14,000. The price of cotton began to go up and Harikisan wanted the Bank to allow him to redeem the 250 bales pawned by him with the Bank. It was after much delay on 22nd April 1943 that the reply was received from the Bank that these bales were pawned not by Harikisan but by the firm through its managing partner and that the pawn was already redeemed in March 1943. Harikisan, therefore, filed on 6th March 1946 civil Suit No. 2B of 1946 as already stated above.

3. Defendants 1 and 3 contended in civil Suit No. 2-B of 1946 that the trial of the suit should be stayed till the decision of First Appeal No. 18 of 1945 and this was the subject-matter of issue 16 framed by the lower Court. The lower Court treated this as a preliminary issue and rejected the prayer for stay by its order dated 15th January 1947. Defendants 1 and 3 seek to have this order revised.

4. The prayer for stay was mainly based on the ground that in Civil Suit No. 6-B of 1943 between the firm as plaintiff and Harikisan as one of the defendants the question about the ownership of the 250 bales pledged with the Laxmi Bank was agitated and it formed the subject-matter of issue 13 in that suit. The trial Court answered this issue against the plaintiff, e.g, the firm. It held that 250 bales belonged not to the firm but to Harikisan and they were pledged by Harikisan. The claim of the firm to that extent was disallowed, and the firm is now agitating that question in First Appeal No. 13 of 1945 before the High Court. In the present suit, i.e, Civil Suit No. 2-B of 1946, the sole question in dispute is that which was covered by issue 13 in the previously instituted suit, civil Suit No. 6-B of 1943 and which is now the subject matter of First Appeal No. 18 of 1945.

5. It is clear from the order of the lower Court that it has misdirected itself on very vital points resulting in the refusal to exercise jurisdiction or acting in the exercise of jurisdiction with material irregularity. Evidently, the learned Judge has misunderstood and misapplied the decision in A.I.R 1935 Mad. 112.1 According to that decision the subject-matter of the subsequent suit must be covered by the previously instituted suit and not the vice versa. It is obvious that the subject-matter of civil suit No. 2-B of 1946 is covered completely by civil suit No. 6-B of 1943 but the lower Court somehow misapprehended the correct position under a wrong belief that according to the ruling the subject-matter of the two suits should be in every respect identical. The lower Court thus acted in the exercise of its jurisdiction under Section 10 of the CPC, with material irregularity. Further the lower Court denied to itself the jurisdiction to stay the suit under Section 151 of the CPC, by misunderstanding the decision in I.L.R (1941) 1 Cal. 373.2 The lower Court failed to see that in that case the learned Judges of the Calcutta High Court have discussed the scope and the application of the inherent powers of the Court now recognized in Section 151 of the CPC, and these powers are open to the High Court and to the subordinate Court alike. This resulted in the non-exercise of jurisdiction which the lower Court had under Section 151 of the Code i.e, apart from Section 10 of the CPC, in suitable cases. In the unreported judgment passed by this Court in second appeal No. 395 of 1946 it is held that a subsequently instituted suit could be stayed under Section 151 of the CPC, even though Section 10 of the Code may not strictly apply. The same view is taken in A.I.R 1929 Lah. 123 and A.I.R 1947 Lah. 28.4 Even before the Code of 1908 which gave a statutory recognition to the inherent powers of a Court such a power was recognized as appears from 17 ALL. 29,5 33 Cal. 9276 and other cases. In 33 Cal. 927 Woodroffe J. observed:

“Law cannot make express provisions against all inconveniences, and that the Court bad, therefore, in many cases where the circumstances warranted it, and the necessities of the case required it, acted upon the assumption of the possession of an inherent power to act ex debito justitiae and to do that real and substantial justice for the administration of which it alone exists”.

6. These observations are cited with approval in I.L.R (1941) 1 Cal. 4907 and I.L.R (1940) ALL. 201.8

7. According to Section 10 of the CPC, the Court is forbidden from proceeding with the trial of a suit when the matter in issue in the subsequent suit is directly in issue in the previously instituted suit between the same parties or between the parties under whom they or any of them claimed under the same title where the suit is pending in British India having jurisdiction to grant the relief. It is not disputed that all the requirements of S. 10, are satisfied so far as the firm and Harikisan are concerned and as against Harikisan the suit is liable to be stayed. It is however contended that the suit cannot be stayed so far as defendants 1 and 2 are concerned as they were not parties to the previously instituted suit. It is true that so far as defendants 1 and 2 are concerned the subsequently instituted suit cannot be said to be a parallel suit as the findings in First Appeal No. 18 of 1945 would not operate as res judicata as held in 61 Cal. 6709 and A.I.R 1942 Bom. 314,10 but a finding regarding the ownership of the firm and its right of redemption of 250 bales which would be binding between the firm and Harikisan would have a material bearing so far as the suit between Harikisan and defendants 1 and 2 is concerned. Thus even if Section 10 of the CPC, does not as such apply, the circumstances of this case, the interest of justice and the balance of convenience justify the staying of the entire suit as against all the defendants. On the other hand, serious complications may arise if the suit is allowed to proceed.

8. It is doubtful if for the application of Section 10 of the CPC, there should be a complete identity of parties or a complete identity of the subject-matter. Such a view would furnish a handle to the unscrupulous litigants to escape from the operation of S. 10 by adding some formal party who was not a party in the previously instituted suit or add some nominal relief not covered by the previous suit. It is enough as pointed out in the exhaustive commentary on Section 10 of the CPC, by Chitaley and Annaji Rao that there should be a substantial identity of parties in the two suits. The same applies to the subject-matter.

9. The learned counsel for the non-applicant relied on 48 Bom. L.R 63311 which lays down the undisputed proposition that all the issues in the subsequent suit should be covered by the previously instituted suit. The decision in I.L.R (1945) Nag. 63412 is also to the same effect. Finally I hold that the lower Court should have stayed the trial of civil suit No. 2-B of 1946 under Section 10 read with Section 151 of the CPC, and I order accordingly. The revision is allowed with costs. Counsel's fee Rs. 30.

10. Revision allowed.